so am i 12 or 40 then atavan

criticizing people's 5s pretty edgy

fair enough, but Amy Winehouse? really?

"criticizing people's 5s pretty edgy"



Not really, seeems to happen fairly often here


Also I don't know how to properly quote 'round here

don't you get it? He's calling you eternal; timeless

forgot you can't convey tone over the intertubes

this is all funny to me

you're the angry dad here man

let's kiss

i'm genuinely amazed you hate all of the acts you mentioned in my 5s list though

like, obviously everyone hates kanye

but like ttng is such an obscure thing to hate

found that kind of interesting

yeah it happens often which makes me sad for the userbase

that's the great thing about music i guess

i mean i wouldn't rate this lp higher than a 3/3.5 but there you are

find your love and all that

thats a reason to 5 something

listening to this now its pretty fucking dope, would be a good stoned listen

Album Rating: 4.0

80s REM is pretty boss silent not sure if you've heard em. They were like the first big alt rock band I think. I wouldnt 5 em but they had some real good shit.

also its ridiculous how much the singer sounds like john lennon, my only gripe so far

Album Rating: 4.0

Honestly everything I have rated over a 4 is pretty much the same to me. I havent even been rating shit lately tho because its just become kinda stupid since music to me is basically just if I like it or if I dont. Ratings are helpful to maybe separate things more than that but Im lazy. I might just get all mine wiped we'll see stay tuned.

5s are very special to me, only my most favourite albums of them all get to be 5'd

but i'm probaly just an autist so yeah

objective classics lol

i get what he means, besides "classic" is a bit of a silly ranking for a personal choice innit?

Album Rating: 4.0

Yea they really should change the meaning of 5s because "classic" is just dumb.

who cares


if it's a 5 it's a 5

i get what he means too but the idea is sort of dumb. what's wrong with the word classic? if an album is classic to me then i will rate it a 5

Album Rating: 4.0

because rating an album that like just came out a classic seems stupid. classics usually have to prove their classicness over time. there are hundreds of classics to me but I wouldnt rate them all 5s.