Radiohead
In Rainbows


4.0
excellent

Review

by Tyler Fisher EMERITUS
October 11th, 2007 | 3833 replies


Release Date: 2007 | Tracklist

Review Summary: With the addition of a second disc, In Rainbows loses some flow but maintains the original atmosphere and quality of the first disc.

Shining white light through a prism creates the entire visible electromagnetic spectrum, wavelengths that span 380 to 780 nm (roughly). Often times, high school students study this in science class, but a rainbow serves as a more popular symbol for this spectrum. In history, the rainbow has stood for peace, diversity, Buddhism, homosexuality, and hope. To put Radiohead inside a rainbow hardly makes sense with this historical background, but then again, since when has Radiohead conformed to social norms? Who else could write the Orwellian “2+2=5” and have it make complete sense? Love or hate, in the past fourteen years, the members of Radiohead stand in their own world far removed from the condition of the music industry while still causing self-proclaimed pop culture gurus name the current generation the “Radiohead Generation.” In six full-length albums, they conformed, pioneered, and finally decided to pursue personal ambitions no matter what anyone else thought. Their sounds ranged from radio rock to quirky electronica and everywhere in between. Given that, the color spectrum makes much more sense. In Rainbows proves the band’s realization that their career has spanned a full rainbow, an entire color palette of tones and voices, and they are still adding new colors fourteen years later.

For the last four years, the world waited for Radiohead’s elusive seventh album, some eagerly and some grudgingly. All news on the band, given either by them or by third party sources, came bizarre, schizophrenic, and cynical. Many predicted In Rainbows to be the result of a band finally going off the deep end. Then, in perfect Radiohead style, they nonchalantly announced the completion of the album and the release date, ten days after this initial statement. Furthermore, the consumer could pay whatever they wanted for a download of the album, which actually only gives half of the album. The full album, with a set price, arrived in December through a pre-order on the site and will go in record stores worldwide by January 1, 2008. With the second disc now in tow, Radiohead have truly compiled a collection of everything the music world expected and did not expect all at the same time. The band played every song on the download live at one point or another other than “Faust Arp” and the transitional elements of the second disc, “MK 1” and “MK 2”. They range from the OK Computer era to songs debuted on their 2006 tour. The studio recording of “Nude” is a long time coming after ten years of toying around with the song on tours. Meanwhile, “Videotape” recalls the best aspects of Amnesiac and “House of Cards” takes the watery atmosphere of Kid A and centers it around guitar.

Despite the amalgamation of styles, a technique employed on Hail to the Thief as well, In Rainbows sounds surprisingly focused, as the album possesses its own distinctive qualities. The opening seconds of “15 Step” give way to the first of these aspects in its extreme form. The electronic drums groove in 5/4, yet it feels oddly danceable. This dance-inspired, groovy drumming style finds its way on much of the album, including “Jigsaw Falling into Place”, “Weird Fishes/Arpeggi”, and “Bangers and Mash.” If any superlative is to be given to the album, Phil Selway has his best album here. Still, not every song follows this dance atmosphere; in fact, the entire middle of the album goes somewhere completely different. “All I Need” through “Reckoner” all utilize strings for climatic effect. “Faust Arp” revolves around the orchestral sound with only an acoustic guitar backing it, epitomizing the sparseness that haunts most of Radiohead’s music. While the contrast between the groovy and orchestral sounds seems vast, the placing of these songs on the album tie everything together, opening the album energetically and slowly transitioning to the strings, by placing a good drum beat behind the initial strings in “All I Need.”

Along with album flow, other structural bonds tie the first disc of In Rainbows into a complete thought. First and most obviously, Thom Yorke remains a constant throughout each song. His unmistakable voice that no one can imitate (no matter how hard Matt Bellamy tries) floats throughout the album in his typical schizophrenic wails, although his lyrical topics seem more “normal” than usual. “House of Cards” begins with “I don't wanna be your friend/I just wanna be your lover” while “All I Need” centers around the chorus of “You are all I need/You are all I need/I'm in the middle of a picture/Lying in the leaves.” Regardless, his voice provides the eerie icing on the cake that makes this album stand out as a Radiohead album more than anything else. Secondly, the guitars take an extremely prominent role on the album, the most important since OK Computer. From the distorted, lo-fi production of “Bodysnatchers” and “Bangers and Mash” to the wall-of-sound arpeggios in “Weird Fishes/Arpeggi”, the guitars on this album not only make the main instrumental material but they vary more than any other album from the band. With the guitars continually playing and Thom always providing that voice brinking on the edge of insanity, Radiohead have proven their unique identity yet again once again.

The second disc, even upon its release, remains in a shroud of mystery. Is it a B-sides collection? Is it supposed to be of equal importance as the first? With the transitional segues, it seems to flow as if intended to stand as one whole unit rather than a collection of songs. The first segue recalls “Videotape”, a faint reprise meant to link the two discs together. “Four Minute Warning” achieves the same quiet finality that “Videotape” did, except using fuzzy keyboard swells, light percussion, and other subtle instruments rather than repetitive piano. The rest of the disc, however, seems randomly placed. The second “MK” feels awkwardly positioned between the guitar-based “Go Slowly” and the piano-based “Last Flowers.” Still, many of the songs maintain the quality and atmosphere established by the first disc, with “Down Is the New Up” and “Up on the Ladder” standing out on the disc. Regardless, with two months to digest the first disc as a complete thought, adding these new songs to the mix confuses the album flow as a whole.

In Rainbows lacks one major aspect of a classic album: a standout track. The Bends had “Street Spirit”, OK Computer had “Paranoid Android” among others, and Kid A had “Everything In Its Right Place.” Meanwhile, this album lacks that defining song; it rather feels content to brew in its own inherent atmosphere. “Videotape” closes the first disc peacefully, like a peck kiss goodbye. However, the entire album lacks a climax. If anything, In Rainbows will be remembered for its unforgettable marketing campaign, with a subtleness and brevity that parallels the album’s atmosphere. The band members probably chuckled at the events of October 10th in the middle of nowhere, England, as bloggers raced the clock for the first opinion and intense arguments fly over message boards and the legend grows. Economic analysts praised the band for their literal application of free-market economics. We as a society have given them exactly what they wanted, more media coverage than the result of sending out 1,000 advance press copies. Maybe we really are the “Radiohead Generation.”



Recent reviews by this author
Das Racist RelaxLil Wayne Tha Carter IV
The Weeknd ThursdayJay-Z and Kanye West Watch the Throne
Shabazz Palaces Black UpFleet Foxes Helplessness Blues
user ratings (4493)
Chart.
4.2
excellent
other reviews of this album
1 of
  • cagedbutterfly (3.5)
    Radiohead rises from the ashes of their past 3 albums and compose a beauty of a record....

    Ryder631 (5)
    After crafting songs of exquisitely Orwellian paranoia for over a decade, Radiohead give u...

    shauryapatel (4.5)
    What were the fans left with after the 'pay what you want' hype was cleared? The collectio...

    Justin Swope (5)
    In Rainbows is another breathtaking passage into the mind of Radiohead, presenting an exqu...

  • someguest (4.5)
    When I'm at the pearly gates......

    pye3214 (5)
    A modern classic and a must listen for everyone, not just Radiohead fans....

    Kuo (5)
    In conclusion this album is a classic, it is easily accessible to most listeners fan or no...

    Kiet Truong (4.5)
    An album that will most likely go down in history as Radiohead’s album that revolutioniz...

  • Alex Getter (4.5)
    Radiohead at their most intimate in years; In Rainbows is their own collection of "seducti...

    Tom Gellatly (4.5)
    An understated, consistently enjoyable album, In Rainbows feels like a wonderful comeback ...

    Nathan (4.5)
    Radiohead's unusual marketing ploy on In Rainbows may be what is most remembered looking b...

    Leslie W (4)
    Mesmerizing.......

  • Reckoner (5)
    A modern classic from the best band in the world....

    RJayZ (4.5)
    It's not easy writing a masterpiece. It's a lot less easy following one up....

    Brandon Garland (3.5)
    Although not as impressive as an Opeth album, Radiohead damn well tries to impress the Spu...

    Adam Downer STAFF (3)
    What happened to Radiohead?...

  • Chris Baranowski (4.5)
    In Rainbows is beautiful in its simplicity and once again proves that Radiohead are the ki...

    David James Young (4)
    An unpredictable record from the biggest unsigned band in the world....

    Daniel Incognito EMERITUS (4)
    Another continuation in the overall Radiohead style, and one which executes its design wit...

    UncalledFor (4)
    May initially feel like a Let Down with No Surprises to be found (because it has Everythin...

  • Porter W. Richards (4.5)
    Dark. Disturbing. Lush, yet subdued. In Rainbows is everything fans hoped for....


Comments:Add a Comment 
Kaleid
October 11th 2007


711 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Smooth mix of band analysis and album review. Your last paragraph sums up my feelings exactly. Nice one

The Jungler
October 11th 2007


4827 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I really like this album, but I'm not sure of how much (hence no rating yet). I'll definitely decide over the next few listens.
Aside from messing up the italics in the third paragraph and calling 'Nude' Numb in the second, this was a great review.

