Album Rating: 4.2

This is at the least better than Kid A

Album Rating: 3.5

How about no

Album Rating: 3.0

lol hell. fucking. no. this sounds like generic alt rock compared to kid a, which, despite being way more experimental, is way catchier than anything on here. i don't dislike this album. it's enjoyable to throw on in the background, but i can't think of many memorable moments.

Album Rating: 3.0

identikit, burn the witch, desert island, decks dark, the numbers... how do these songs go again? i've heard them each like 5 times but they're so unmemorable

identikit is their least memorable song since the tourist

Album Rating: 3.0

i'm inclined to agree with that statement

Album Rating: 4.2

Burn the Witch if anything is the biggest standout on this thing

Album Rating: 5.0

Yeah it's in the top half for me.

I totally understand why this wouldn't be everyone's favorite album, because imo it seems crafted for a specific type of person. The way everything is dream-like and reverby with lots of repeat effects like the vocals in Present Tense gets very close to how my mind deals with sound, making this a very personal experience for me. This album best mirrors the way I experience the world, sensory-wise and emotionally, of the band's discography, so it's kind of hard for me not to love it.

Album Rating: 4.5

Beautiful statement

Sometimes when I listen to this I think that these guys are getting better. Sometimes I think they're just as good as before. I'll have my answer the next time they make an album.