Album Rating: 4.0

I Know The End and Punisher are easily her top 2 for me and i'd still call this a tad more consistent/interesting than Stranger.

Album Rating: 4.5

some of the lower ratings are probably just antihype since Punisher got a lot more attention than Stranger



this album has a higher ceiling and a higher floor than Stranger, IMO

Album Rating: 4.5 | Sound Off

"yeah but the highs ain't as high"



I mean Motion Sickness, Funeral, and Scott Street are amazing songs, but so are I Know the End, Chinese Satellite, and Kyoto

Album Rating: 4.0

'So weird to me that this is rated lower than Stranger when this is so much more consistent'



Yes, it is more consistent--consistently inferior to Smoke Signals.

turns out we finally know where those signals were coming from that sick b u r n all along

Album Rating: 4.0

speeding cuz fuck the cops

Album Rating: 4.5 | Sound Off

Smoke Signals is like mid tier on there but sure

that's a fake opinion stop being negative

Album Rating: 4.0

Smoke Signals is probably one of my least faves on that album tbh

Album Rating: 2.0

thread has too much positivity anyway

Album Rating: 4.0

Stranger is mid as hell



this is probably closer to mid then it was last year but will I ever listen again to verify? probably not

Album Rating: 4.0

Ok, so I re-read my Stranger review from 2018 and apparently I was lot more positive about Smoke Signals back then than I am now:



"Opener “Smoke Signals” immediately sets the tone, blending clean-channel echo-swathed guitars with the light glaze of symphonic strings that sound like they came straight from Vespertine. From the first time that sad, draining motif hits the ears, the mix of sadness and beauty is intoxicating."



lol

Album Rating: 2.0

intoxicating

Album Rating: 2.0

Damn I'm really gonna page break every last sucker on sput today

Album Rating: 3.5

I haven't listened to this in full in about a year now but Kyoto still owns

break it again and jam Coheed with me it is the only good way to listen to incel jams in a phoeb thread

Album Rating: 4.0

genuinely proud of you for referring to it as that. can we just do away with the term post hardcore altogether now

you have already done away with the term post hardcore by repeatedly using it without any understanding of its meaning or application so imma call that a moot question

Album Rating: 4.7 | Sound Off

Johnny will still be commenting on this thread long after all of us have died or quit sput

stop making phoebe's music about your depression again