Album Rating: 4.5

It'll burn a hole in you eventually, mark my words.

I was joking dbizzles

this is actually extremely amazing so far, like 4.5 easy so far

Great Oregon album too

Album Rating: 4.5

Nice one ALA

Love the ambient codas to some of the songs here

Fuck I need a good cry maybe I'll listen to this later.

dude yyyyyyyyyeeeeeeeeeesssssssssss the ambient parts kill me just as much as the actual music

they're so ethereal and sad but also so creepy in a way, it's really hard to explain

Fourth of July was almost too much. To bad i'm not much a crier(at least not easily)

Album Rating: 5.0

Re-listening to this now: bliss. May just say fuck it and go on a 5ing sesh today - this, Crazy on the Weekend and a couple of others look bump worthy

Album Rating: 4.5

I don't cry much either, especially not until I've known something for a long time. Pretty sure I've teared up to this before.

Honestly a good cry to music is can be really cathartic.

Album Rating: 4.5

ALA just wait till No Shade in the Shadow of the Cross and Blue Bucket of Gold

Album Rating: 5.0

"bliss. May just say fuck it and go on a 5ing sesh today"



Then what's preventing you from 5'ing it?

Album Rating: 5.0

Can't remember crying to music ever personally, though I know I've gotten close with this

Album Rating: 5.0

oh shit someone is hearing this for the first time?



i'm jelly

omg every time i think "Ok ... this is going to be the track that isn't a 5/5" the song changes up and i'm like 'Oh shit waddup'

Carrie and Lowell might have one of the most beautiful progressions

Album Rating: 5.0

@Calc I'm just a stingy 5er is all

Album Rating: 4.5

Ive started to tear up several times at concerts, it's embarrassing.

Album Rating: 5.0

@Asleep: I really dislike that line of thinking but fair enough. I surprisingly never cried to this.

I like being stingy with ratings

It helps people understand better just how greatly my fandom of something differs.

Album Rating: 5.0

@Calc How come? If an album is basically subjectively perfect for me thats a 4.5. If its something I've listened to for years and developed some sort of unquantifiable bound to (but I sure as hell know it when I feel it) then it goes up to a 5. Works for me, gives a 5 that special quality

Album Rating: 5.0

I've never cried to this (or any music, I think) but I can literally feel my heart sink every time I listen to this. It's downright depressing.

Album Rating: 4.5

There are probably only like 20 albums that have made me tear up, it's not exactly a common thing.

I started to lose it at a fucking Drive-By Truckers concert a few weeks ago lol

It's depressing but Fourth of July also has a slight comfort to it

Album Rating: 5.0

"@Calc How come? If an album is basically subjectively perfect for me thats a 4.5. If its something I've listened to for years and developed some sort of unquantifiable bound to (but I sure as hell know it when I feel it) then it goes up to a 5"

I can appreciate this. For my entire first year on this site I only had one 4.5 (TDAG) and only a handful of 4's. My perception at the time was that no album is perfect, and until I find maybe that 1 album (or 2 tops) in my entire life, I'd hand them a 5.

Then I lightened up, of course.