John Williams Star Wars, Episode I: The Phantom Menace
» Back to review

Comments:Add a Comment 
LotusFlower
July 5th 2016


12000 Comments


Also super jealous alex

CaliggyJack
July 5th 2016


10965 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

As in, with the original emperor make-up and all?



I mean, I love the sequels, but... George did the right thing in having Ian McDiarmind edit himself into the old movies for future DVD releases. The hologram dude in 4 was god-awful and the make-up effects in 5 and 6 were just... eeeewwww

LotusFlower
July 5th 2016


12000 Comments


That's why I said at least one of the edits before he went crazy with all the CGi add ins or scene changes

CaliggyJack
July 5th 2016


10965 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

There are certain edits that I think are justified. The Emperor being one, and replacing old yoda with new. Some others... not so much.



What was did I want to say...



Oh yeah



Fuck you RedLetterMedia and fuck you plinkett.

LotusFlower
July 5th 2016


12000 Comments


Pinklett's review is better than 90% of the movies

CaliggyJack
July 5th 2016


10965 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Plinkett is that you?

LotusFlower
July 5th 2016


12000 Comments


Totally yeah, because what I'm saying is an unpopular opinion for sure

CaliggyJack
July 5th 2016


10965 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

I is still the best Star Wars.



To be frank though, the sequel series is equally as bad as the prequels but for completely different reasons.

CaliggyJack
July 5th 2016


10965 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

@Angry



No



No he does not.

LotusFlower
July 5th 2016


12000 Comments


Not at all, the original has issues, but they're infinently better movies for so many different reasons. Even beyond story telling. Also o thought you were joking about 1 being the best, wtf?

LotusFlower
July 5th 2016


12000 Comments


Pinklett has a passion for the movies and I love seeing in depth literary analysis, even if it was mostly for the story than anything else.

CaliggyJack
July 5th 2016


10965 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

I don't want to hear his festering BS



Hence why I won't be watching it, I'll simply sit as my friends shove his vids into my face again ad fucking nauseum.



Also Clover



Agree to Disagree

LotusFlower
July 5th 2016


12000 Comments


How is what he says festering bs? Does it just boil down to "I like it he doesn't" or...

CaliggyJack
July 5th 2016


10965 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

I do like it and he doesn't, but I also heavily disagree with some of criticisms. I also heavily disagree with a lot of his praises for the sequels.



Also, I don't find him funny, just annoying.

LotusFlower
July 5th 2016


12000 Comments


Ah, fair enough. I can watch anyone praise or tear into something when they have the passion or the depth for it, so I liked watching his prequel review because it helped place a lot of the issues I had with it squarely.

zaruyache
July 5th 2016


28714 Comments


"I is still the best Star Wars."

wait you like Phantom the most? yyyyyyyyyyyyy

CaliggyJack
July 5th 2016


10965 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

I wouldn't hate Plinkett's rev so much if it didn't cause this giant uproar of Phantom Menace hating bandwagoners. He turned hating Episode I into a meme, where people hated the fucking movie because it was popular to hate it.



Other than his crappy humor, I suppose there is nothing inherently wrong with his vids.



Also Zary. There is a whole list of reasons.

zaruyache
July 5th 2016


28714 Comments


chief reason "Bad taste"??????????????????????????????????????????????? Or you're allergic to A New Hope's goodnessness???

AlexKzillion
Emeritus
July 5th 2016


19110 Comments


Everything CalligyJack has said the past two pages either untrue or just a very contrarian opinion lol.

CaliggyJack
July 5th 2016


10965 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

The Room was designed as a satirical black comedy. 90% of reviewers, including RLM, completely missed this and just assumed it was a poorly made thriller.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy