">
 

Pink Floyd
Meddle


3.5
great

Review

by Killtacular USER (34 Reviews)
June 25th, 2005 | 67 replies


Release Date: 1971 | Tracklist


Released in 1971, Meddle was the album that is widely credited as the source of Pink Floyd's future sound, mainly from the 23 minute epic Echoes. Made up of six songs and a few different genres, this album serves as a fairly decent Floyd record and pretty good album overall.

The first track, One of These Days, starts with about 20 seconds of silence, until a static type effect lightly begins. This leads into a wonderful bassline, and every now and then a twangy sound. This continues for about a minute or so, and then some cymbal crescendos and other slight effects are added to the mix. Later, some tom work is added, while a guitar is sort of wailing in the background. About halfway through, everything stops and a pulsing sound fluctuates volume. Effects are added, and then Nick Mason adds the distorted, electronic sounding vocals with "One of these days, I'm going to cut you into little pieces." Now things go into overdrive with cymbals singing, guitars screeching, and keyboards plinking. A little solo from Gilmour, and some key work from Wright, and then the song just sort of stops and fades away.

Next is Pillow of Winds, a slower song. It starts with some guitar strumming. Some soothing vocals come in from Gilmour, and just add to the easiness of this track. "When night comes down, you lock the door/The book falls to the floor" says Dave as he strums his strings some more. The guitar eventually gets a little higher pitched as keys highlight the notes. Mason's hi-hats come in and the band plays away, still continuing the slow pace and mellow mood. The vocals make a return and "Sleepy time when I lie/With my love by my side" is softly sung. Afterward, the music continues and then eventually fades out. This is one of the slowest songs and, as a result, is easy to relax to.

Fearless is up next, and begins with a strummed guitar, which brings the band in. They just play for a bit until vocals come in with "You say the hill's too steep to climb/You say you'd like to see me try." Again, Gimour's vocals are very soft and soothing. Then everything goes away, with some keyboard remaining and Dave's singing. This moment is very relaxing. This leads into the opening tune, until it softens up a bit, and then returns with some strumming. "Fearlessly the idiot faced the crowd smiling" brings back the vocals. Soon thereafter, the soft interlude returns, with lone keyboard, cymbals, and vocals. They then make a triumphant return, going back to the opening lick, but this time it seems more enthusiastic. Strings are strummed, cymbals go crash, and then towards the end, there's some crowd chanting something. The music fades away, leaving just the horde and their chanting. I'm not sure what it is, but they seem to enjoy doing it. This chanting ends the track.

San Tropez starts off with guitar and drums. Piano joins, as well as Waters' vocals. This song has a different feel to it, and is part of the middle two 'drifter tracks', which venture into different sounds as opposed to the rest. After some vocals, there's a little solo of something that sounds kind of like Hawaii... if that makes any sense. Everything goes back to the way it was and vocals come back. "Makin' for a date for later by phone/And if you're alone I'll come home" leads into a nice piano solo from Wright. This is what brings up the quality of the track, as it goes on for a decent amount of time. Eventually, the song fades away while in the middle of the piano.

Seamus is up next, and is also the shortest track, as well as my least favorite. There's some dogs howling and Gilmour singing about a dog named Seamus. After the vocals, theres some guitar with a slight hint of piano along with a bit of more howling. This continues a bit, until a longer howl, along with the fade out of instruments, ends the track. This seems more like just filler, and the record would've been better off without it. Definitely not one of Floyd's best tunes.

Finally, there's the 23 minute epic, Echoes. It starts with a high-pitched pinging, almost like sonar. Soon, some other little noises join in the background. Keyboard joins in and then some guitar, followed by Mason's drums. A few seconds of jamming, and then they mellow it out with the twanging of guitar and the pulsing of keys. The drums join again with some toms and crashes, until mellowing again. "Overhead the albatross hangs motionless upon the air" marks the entry of some slow vocals by our buddy Gilmour. The mellow tunes continue as vocals march on as the keyboard gets slightly more frantic until vocals disappear and the band jams a bit. Mellow time again, as Gilmour's voice makes a return. "No one flys around the sun" marks the jamming session again. Soon after, there's a guitar solo while Mason bashes his skins. This goes on for a bit as the strings squeal louder and louder, until about seven minutes in it transfers to the great instrumental part with a nice bassline, good drums, and more string twiddling. Notable here is Wright's key work, chiming in over top of guitar with an almost organ-type sound. This goes on for a bit, until Gilmour plucks away some more. After about four minutes into this part, a howling type noise comes in as the instruments fade away. This leads to high-pitched squealing, thanks to Gilmour's effects laden axe. After a bit, this goes to lone keyboards, and occasional squeaks. Eventually, guitar makes a comeback along with Masons percussion work. The band goes back to the mellow music that began the song as vocals make a return. "So I throw the windows wide and crawl to you across the sky" signal the return of jamming, as the band goes at it. After a bit of that, the mellow-ness returns, with a keyboard solo from Wright as Mason's ride keeps time. This fades out with a howling wind taking it's place, which then fades out to end the song and album.

