Ethereal Shroud They Became the Falling Ash
» Back to review

Comments:Add a Comment 
burningbeard
September 4th 2015


155 Comments


Apologies for the delay. Try as I might I can't find a message on Bandcamp. Happy for you to ship 'as is' unless you need anything more from me.

Cheers.

DarkNoctus
September 4th 2015


12213 Comments


i sent you a message on here, on your profile, heh

i just need to know your first name so i know which order is yours [:

burningbeard
September 4th 2015


155 Comments


OK, sorry for the misunderstanding. I've put a note on your page on here.

Cheers.

SharkTooth
September 11th 2015


14922 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

Best comment I've read in a long time

DarkNoctus
September 11th 2015


12213 Comments


actually i rate everything on this album 'fairly' ie based on how i like it and i would encourage everyone else to do the same, so if you hate this then power to you but if you're downrating this just to make some strange point then... well, i can't stop you. the idea i do it to make my own album look better, though? that's utterly ridiculous.

oh and just for the sake of numbers, i have wayyyyy more albums highly rated than lowly rated. i use the rating scale as fairly as possible - if i hate something, it's awful. if i love it, it's superb/classic and anything between. you really don't have to respect my opinion about liking and disliking certain albums. i honestly do not care, and you shouldn't either as it's completely arbitrary to care about what some other person thinks about an album you like.

"endless albums" i think i have about 120 albums on this website lowly rated. you know, out of 1308 ratings. which means that over 90% of my ratings are neutral/positive ratings, most of which are positive. you really don't have a leg to stand on by accusing me of rating shit lowly on purpose. that's less than 10%. as for 1.0 being a 'darknoctus' rating, funny how it's the least common rating i give...

thank you for your time.

Asdfp277
September 11th 2015


24408 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

the edge

emester
September 11th 2015


8271 Comments


lmao

zaruyache
September 11th 2015


27473 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

noctus prob gave the guy's solo project a bad rating on RYM so he's here to vent loool

Alastor
September 11th 2015


2151 Comments


man, that dude is bitter.

Serenityinaz12
September 11th 2015


134 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

I haven't been around as long as some of you but from what I've seen it's pretty accurate though what dude says, lol. I don't think there has been a single release I've seen that consistently gets a lot of 4's and aboves without a Noctus 1.5, 2 or 2.5 to match it. I just see that if it's low rated by him it's probably actually a good release. Well, black metal anyway not sure how he rates other genres.

zaruyache
September 11th 2015


27473 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

idk he's got a 90% objectivity score. that mean's his ratings are spread out pretty well, doesn't it? I'm still fuzzy on what that and what "Rating Variance" actually mean on this site.

Serenityinaz12
September 11th 2015


134 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

not sure, maybe they are spread out - but just my experience is seeing generally high rated releases pretty low rated by him, almost always. Not sure what his high scores are for.

Valkyrion
September 11th 2015


1161 Comments


perhaps they're better albums than the ones he rates low :]

DarkNoctus
September 11th 2015


12213 Comments


feel free to listen to what i rate highly and make your own judgement

i have like, hundreds upon hundreds of albums a 3.5 or above for you to peruse if you're at all interested in my high ratings. not sure why you would be...

I don't think there has been a single release I've seen that consistently gets a lot of 4's and aboves without a Noctus 1.5, 2 or 2.5 to match it. I just see that if it's low rated by him it's probably actually a good release. Well, black metal anyway not sure how he rates other genres.


maybe it's just not my taste? i mean, i wouldn't argue against someone not liking this because it's not their taste, that's how a music rating website works...

that said, almost ALL of my high rated albums are universally high rated so i don't know where on earth this criticism is coming from

DarkNoctus
September 11th 2015


12213 Comments


actually decided to have a look and the most common rating i give is a 3.5, meaning 'great'

i really cannot fathom why people think my rating system is unfair when the majority of my ratings are positive

and even then, why the hell does it matter?

anyway, if you want to have a dispute with me about ratings i'd prefer it on my profile page. this really should be discussion about the review or the shitty tunes i made in my bedroom with a broken guitar. thanks.

zaruyache
September 11th 2015


27473 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

i was gonna write a thing but forget it, it isn't worth trying to clarify why the angry dude is silly :3



so I'll just say hey joe you know that supr obscvre postrock band Johnnytwentythree that you like that I totally didn't find by stalking you yeah I tracked down their CD and it's pretty good thanks for that. 8|

DarkNoctus
September 11th 2015


12213 Comments


jxxiii is so good

a good friend of mine from cincinnati, their hometown, showed me them and i fell in love with it

BMDrummer
September 12th 2015


15134 Comments


this thread is great, i should probably listen to this

yuneek
September 12th 2015


306 Comments

Album Rating: 1.0

JUSTIIIIIIIICEEEEEEEE

Gameofmetal
Emeritus
September 12th 2015


11604 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

savage



didnt you say you didnt finish the first track



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy