Really can't argue with that

Album Rating: 4.0

Agree with adolf

Album Rating: 4.5

mechanical hand is my fav htb tbh but yea this wins no contest

Album Rating: 4.5

You guys are forgetting about Calculating Infinity though. But as for HTB I would agree Mechanical Hand is best

Album Rating: 4.0

Desperate Living is like 100 times better than Mechanical Hand. I gotta finally write a review for it

Album Rating: 4.5

Oh it's definitely dope but Mechanical Hand is as well

Album Rating: 4.5

desperate livings ok but quees a little too much for my taste

Album Rating: 4.5

ha i can see what you're sayin but the songwriting is pretty dank on it.



oh and back to best metalcore i totally forgot about possibly my top contender, Misery Signals - Controller, how could i fucking forget that masterpiece

Album Rating: 4.5

This shit fucking pulverizes. Found about these guys and Catharsis in the same night. Metalcore was just such a strong, stacked genre in the 90s.

Album Rating: 4.0

Catharsis jams.

setting fire to sink

Album Rating: 4.0

Coalesce is best core to me now

Album Rating: 5.0

ur insane



they gd but

Album Rating: 4.0

I dunno man i listen to a lot of core they have just slowly risen to the tippity top



Botch are probs second

Album Rating: 5.0

converge simply cant be topped if you lump them in the metalcore genre



like people can argue EHDWDWJN EVERYONE SAYS THAT ok no band in metalcore has a discog filled with as much quality



jane doe, petitioning, crashing, fail me, poacher diaries, unloved/weeded out, axe



botch has like 3 releases two of which are very good one thats outstanding



coalesce has two great albs and some lame ones



converge has one of the best albums of all time



idk dillinger, knut, cave in, 7a7p, beecher, botch and maybe rorscach have made the best stuff in the genre in my view. I used to be HUGE on metalcore but it kinda grew off me, not enough unbelievable stuff compared to other metal genres



which is sad cause stylistically good real metalcore makes my heart weep

Album Rating: 4.0

I generally agree with everything youve said there except that the only converge albums that have ever blown me away are jane doe, you fail me and all we love. Their old stuff (90s stuff basically) is cool and all solid but none of it has ever really stuck with me.



And yeah Ox and Give them Rope by coalesce arent great but Functioning on Impatience has really grown on me recently, probably in my top 3 albums in general.



Dillinger wore off me hard, Challenger by Knut is solid but none of their other stuff is that great to me, 7A7P are cool but bore me a bit, Rorschach, KIG and Deadguy all rip, Cave in dont do much for me and Beecher are solid but not titan level



Metalcore is still my thing but tbh i really think ive run the well dry, if you have any obscure recs pls suggest them

Album Rating: 5.0

youve probs heard most of the obscure metalcore I have lol



idk man fair assesment but I never understood why when forever comes crashing is so undervalued. Their most thrashy/metalcore record, and brilliant songwriting. Absolutely dynamite



functioning on impatience is lit nation



yea knut's challenger is top 5 metalcore, they have one other worthwhile release the rest are a drag sadly



capsule's blue is a stunning obscure metalcore gem. I doubt you javent heard it, but if not check NOW

Album Rating: 4.5

i never really got into coalesce

Album Rating: 4.0

Yeah man ive heard Blue, good shit



Coalesce took ages to grow on me demi, give Functioning another try when you get the chance

Album Rating: 4.5

Coalesce is part of what I'd call the Big 5 in metalcore. With everyone in their prime, though, they're like the second to least good out of all of them. It's like 1. Converge 2. Botch/Dillinger(toss up) 3. Coalesce 4. Cave In. IMO, of course.