Overall, this is a pretty decent album. It's got good music, vocals, and lyrics. It wouldn't be at the top of a Pink Floyd list, but it would make a worthy addition. Meddle should contain at least a track or two anyone could enjoy, and for those who enjoy later Floyd, there's always the epic Echoes.



[+] Pros

(+)The music is usually mellow and relaxing
(+)Vocals are great throughout
(+)Echoes

[-] Cons

(-)Doesn't compare to Floyd's later works
(-)Middle section of Echoes could've been done without
(-)Seamus

[?] Perplexing

(?)What the hell is that on the cover? Is that a nose? You been diggin' for gold, Roger?


Tracklist

1. One of These Days -5:57 (Gilmour; Mason; Waters; Wright)
2. A Pillow of Winds -5:11 (Gilmour; Waters)
3. Fearless -6:08 (Gilmour; Waters)
4. San Tropez -3:43 (Waters)
5. Seamus -2:15 (Gilmour; Mason; Waters; Wright)
6. Echoes -23:29 (Gilmour; Mason; Waters; Wright)



SCRUPLES



Recent reviews by this author
The Dillinger Escape Plan Calculating InfinitySunn O))) The Grimmrobe Demos (Demo)
Mr. Bungle CaliforniaBrian Eno Ambient 1: Music For Airports
Staind Break The CycleNine Inch Nails The Fragile
user ratings (3604)
4.2
excellent
other reviews of this album
1 of
  • EVedder27 (4.5)
    An outstanding and ambitious effort that is underappreciated....

    Oceania (5)
    Pink Floyd is one of those rare bands whose vast catalog of music is filled with hidden ge...

    e210013 (4.5)
    One of Pink Floyd’s most exquisite pieces. It’s one of their most enduring and beloved...

    scotish (5)
    One of these days, it’s going to cut you into pieces....

  • TheMoonchild (4)
    The moment Pink Floyd made it clear they were here to stay....

    isaacb263 (4.5)
    A classic PF record that compares to DSoTM....

    AnyColour74 (4.5)
    ...

    Seals84 (4)
    Set the tone for some of Pink Floyds best work...



Comments:Add a Comment 
pixiesfanyo
June 25th 2005


1223 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Seamus is dope.



This is a great album, you are acting crazy.

masada
June 25th 2005


2733 Comments


This album has led me to enjoy the company of men in a way I cannot explain.

"Echoes" is my mother.

Kingofdudes
June 25th 2005


294 Comments


[-] Cons

(-)Doesn't compare to Floyd's later works
(-)Middle section of Echoes could've been done without
(-)Seamus

[?] Perplexing

(?)What the hell is that on the cover? Is that a nose? You been
diggin' for gold, Roger


Con #1 - I dont know about that, I think I like this album more than The Wall in general, and maybe even more than DSotM.
Con #2 - I like having the middle section in it. It isnt so bad after you get used to it. They actually improve this section when they play it live.


The cover is an ear(Roger's I think). Just turn your head to the left and you can tell.

Pretty good review, I love every song on this album.

Killtacular
June 26th 2005


1314 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

I knew it was an ear, but I just couldn't help but comment on it. The chance to relate it to a nose and nose-picking was too much to pass up. And I don't mind the mid-section to Echoes too much, but it'd do a good job to bore some people not used to such things. I stand by my 3.5, you crazy folks.

Pig on the wing
June 26th 2005


25 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

I like the middle section because its bleak screeches and mind-screwing nature of uncomfort contrasts and higlights incredibly the warmth of the subsequant gradual build up and conclusive vocals, which is one of the best pieces of music I've ever heard. Sorry if this has made me sound like I know what I'm on about, (or the opposite) but its the best way I could describe it.

DesolationRow
July 13th 2005


833 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Fearless, One of These Days, and Echoes are three of my favorite floyd songs. Nice Review

moaner
July 28th 2005


6 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

your review of echoes is a bit descriptive. its more of an emotional journey than anything else, and whether listened to on a whole basis, or concentrating on one aspect, it still comes out great. I love it.



I also enjoy this album a lot. nice to listen to, requires no listener effort.

fendercustomstrat
August 1st 2005


46 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Meddle is probably the most underrated Floyd album that deserves the most credit and listening. Without "Seamus", the album would be stellar.



2 things that I'm surprised wasn't included in the review:



1) "Seamus" was based on a song from Floyd's film "Live at Pompeii" called "Mademoiselle Nobs" in which a dog named Nobs howls in pain from the sound of Gilmour's harmonica. Nick Mason is nowhere to be found on the film track, Rick Wright's job is to keep the mic near the dog, and Roger Waters surprisingly does rhythm guitar over a pre-recorded bass track. The only difference is that "Seamus" has lyrics, not good ones at that.