FlawedPerfection
Emeritus
October 11th 2007


2806 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Got those things, thanks.

Electric City
Staff Reviewer
October 11th 2007


15743 Comments

Album Rating: 3.8 | Sound Off

In Rainbows lacks one major aspect of a classic album: a standout track. The Bends had “Street Spirit”, OK Computer had “Paranoid Android” among others, and Kid A had “Everything In Its Right Place.”


Wow, I said almost the exact same thing in tribe's review, as you pointed out.

The review is well done, by far the best one, as predicted, and hits on everything I feel about this record, except that I feel like this has strong similarities to The Eraser. Someone in one of the reviews said "This album is composed of good songs and slightly better songs." That's correct.

lunchforthesky
October 11th 2007


1039 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I disagree.

the classics song is Videotape imo.

but to each their own.

excellent review.

Electric City
Staff Reviewer
October 11th 2007


15743 Comments

Album Rating: 3.8 | Sound Off

Videotape is such a letdown in comparison to the live version.

lunchforthesky
October 11th 2007


1039 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Also I think Fake Plastic Trees is the classic on The Bends.

Altmer
October 11th 2007


5652 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

I find this album to be a dull snoozefest, but hey, good review!

IsItLuck?
Emeritus
October 11th 2007


4927 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

"Who else could title a song “2+2=5” and have it make complete sense?"

well it makes sense because the title is based off the book '1984' where 2+2=5 was one of the more central ideas of the book. other than that, great review.This Message Edited On 10.11.07

VeryPleasantNeighbor
October 11th 2007


272 Comments


The only real "climax" on the album is the ending of Nude. "You will go to hell for what your dirty mind is thiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiking...." One of their best since Exit Music or Let Down.
All I Need could've if they hadn't buried the vocals.
I don't know about the album as a whole...I haven't really gotten into Reckoner or House of Cards yet, and I don't care for Faust Arp. The other 7 songs are amazing.

Oh, and it's not a double album (a la The White Album). The other CD is just a bonus CD. This could change when it goes to stores, but as of now these 10 songs are the true album.



bloodyBourne
October 11th 2007


21 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Videotape is such a letdown in comparison to the live version.

On the first listen i felt the same way. But now I'm beggining to like the atmosphere they created with the song

FlawedPerfection
Emeritus
October 11th 2007


2806 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

The only real "climax" on the album is the ending of Nude. "You will go to hell for what your dirty mind is thiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiking...." One of their best since Exit Music or Let Down.

All I Need could've if they hadn't buried the vocals.

I don't know about the album as a whole...I haven't really gotten into Reckoner or House of Cards yet, and I don't care for Faust Arp. The other 7 songs are amazing.



Oh, and it's not a double album (a la The White Album). The other CD is just a bonus CD. This could change when it goes to stores, but as of now these 10 songs are the true album.


Sure there's that climax in "Nude" but it's the third song on the album. Also, I'm still hazy about the second part being a bonus disc, I guess it is but I don't know. I'll wait for more info on the physical release.

DFelon204409
Emeritus
October 11th 2007


3996 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Big ups on the review. I was saving my commentary for the staff review. I think I'll post my reactions tonight while I crunx.

astrel
October 11th 2007


2614 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I am sure it already has been said but 2+2=5 is a 1984 reference. Other than that, great review, I should get this album either today or tomorrow.This Message Edited On 10.11.07

FlawedPerfection
Emeritus
October 11th 2007


2806 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Yeah 1984 is one of my favorite books and I completely neglected that fact ugh I suck.

Electric City
Staff Reviewer
October 11th 2007


15743 Comments

Album Rating: 3.8 | Sound Off

Yeah, man fo rlz.

Also, I don't get the El Cielo reference. Awesome album, yes. Sound anything like this? no.

FlawedPerfection
Emeritus
October 11th 2007


2806 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Focus on atmosphere.

Electric City
Staff Reviewer
October 11th 2007


15743 Comments

Album Rating: 3.8 | Sound Off

Mmm I don't quite get it. I'd definitely go more with The Eraser as a recommendation in terms of atmosphere and similarity, but I probbly won't review this, as by the time I work up the energy for it there'll be ten.

Serpento
October 11th 2007


2351 Comments


Great review FP, so far the best of the three. I love your clincher, too, a throwback to that whole notion about our generation.

tribestros
October 11th 2007


918 Comments


Very good review, owned mine, but the thing that bugs me here is how it's any different if Flawed reviews this 1 day after the release, and I do it on the day of release? What's the big difference?

Btw, Arpeggi is the CLEAR standout track, and is one of my fav Radiohead songs of all time.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy