Review Summary: Pink Floyd's first album is a bold psychedelic gem, fronted by the mastermind Syd Barrett.11 of 11 thought this review was well written
Pink Floyd was certainly a different type of band in their earliest stages. Back when Syd Barrett was calling the shots, Pink Floyd had an entirely different sense of style, entailing extremely ornate psychedelia. The band's first album, The Piper at the Gates of Dawn, is nonetheless an iconic album that delves into the disturbed mind of Syd Barrett himself.
Without a doubt, this LP is peculiar and highly outlandish, and its ingenuity transcends the facets of traditional rock music. Barrett's vision of a mystical world comes to life through bizarre noises, playful vocals, and contorted song structures. Listening to this album feels stepping onto a completely different planet and trying desperately to find one's bearings. After the spacey opener "Astronomy Domine" kicks in and breaks any links with reality, it is very unclear as to where the album is headed. The real challenge with the album is discovering what all these songs mean, but the absence of lucidity from beginning to end makes the album a delightful enigma.
For an album that was released in the 60s, the production on The Piper at the Gates of Dawn is really quite impressive. Each instrument sounds as clear as it wants to be, and the album carries a very supernatural flavor. The guitars on the hefty "Lucifer Sam" are very defined and intense as Barrett amplifies his voice during the tumultuous chorus. The track exudes enthusiasm through a sound that is large in scale and ambition. Many parts of the album are clearly drug-induced and expose the most anomalous fragments of Barrett's mind. "Matilda Mother" is presented as a interesting story that gradually descends into madness. The song journeys into a land of fantasy ruled by a dignified king. The unknown mother plagues the mind of the speaker as Syd sings, "Why'd you have to leave me there, hanging in my infant air, waiting?", but she also serves as the speaker's source of comfort.
The shift between tracks is purposefully disorienting, yet the album channels the band's energy through grand guitar solos and amusing lyrics. Listening to this LP requires blind acceptance of the illogical. The imagery of "Flaming" transcends reason and is conveyed as an elaborate daydream. The track floats upon a wave of psychedelic sound effects and frolics along like an exuberant game of hide and seek. The LP dives into a truly zany place with the ambitious, instrumental "Interstellar Overdrive". The track escalates with raspy guitar strums and eccentric background textures. In addition, it emits monstrous noise and distortion by implementing several crazy effects that magnify its breadth. Clocking in at just under ten minutes, it is a dense song with a haunting tone that transports the listener into a chasm of darkness.
After the breathing room of "Interstellar Overdrive" Barrett returns to his post as the storyteller, as he sings about tiny creatures who eat, sleep, and drink wine. "The Gnome" is a blissful little tune that is as enjoyable as it is strange. The multiple vocal layers carry a hint of eeriness alongside merry lyrics. The band shifts gears with "Chapter 24", a more delicate track with a heartwarming chorus. The band's unity comes to the forefront with the accented chant of "Sunset, sunrise". Despite the ambiguous lyrics, Barrett comes across as settled and placid, more so than any other song on the album. The track is truly an overlooked gem in the band's back catalogue.
The influence of mind-altering drugs on this LP is fairly evident from the gaudy imagery and nonlinear composition. Pink Floyd embraces an obscure identity for the sake of an intriguing musical form. Additionally, this form benefits from remarkable songwriting and lighthearted musical recreation. Barrett's style clearly differs with Floyd's later albums, but his musical ideas are equally awe-inspriing. His talent as a vocalist is another interesting attribute displayed on this LP like, for instance, on "The Scarecrow" which showcases one of his finest vocal performances. This simple track spices the album up with perky percussion and unique instrumentation that sets it apart from its surrounding tracks. Barrett creates sympathy for the inanimate scarecrow to the point where it appears to be an analogy for his own life.
The Piper at the Gates of Dawn might not be everyone's cup of tea. It is completely different from future albums like Animals and Wish You Were Here. This is primarily because The Piper is the only LP in which Barrett was ultimately in charge. The end product is an unconstrained LP that is heavily psychedelic and dreamy. While it took me a little while to get into this album, I was mesmerized once I came to appreciate its distinctive style. This album is definitely not for everyone, but those who give it a chance are in for a real treat.