2) the chanting at the end of "Fearless" is actually a live performance of the Rodgers & Hammerstein song "You'll Never Walk Alone".



Overall, decent review. I just wish "Seamus" wasn't on this album, or any album for that matter.

Knoxvillelives
August 16th 2005


342 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

This album kicks the Wall's ass.



Fantastic diversity and some really beautiful songs



Anyone know where I can get a 'dog-less' Seamus? :P

Seriously



What the hell? The chanting at the end is the Liverpool football/soccer club (United Kingdom) anthem, adopted as their motto and chant. You can hear them shouting...'Liver-pool! Liver-pool!' *players come out* 'Wheeeeyyyyyy!!!!'

Kingofdudes
August 17th 2005


294 Comments


2 things that I'm surprised wasn't included in the review:

1) "Seamus" was based on a song from Floyd's film "Live at Pompeii" called "Mademoiselle Nobs" in which a dog named Nobs howls in pain from the sound of Gilmour's harmonica. Nick Mason is nowhere to be found on the film track, Rick Wright's job is to keep the mic near the dog, and Roger Waters surprisingly does rhythm guitar over a pre-recorded bass track. The only difference is that "Seamus" has lyrics, not good ones at that.

2) the chanting at the end of "Fearless" is actually a live performance of the Rodgers & Hammerstein song "You'll Never Walk Alone".


The reasonwhy those 2 things arent in there is because those 2 things are wrong.

Knoxvillelives
August 17th 2005


342 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

^^lmao



That Seamus 'factoid' is bull

The lyrics are great for a start

fendercustomstrat
August 18th 2005


46 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

If anybody has ever put their egos aside to give someone else the benefit of the doubt, you guys would realize that you could be wrong.



I'll admit that I was wrong about the 'live performance' part, but it specifically says Rodgers & Hammerstein in the vinyl sleeve, the cd liner notes, and everywhere on the internet. http://www.guitarnoise.com/pink_floyd/meddle/index.php Go to this site and look under "Album Credits".



And to knoxvillelives - don't bash my corrections and say it's bull when you don't have anything to prove I'm wrong!!! Both of my facts are what I said they are!!!! I bet you've never even seen 'Pompeii' and you have no idea what I'm talking about!



One more thing - Seamus' lyrics are extremely weak. I've heard boy bands write better lyrics than this piece of shit excuse of for a song. It's 100% shit filler-material that shouldn't have made 'The Final Cut'!!! (That's right, everyone wishes they came up with that!)

analrightstart
August 24th 2005


96 Comments


i bought animals today and loved it, hopefully going to buy this tomorrow and love it just as much

Dried Muffin Remnants
September 23rd 2005


297 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

I LOVE ECHOES. LOVE IT.

Knoxvillelives
October 5th 2005


342 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Is it just me or is Fendercustomstrat taking this a little personally. First of all, being an Liverpudlian myself, I can officially clarify that the chanting in Fearless is from a Liverpool game, see my previous comment.

Also, I do know what Pompeii is, though I admit I've never seen it. But I have read several books including Nick Mason's official coffee table book and when he talks about Seamus, he regrettably doesn't mention the extraordinary events you described. You may be right, but I have serious doubts.

spanna
November 13th 2005


5 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

echoes is pure greatness. the parts with the vocals are so fragile and beautiful. and when it comes out of the scary 'nighttimey' bit back to the 'day' ah

fendercustomstrat
November 23rd 2005


46 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

knoxvillelives -



I find it hard not to take it personally when someone with a first grade education would be able to understand that the album's liner notes say "You'll Never Walk Alone" - Rodgers & Hammerstein. It's from the musical "Carousel". Look it up if you don't believe me, but don't call it bullshit because I know something that you don't and you want to disregard the truth.



As for Nick Mason, if you read my original statement he was NOT in the scene with the song "Mademoiselle Nobs", thus, he can't write about a song that he was not a part of. I wouldn't call it an 'extraordinary event'. I'm not saying that it isn't a chant for Liverpudlian soccer games either and I never argued against that .



I just find it offensive to disregard the truth just because I might know something that you don't. I know my shit from Blind Willie Johnson and Pinetop Perkins to Jelly Roll Morton and Art Blakey to the Mahavishnu Orchestra and Return to Forever (I'll be very impressed if you've heard even one song from each of these artists, let alone what genre of music they play), so don't think that I'm making up some fact to appear superior.

pfandozzyrock
December 26th 2005


40 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

MEDDLE is probally there 3rd or 4th greatest album



Echoes is probally there greatest work of all time, its the greatest song floyd ever created , to say this album is nothing but good or average your kidding yourself. IT is floyd and this album is fucking amazing.



I recondmend to buy this album to anyone... its supurb



pulseczar
December 26th 2005


2385 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

I don't get what's so great about this album, other than OOTD and Echoes it's just a bore.

Dried Muffin Remnants
December 30th 2005


297 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Brilliant, but too short and too much filler.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy