I feel like people are too overly critical of this album solely because Roger Waters was the focus and they wanted to see more Gilmore and Wright.
Yet this shouldn't be enough to call the album objectively bad. I mean, if there wasn't the history/popularity of Pink Floyd, if their previous albums didn't exist, and then you heard this, you are telling me you would just be like "meh thats ok pretty mediocre group."? Bullshit.
|
| |
Album Rating: 3.3
That's true, but it IS inferior
|
| |
To their other albums? Yeah. But this album is still better than any other rock i've heard from any
other group
|
| |
Album Rating: 3.3
The only major problem is the vocals, in THAT department it really needed more Gilmour and Wright BADLY
|
| |
agreed, the vocals on gilmour and wright tracks are much better on this album and others, but Gilmour and Wright couldn't have created the same grim atmosphere with their vocals.
|
| |
Album Rating: 3.3
Some tracks needed Roger yeah but a lot would've been better with Wright especially
Can you imagine Wright singing Nobody Home
like uuuugh
|
| |
you cant be serious?
I think Nobody Home is an example of perfectly fitting tone
or maybe i just liked the song enough to not notice
|
| |
Album Rating: 3.3
You don't get it Wright has one of my FAVOURITE VOICES EVER
|
| |
same with me but his voice is more uplifting and waters' fits better with such a depressing topic as Nobody Home
|
| |
Album Rating: 3.3
No way Wright has the most melancholy voice I've heard
|
| |
maybe you are right I often don't even know which one is singing tbh
lol
|
| |
don't get me wrong, this a spectacular and landmark record. In comparison though to DSotM, WYWH and Animals, this really
just can be in my top 3 floyd albums. Top 5 though? Definitely.
|
| |
Album Rating: 5.0
this >>> dsotm
please don't burn me for this
|
| |
Wtf?
|
| |
Album Rating: 5.0
nah
the wall is a good album and i'll always enjoy it but i fucking hate it at the same time
|
| |
naw man I can totally understand. Just imo Dark side is nealy untouchable. that is until WYWH and Animals came along
|
| |
Album Rating: 5.0
i never fell in love with dark side as a whole. time is a huge jam tho
|
| |
The assumption of people who hate the wall is that Gilmour could have had a lead role and created another classic album, i dunno, if he was so great why is none of his solo stuff classic (or is it I have never even heard it lol)?
|
| |
Album Rating: 4.5
Well, I think Division Bell is a classic, does it count?
I'm the only one that appreciates it though
|
| |
Album Rating: 4.0
Artuma be true to yourself m/
DTSOM is a little overrated agreed
|
| |
|
|
