Album Rating: 3.5

Lol sowing

Album Rating: 4.0

Im not a Mastodon fanboy, but this shit rocks man. A double album as well - very impressive. Covid done some bands good.

Album Rating: 4.0

All songs are solid for me, but if I had to pick the best here it would end up something like this:

1. Pain With An Anchor

2. The Crux

3. More Than I Could Chew

4. Teardrinker

5. Dagger

6. Had It All

7. Savage Lands

8. Gobblers Of Dregs

9. Eyes of Serpents

10. Gigantium

Album Rating: 4.0

Brann's drumming in Peace and Tranquility is just RAW. That snappy snare tone sounds so good.

Album Rating: 3.0 | Sound Off

Finished disc 1, Pain With an Anchor, The Crux, and Pushing the Tides are the highlights so far. This is shaping up to be a really solid record. Let's hope disc 2 is as good as the first.

I can't rate it yet, more time is needed, but god man the polish on the production is killing me a bit. It definitely refines the emotion in a way where it's less impactful than it wants to be. And I don't like Bran taking the mantle as the vocalist so much. It gives it just too much of an accessible milt rock vibe where it's hard to love it as much as I want to. I love this band but I still think everything after their first four LP's is less than their best.

Album Rating: 4.5

This is great but I just went back and jammed crack the sky and I realize why I didnt 5 this. Cause Sky will always be the 5 in their discog.

Album Rating: 5.0

Yeah Skye is top tier but this may be the second best. Mainly because they somehow managed to provide quantity AND quality all within a refreshing package. God damn do I love these guys.

Album Rating: 4.5

Album Rating: 2.0



Remission >



Leviathan >



Blood Mountain >



Crack the Skye >



who cares the rest suck







(Once More Round the Sun is a hair better than the rest but still eh 🤷🏼‍♂️)





Sorry bro but this is a straight up shit horrible opinion.

OMRTS is the worst mastodon yh

Album Rating: 4.0

I think my current ranking would look like this now:



Remission - 4.6

Leviathan - 4.5

Crack the Skye - 4.3

Blood Mountain - 4.1

Hushed and Grim - 4

Emperor of Sand - 3.8

Once More 'Round the Sun - 3.5

The Hunter - 3

Album Rating: 4.0

time for album rankings it seems... hmhmhmhmh



Blood Mountain

Crack the Skye

Remission

Leviathan

Hush Hush Hushed and Grim

Emperor of Sand

The Hunter

Once more round the Sun

Album Rating: 3.5

Leviathan

Crack the Skye



Blood Mountain



power gap



Remission

Hushed and Grim (was good at first listen! shall hit it a few more times and see how I feel)



power gap



The Hunter



ONCEOLKJHNSADKJFNBLMDSUN

Album Rating: 4.0

This is interesting tbh. I always thought The Hunter was usually regarded as their worst by the fanbase

the Hunter got more flack because CtS is a fan fav; OMRTS benefitted from a little bit of the classic critical "at least it's not another disappointment" see-saw that comes literally time after a band follow a polarising-ish album with an apologetic safe one, but this didn't go that far because it's not very good

Album Rating: 4.0

I can see that. I wasn't a fan of Mastodon at the time The Hunter came out, but I could definitely imagine it disappointing people when it came out. Kinda makes me wonder how Once More would've been received if it came directly after CtS

Album Rating: 5.0

Hunter>Once More

Album Rating: 3.0 | Sound Off

I still flinch whenever somebody mentions The Hunter

Album Rating: 4.0

I like The Hunter, first half is full of bangers, second half... not so much



OMATS tho... I still like it anyway, I don't really despise anything made by this band

Album Rating: 4.5 | Sound Off

It’s the Curl Of The Burl.