SteakByrnes
09.30.20 | 1 is 1 yea right on brother |
dedex
09.30.20 | 4 > 2 > 1 then idc |
Josh D.
09.30.20 | for a band with 3 good songs, this must've been tough |
Josh D.
09.30.20 | "arguably defined the whole metal core genre as we know it."
oh no |
Bedex
09.30.20 | I always get this band confused with Oathbreaker |
Josh D.
09.30.20 | in high school a friend would wear a TOCS shirt and I didn't know what UO was, and his band would play a nearby coffee place once in a while. And one time they had small flyers to advertise the show and it said "bring a tow truck, there's gonna be a breakdown". I also did not know what that meant at the time. My brain has retained this information for reasons unknown. |
peekatoad
09.30.20 | Interesting take. Define the great line and lost in the separation would be my top 2 followed by they're only. Not a big fan of disambiguation. and i'll say it that i'm disappointed they got back together... i went to their farewell tour and that was one of the best shows i've seen and made peace with the fact they were done.
also letlive on that tour was INSANE. like holy shit letlive was the best opener. mewiwthout bored me so much i went to the back and chilled out until underoath came on |
Josh D.
09.30.20 | I went to that tour too because I was really into Fake History, so I saw letlive. 4 or 5 times in 18 months because they toured so much. Mewithoutyou wasn't on that show though, Silverstein opened. Left after a couple UO songs. |
Pikazilla
09.30.20 | ew letlive ew |
Josh D.
09.30.20 | yeah, I hopped off that bandwagon reeeaalll quick when the album after FH came out. Christ.
I actually remember when that second album came out, a user on here posted in the review for it "lol Josh sorry man" because it's so bad and he knew I was a fan : ( |
bigweinerdon
09.30.20 | great list |
peekatoad
09.30.20 | Get outa here pika. Letlive was amazing. I also saw them a bunch since they were touring so much. I ended up seeing the farewell tour in toronto i think.. made a long journey for it and was totally worth it even in the winter |
Pikazilla
09.30.20 | Letlive are amazing live but I will always consider their music a tacky bargain-bin glassjaw copy |
DopeFiend
09.30.20 | “Arguably defined the whole metalcore genre”
Sorry but that title goes to Jane Doe all day |
Veks
09.30.20 | Nah. Underoath had a much bigger influence on the whole genre.
Literally hundreds of bands tried to copy their style.
Converge is much more hardcore than metalcore. They probably only have 1 "metalcore" album and it's not even. |
peekatoad
09.30.20 | Early glassjaw is pretty good and i get your view on letlive Pika |
onionbubs
09.30.20 | good list! 1 2 4 (these three are all 5s but they do get better w each album) 6 9 >>>>>> 8 5 7. not ranking survive kaleidoscope but it rules ahrd and makes me even more upset i havent seen them live |
SymbolicInTime
09.30.20 | Cool to see CotP so high, it was my 2nd favorite of theirs for years. When I first found these guys, Disambiguation was about a year from release. I loved TOCS, but couldn't get into DtGL or LitSoS for whatever reason. So I went back to Dallas-era and really loved CotP especially. The sheer emotion on there was so intense, 12yr old emo me latched to it like a barnacle |
Groundking
09.30.20 | Imagine calling Down Set Go filler, wtf |
Project
09.30.20 | "Their is also filler here with "Down, Set, Go!""
get right out of here, Down Set Go might be the best song on that album |
Project
09.30.20 | i still think LITSOS is their masterpiece and Too Bright to See is the best song they will ever write, especially considering the comeback album was an absolute joke |
SteakByrnes
09.30.20 | Yea Down Set Go is one of the few songs I come back to on TOCS |
Doibhin69
09.30.20 | 4 is top 3 |
davezillaMP3
09.30.20 | @groundking, @Project fun fact, Spencer hates "Down Set Go" (I don't outright hate the song though)
@SymbolicInTime yeah, i kinda went into this thinking all the dallas stuff would be at the bottom since i never cared for his era when i was into them, but CotP really surprised and impressed me.
@onionbubs thank you so much for liking my list!
@Peektoad, sadly i have never seen underoath live, my parents had never let me go even during their farewell tour
@steakbyrns oh yeah!
|
Emim
09.30.20 | This ranking makes me sad. |
davezillaMP3
09.30.20 | @Emim like i said, this ranking would have a lot of hot takes |
peekatoad
09.30.20 | Dave- the setlist for the farewell tour was stacked. they played 17 songs including the encore. They sounded so good
Also i remember jason from letlive running off stage and hopping on the bar and kicking napkins everywhere. I wish letlive played followed by underoath |
Josh D.
09.30.20 | Let's hope list is short-lived and riddled with disease |
SaveBandit
09.30.20 | I don't hate this ranking. I fully understand anyone putting Disam, DTGL or LITSOS as #1 lol.
I think my personal ranking would be something along the lines of DTGL > Disam > LITSOS > TOCS > shuffle the rest, idc. |
SteakByrnes
09.30.20 | For me it's Disam > DTGL > LITSauce > TOCS > TCOT > COTP > Erase Me > AoD
But yea any one of Disam, DTGL, or LITSOS at number 1 makes sense to me |
DopeFiend
09.30.20 | Amia Venera Landscape’s one album made Underoath’s entire discography irrelevant. |
davezillaMP3
09.30.20 | @peekatoad, oh hell yeah, i take it they played the whole anthology disc, or did they skip over the dallas era?
@Savebandit thanks for not hating it! |
Rickislost
09.30.20 | Disambiguation is definitely my top 1. I wish I could download the sunburnt and unsound from the anthology too |
Emim
09.30.20 | "Amia Venera Landscape’s one album made Underoath’s entire discography irrelevant"
What a dumb perspective. |
peekatoad
09.30.20 | They didn't play any dallas era stuff which i wish they did instead of the diambiguation songs but thats just me. Their encore was:
Casting Such a Thin Statue
A boy brushed red..
Writing on the walls |
davezillaMP3
09.30.20 | yeah that is a shame their was none of the old stuff, though i understand as it does not suit Spencer's vocals (and apparently the bad blood with dallas prevented him from making a cameo during the farewell tour) |
OwMySnauze
09.30.20 | Worst ranking of Undeoath. The changing of times is definitely not the worst |
davezillaMP3
09.30.20 | their is nothing that is worth coming back to for me with the changing of times, i do not think its a bad album, i just do not think it has anything to offer compared to the rest of their catalog. |
Joeman82
09.30.20 | Act of Depression is like bad bad. Like really bad. The bro abortion lyrics are fucking cringe. |
Joeman82
09.30.20 | But props for saying 10 friends is a goated track cuz it is.
4 will always be 1 for me |
davezillaMP3
09.30.20 | no problem, i was just acting on my words ;) @Joeman82 |
Veks
09.30.20 | 4 will always be 1 for me. |
thatbandsucks
10.01.20 | It's always a shame when people talk crap about They're Only Chasing Safety
I think it's so influential. It made "selling out" necessary. Define The Great Line would have never happen or any other subsequent albums if TOCS didn't nudge them in the right direction.
It's also a special album it its own right. At the time, and even to this day, no one has ever fumbled with post hc, and subtle pop punk/emo and mend it so cohesively.
and my god, the contrast from the first half of the record to the second. The first half is literally pioneering metalcore as the second keeps a filthy traditional finch or glassjaw esque feel to it |
Groundking
10.01.20 | TOCS is amazing agreed and best yeah. My ranking;
TOCS>DTGL>Disam>Erase Me>LITSOS>TCOT>COTP>AOD |
Veks
10.01.20 | "It's always a shame when people talk crap about They're Only Chasing Safety"
[2]
People talk crap because they didn't hear it at the time and then it became cool to shit on it. Like people are scared they will be called Myspace dorks or something for liking it.
Tsk tsk. |
Veks
10.01.20 | "Their is also filler here with "Down, Set, Go!"
Crazy person. |
thatbandsucks
10.01.20 | This guy's write up really made my blood boil
"Spencer was brought in at the last minute, and its very obvious Spencer is not comfortable with shrieking"
I call bs. Spencer's harsh vocals on that album was laid down with such finesse and vigor. also, their previous work was heavier so how do the harsh vocals sound rushed or whatever he's trying to articulate here? There's also more junz than melodic pop punk riffs.
and Down Set Go filler lmao |
thatbandsucks
10.01.20 | My god, his review for Define The Great Line is worse. Literally one of the greatest metalcore records, if not THE greatest mc record is just a 4/5 because two of the tracks were too long lmao |
Veks
10.01.20 | It definitely is one of if not the most influential. |
bigweinerdon
10.01.20 | Yeah Down Set Go is the best song on the album lol |
davezillaMP3
10.01.20 | @thatbanduscks you are acting like i panned TOCS, which i did not. Also if your really mad at me for feeling "Down Set Go" was filler, just wait till you hear how Spencer feels about the song.
secondly that is incorrect on what i said on Define, it was one song that was on the long side, my other main problem was the interlude track is unneeded.
You know you can love an album, and acknowledge its influence and legacy but still have some things about it you were not a fan of right?
|
Veks
10.01.20 | Yeah Spencer's opinion is irrelevant. That song is top 3 for that album at the very least. |
davezillaMP3
10.01.20 | for me top 3 on that album would be (exuding "Ive got 10 friends")
1. Young and Aspiring
2. A Boy brushed Red
3. I'm content with losing |
OwMySnauze
10.01.20 | The Synths and screams on The Changing of Times are perfect. Does not belong dead last on this list... especially behind Erase Me. The worst album they’ve ever made |
Storm In A Teacup
10.01.20 | oh shit 1 is 1!!! nice! totally agree! |
thatbandsucks
10.02.20 | lol is the sole reason you claim Down Set Go is filler is because you watched that Antony Padilla video? |
thatbandsucks
10.02.20 | Casting such a thin shadow in its entirety is one of the best songs on the album dude
saying something is too long is not even a contention regarding music |
davezillaMP3
10.02.20 | @Owmysnauze I knew that would be controversial seeing how many underoath fans love that album, i have tried over and over to give it a chance. my placement of erase me over it came soly down to "On my teeth" and "rapture" |
davezillaMP3
10.02.20 | @Thatbandsucks no, i was just bringing it up as a point of at least i don't hate the song. I think its fine personally.
Also something being too drawn out is a criticism, just because your song is 19 minutes long does not mean its good (not underoath obviously, just an example). its not a matter of looking at the time of the song, but rather the context on how the song works, and that song would of worked better if it was shorter(and i am not saying shorten it to 4 minutes, they could of trimmed off some of that song though and it would of worked better) |
thatbandsucks
10.02.20 | I guess it could be criticized if you had an argument. You can't provide any details why the tracks don't fit despite them being "too long." You just want to strip the record from all extra aesthetics and reducing it to the metalcore equivalent to any pop record ever made. |
davezillaMP3
10.03.20 | Again, that is BS, i never said i wanted them to reduced to a pop metalcore, if i did wouldn't i just pan the album for not being TOCS 2.0? or have "Disabiguation" (aka the least poppy album of the Chamberlain era) as my number 1? Heck i do not think you even need to cut the song, i get what they were going for with the slow build, but it would still work really well if you cut the 3 minute build to the drop to a 2 minute build. you still get the effect of everything slowly building up without it being on the slightly tedious side. I am not against builds 3 minutes or longer, however in the case of that song the buildup it drags for too long for it to have the emotional melodic impact that it is intending with the drop. |
davezillaMP3
10.03.20 | @stormofateacup another man of culture i see |
Spec
10.03.20 | this is the strangest ranking i've ever seen |
GhostB1rd
10.03.20 | 1, 2, 4, and 6 are all arguably classic albums. |
Veks
10.03.20 | Yup good call Ghost. |
Emim
10.03.20 | "The Synths and screams on The Changing of Times are perfect"
Agree hard. So cheesy but so good when set in contrast with each other. |
davezillaMP3
10.04.20 | @spec i mean i get that a lot with my artist discography rankings haha
@GhostB1rd they are all very influential albums for sure
|
peekatoad
10.05.20 | it's interesting that you like act of depression a bit more than the changing of times |