Album Rating: 4.5

Just got around to this and I now have a new fav Nick Cave album so far. This shit is so amazing.

Album Rating: 5.0

Easily the best Cave, agreed. It was my first album of his, rushed to the shop to buy the cassette after seeing Loverman on MTV. That video haunts me still.

Album Rating: 4.0

4th best after Good Son, Skeleton Tree & Henry but I do sometimes consider it up there with the latter

Album Rating: 3.5

This is second best after tender prey

Album Rating: 4.5

My ranking of what I've heard so far:



Let Love In (4.7)

The Firstborn is Dead (4.5)

The Good Son (4.3)

Tender Prey (4.3)

Ghosteen (4.2)

Your Funeral... My Trial (3.9)

From Her to Eternity (3.6)

Wild God (3.5)

Kicking Against the Pricks (2.7)

Henry's Dream (2.5)

Album Rating: 4.5

Slowly but surely making my way through the discog lol. Also damn Demon bro, Henry is easily my least fav so far. Needs some more listens but it did absolutely nothing for me on first couple jams. :[

Album Rating: 3.5

The first two songs on Henry are amazing god-tier seeds and everything after is straight up dog shit

Album Rating: 5.0

Nah, last two (Loom of the Land, Jack the Ripper) are among his best songs. But have to agree that I Had a Dream, Joe is my fave there, it’s puzzling why Cave neglects it from gigs.

Album Rating: 4.5

Last two + first two + John Finn's Wife + Brother My Cup are all vintage Bad Seeds and probably a marginally superior crop of highlights to those there, extremely L takes itt (but that's what you get when you jam half a giant discog in a week *shrug*)

Album Rating: 4.5

What does time frame have anything to do with it??? Lmao Johnny's ego blown up to the size of a blimp itt, shocker. Also have been jamming his discog over the course of a few months. But please tell me what time frame you think is appropriate so I can follow it like my life depended on it. Its always funny when people act like you need a certain and specific amount of time jamming an album before forming an opinion lmao.

I just wish you liked Your Funeral... My Trial and From Her to Eternity higher but you didn't bottom them so my ego semi-chillin'

Album Rating: 4.5

I love both of them just not as much as some others lol.

Album Rating: 4.5

lol in what universe would you not consider time, familiarity and reflection positive factors when it comes to forming an opinion (which yes, anyone can do with the benefit of even a cursory listen)

Goo Goo Dolls did it better

Album Rating: 4.5

When did I say it wasn't? You act like I need a certain amount of time to form an opinion. Maybe it will change in time but after 2 listens it does nothing for me. Sorry if that doesn't follow the Johnny logic lmao. Good for you if you dig it. This site gives staff titles to egotistical jackasses who can't get their heads out of their own anuses. Its like a cult if the cult was unpopular and occupied by 10 dudes who jerk off 12 times a day and have no idea how to talk to women.

Album Rating: 4.5

>You act like I need a certain amount of time to form an opinion

posted 200 whole pixels away from a comment where i said the exact opposite yes

>a cult if the cult was unpopular and occupied by 10 dudes who jerk off 12 times a day and have no idea how to talk to women.

i mean that perception would explain p perfectly how you've spent more time online thirsting over a contrib title than you have over your actual wife, but by all means carry on acting like a baby about it

Album Rating: 4.5

Johnny you say that because a woman loving you is a foreign concept to you. Also lol @ staff members making personal comments about users' wives. Real classy. Wonder why this site is going extinct.



I come into a thread to share my opinion, give a ranking and I get ridiculed with comments about how I rate and attacks on my personal life/wife. Its wild dude. Carry on. I'll go away.

Album Rating: 4.5

yes the site is definitely going extinct over your inability to take a dig without throwing a tantrum and not over the hideous loss of infrastructure it's sustained in the past two yrs

Album Rating: 4.5

A dig? You're talking about my wife. Which you would never do to my face so why do it here? You think you're cool because you're a staff member on the shittiest website of all time when in reality you're probably a soft boy that wears khaki shorts above your knees and drinks Whiteclaw.

Album Rating: 4.5

referring to the fact that you're married and speculating about your wife in any level of detail (which i have no intention of doing) are entirely different things, but you keep on throwing out punches you can't roll with. if you can't handle a "lol you're married and still act like ___" gag irl, you most defs aren't in a position to fingerpoint the rest of this site for shittiness