Album Rating: 2.5

The Line is a gorgeous little piece and definitely one of the better tracks here [2]



It and "Waves" are about the only thing on here I still listen to

Album Rating: 3.0

Damn dude not even Rebirth or Old Haunt?

Album Rating: 5.0

Waves is definitely the main one I come back to, but when I do I end up listening to most if not all of the album

Album Rating: 3.4

The Line is eh

"Casey has one of the best voices to date"

Agreed, and I think this may be my favorite performance by him to date, especially after how strained he sounded at times on Act III

Album Rating: 4.0

his voice has gotten sooooooo much better since act III



the line is by far my least favorite track though

Album Rating: 4.5

I'm kinda surprised the average is staying this strong. Was pretty sure it wold drop to at least a 3.9

Album Rating: 4.5

When that bitter suite 3 reprise happens towards the end of night on the town. Oh man, the feels

Album Rating: 3.0

bitter suite 1 you mean

Album Rating: 4.0

Jeez this album flows fucking perfectly. I absolutely love the whole musical. pantomime vibe that TDH has.

Album Rating: 4.5

Show last night was fantastic. So much passion.



Album is easily the best Act so far.

Album Rating: 4.5

This is undoubtedly my favorite album of the year so far. Rating may even go up.



Of course, new Orbs has the new potential to drop whenever, though, so...

Album Rating: 3.0

I kinda dig the theatrical sound on this one, but I don't like that most of the songs have this poppy sound/songstructure.

Album Rating: 4.0

all of their best songs have always been the poppiest ones though



this album expands the pop hookiness but also the arrangements and theatrics so they really focused on their strengths here imo

Album Rating: 4.5

Sorry for joining the party so late, gentlemen and ladies, mind if I do a short song-by-song rating from my opinions?



Rebirth- Best intro of theirs from any album

The Old Haunt- When the main melody ends, this song goes bad real fast

Waves- Good song, but extremely overrated. Flows very nicely

At the End of the Earth- Great song. Has some good vibes radiating off of it and the melody is very catchy

Remembered- Neat little piece, I rarely listen to it.

A Night on the Town- Main track from this album, great song, but I pretty much stopped listening to it because of the other catchy stuff

Is There Anybody Here?- Underrated, but also overrated because there are a ton of people that say that it's underrated to the point where it's played and defended so much that it's overrated now.

The Squeaky Wheel- Nice changeover from the beginning stuff on the album. 2nd best on the album.

The Bitter Suite IV and V- Nice tune. Has a great tone to it and the direction they took after the little intro is very nice and catchy. A little disappointed in the part where Casey sings, "Don't you tread too close to the line this time", though. Nick, the drummer, could've made something more of that section instead of a simple bass-snare-high hat all on the same beat thing.

The Bitter Suite VI- Terrible. Very boring and anticlimactic.

King of Swords- Great song, but now overrated for the same reason as Is There Anybody Here?

If All Goes Well- Worst song on the album. Just made for filler, like Wish Them Well was for Rush on Clockwork Angels.

The Line- 2nd worst. Boring and goes nowhere.

Wait- Definitely like parts of The Color Spectrum, but weird and out of place. Doesn't really fit.

Ouroborous- Best song on the album. Definitely a great ending and certainly and eerie one. The "lost my soul in the place of the great deceiver" is my favorite part.



Definitely a great album, except for the few turds on it that are uninteresting.

In my opinion, this is their best album ever, barely edging out Act II.

Also, IV>II>I>The Color Spectrum>III>Migrant

Migrant is a fat fucking turd that Casey laid because he thought he could go in a different direction. Too pop-esque and hippy-ish for my liking.

Hi there, you're absolutely not right

Album Rating: 3.0

yeah it's levi-Osa not leviosaaaa-Aaaar

Album Rating: 4.5

how can you dislike 1/3 of the album and still give it a perfect score

Album Rating: 3.0

^^^^^

Album Rating: 4.0

did that guy say that the end of the old haunt is the bad part?