|
Emeritus
Reviews 149
Approval 97%
Soundoffs 434
News Articles 30
Band Edits + Tags 611
Album Edits 1,574
Album Ratings 3842
Objectivity 79%
Last Active 10-27-22 11:13 pm
Joined 01-25-13
Review Comments 19,513
| Rec Roulette Round One - Cold Hours
Four participants with four lists of recs going.. Each will act as judge of his own list and dictate what genre/theme/mood/concept/ides goes for each round, and the other three will rec.. How we compute scores will be determined at a later date amid bloodshed and squabbles.. It will messy and long and beautiful!! Participants are bgillesp, butcherboy, uniqueuniverse and this boi. | | 1 |  | David Sylvian
Blemish
our subject for this round - albums perfect for the fall/winter seasons
example above | | 2 |  | Dirty Three
Cinder
butcher's rec
result // 3.7/5 (a bit overlong, but i like me some violins and it fits the criteria so gj) | | 3 |  | Sivyj Yar
Burial Shrouds
uniqueuniverse's rec
result // 3.2/5 (nails the vibes i'm looking for, but the music didn't quite grab me as much as I'd like it to) | | 4 |  | Insomnium
Above the Weeping World
bgill's rec
result // 3.8/5 :WINNER: (really picks up near the end, but it's hard to say if it fits the criteria or not but w/e) | |
bgillesp
08.03.17 | Insomnium- Above the Weeping World
Unless that's too mainstream in which case I can find something else | butcherboy
08.03.17 | Dirty Three - Cinder | butcherboy
08.03.17 | also, Frip, you still haven't rec'ed on bgill's list.. | Papa Universe
08.03.17 | Are EPs acceptable? | Frippertronics
08.03.17 | yes | Papa Universe
08.03.17 | The obvious choice would be Paysage d'Hiver - Das Tor
But I'll go with Sivyj Yar - Burial Shrouds.
I hope you're into Black Metal, although your ratings don't really indicate that. But bgillesp rec'd a Black Metal album, so I suppose I can too. | bgillesp
08.03.17 | Mine was melodeath. | bgillesp
08.03.17 | I'm assuming it's not accepted though. I'll look again | bgillesp
08.03.17 | Ray Lynch- Deep Breakfast is my backup | Frippertronics
08.03.17 | alright, I should have results ready by the weekend | bgillesp
08.03.17 | Do you like metal? Can't see your pie chart on mobile. If you don't switch to my backup | Mort.
08.03.17 | i would of liked to do this, shame | Papa Universe
08.03.17 | Mort: Stick around and sign in once someone decides upon the next comp. | butcherboy
08.03.17 | or start your own.. captain your own destiny is what someone somewhere always says,. | bgillesp
08.05.17 | You putting everything up today or tomorrow? JW | Frippertronics
08.05.17 | may be Sunday, but it could be tomorrow
keep yr eyes peeled | Papa Universe
08.06.17 | Sunday it is | Frippertronics
08.06.17 | and I promise I'll be a bit more descriptive next round but this was quite last minute as I was caught up in some work-related stuff | Papa Universe
08.06.17 | So that's everyone, right? Time for round 2, I'll shout others. | Frippertronics
08.06.17 | ye, i got my round 2 up and ready
i imagine the way i got mine set up could work so there's no definite end as of now |
|
