Friday13th
07.29.21 | This Elimination Round will be different. I want you to give me (in one single comment that makes clear you are voting) your top 4 ranking out of these ten. So if Procol Harum was your favorite, followed by Jordsjo, Pendragon, and Seru Giran, you would say "1. Procol Harum, 2. Jordsjo, 3. Pendragon, and 4. Seru Giran." I will weight the number 1 spot over number 2, etc.
Voting ends next Thursday, August 5th. |
Divaman
07.29.21 | Wow. |
zakalwe
07.29.21 | Can place my top 3 straight off the bat but will have another few listens to confirm 4th spot. |
e210013
07.29.21 | Ok, I can see your point. Definitely, this time it will be different from the other tourneys and I can see why. We have here ten and not eight finalists.
I think I'm ready to choose my favourite four finalists. By a question of coherence, which means, according to my ratings, three are perfect clear to me. I mean Jordsjo, Hermann Szobel and Quiet Sun, which are the only albums I rated with 4.5. The problem is the fourth one, because all are great in their own way and I like all. But, after some reflection, I decided to choose Regal Worm, due to its originality. This is probably the album that most surprised me. An album with so many influences and very difficult to define. Even now, I'm not sure what to think about it. The only thing I know is that it's original and chalenging that forces us to repeted listening to full appreciate it.
So, according with all I mentioned above, here are my four candidates by order of preference:
1. Jordsjo
2. Quiet Sun
3. Hermann Szobel
4. Regal Worm |
Pangea
07.29.21 | seems like a good way to progress the tournament. i'll try to relisten all of them this week before voting |
Inoculaeted
07.29.21 | Omg no there’s so many amazing albums here. |
Jethro42
07.29.21 | I'll have to relisten to couple of these before voting... |
Divaman
07.29.21 | Me too. |
Jethro42
07.29.21 | Are the new rules because of the 10 contestant left, or if it's only experimental? |
bgillesp
07.29.21 | This is super tough but I like this style of round.
[edit] Sorry Friday, I got hasty and I’m rethinking my 4th pick possibly. I’ll edit this and post my final decision again by the end of tonight. |
zakalwe
07.29.21 | 1. Pendragon
2. Regal Worm
3. Quiet Sun
4. Seru Giran |
MiloRuggles
07.29.21 | Oh golly, I'll have to work through most of these again. I did revisit Quiet Sun after a lukewarm first spin, and enjoyed it much more. I think it benefits a lot from speakers rather than headphones. Still think it falls off at the end, but it really is something special up until at least the halfway point |
bgillesp
07.30.21 | Ugh I have 5 on here that I love and the other 5 I like, but I’m okay leaving out. It’s just figuring out that one extra is giving me issues. I’m glad I relistened to Jordsjo again though because I didn’t think it would grow on me as much as it did. I’m dead even on Ibio, Seru Giran, and Jordsjo. I love the smoothness of Jordsjo, Seru Giran is the most consistently entertaining, and Pastor may be the best individual song from the whole year off of the Ibio album. |
bgillesp
07.30.21 | Okay, I have relistened to all of my favorites tonight. I am very unhappy to have to eliminate one but I don’t think I will get any closer to a happy decision with more listens.
1. Regal Worm
2. Hermann Szobel
3. Ibio
4. Seru Giran |
Divaman
07.30.21 | I'm giving one more listen to each of my top 5 and then I'm going to vote. |
MrSirLordGentleman
07.30.21 | 1. Seru Giran
2. Yolk
3. Jordsjo
4. Hermann Szobel |
Zig
07.30.21 | 1. Hermann Szobel
2. Quiet Sun
3. Kollektiv
4. Yolk |
Zig
07.30.21 | "I will weight the number 1 spot over number 2, etc."
like the first spot gets 4 points, the second 3, so on? |
wham49
07.30.21 | 1-5
2-10
3-6
4-1 |
Jethro42
07.30.21 | 1. Regal Worm
2. Jordsjo
3. Pendragon
4. Procol Harum |
Jethro42
07.30.21 | Damn hard |
bgillesp
07.30.21 | The 1 was Tantra but y’all voted it out :( |
e210013
07.30.21 | The one of all is what we will decide. Especially, because it isn't mine. Lol. |
Divaman
07.31.21 | I make no promises that these will be in the same order in any future rounds. This was really hard. But here's my vote for this round.
1. Procol Harum
2. Regal Worm
3. Jordsjo
4. Pendragon
It broke my heart not to be able to squeeze in a vote for Ibio as well. |
TwigTW
08.01.21 | My top three albums fell into place fairly quickly, but picking the fourth is so hard. Re-listening to all the albums is a lot of fun tho. |
Divaman
08.01.21 | I notice that Jethro and I have voted for the same four albums, just in a different order. :) |
Jethro42
08.02.21 | I've noticed that too Diva. It's not over till it's over, Twig, but you're in good position! |
someone
08.02.21 | anyway, i can't say i have the full confidence that i've made the right ranking (and this is not a ranking, just the 4 i find to be the best), but here we go anyway:
1. Hermann Szobel
2. Quiet Sun
3. Kollektiv
4. Regal Worm |
TwigTW
08.02.21 | ^Szobel at #1, I have full confidence in you ;-)
@ Jethro: As are you! This is where I historically get blown out of the water, lol, but anything could happen... |
Inoculaeted
08.02.21 | Rounding out my top 4 today. Love revisiting these. I'm less conflicted about my choices than I initially thought I'd be. I think it's only that 4th spot I'll need to sure up, but I'm pretty confident about a top 3. |
Jethro42
08.02.21 | Yesss Twig, finally! Kudos! |
Friday13th
08.02.21 | This is tough, but here it goes.
1. Regal Worm
2. Procol Harum
3. Seru Giran
4. Yolk |
Friday13th
08.02.21 | I can see a decent argument why any one of these should win. |
Inoculaeted
08.02.21 | 1. Jordsjo
2. Seru Giran - last 2m of noche de perros is my fav 2m of the tournament
3. Regal Worm
4. Yolk
These are the four I'd be most excited to revisit in upcoming rounds. Extremely tough choosing that 4th. Ibio, Quiet Sun, and Szobel are all right there for me. Seru Giran is so fucking well performed and fun that it snuck up on me as a contender. I remember enjoying it quite a bit but it wasn't in the first four I came up with. Quiet Sun and Szobel shrank a little bit on relisten, perhaps due to their erratic structures. Both are fantastic but are more in the "when I'm in the right mood" vein. Yolk and Regal Worm are both super weird in their own unique way and I love em for it. Jordsjo is my nominated champ for combining compositional balance with technicality and atmosphere. It's strong starting and strong finishing with a clean 40m runtime. Only excellent albums left here. |
Pangea
08.03.21 | okay after another listen of each album, i'm ready to cast my vote.
1. Regal Worm
2. Procol Harum
3. Yolk
4. Hermann Szobel
really liked jordsjo too, but that one unfortunately had to miss out |
Divaman
08.03.21 | So by my unofficial count right now, Regal Worm is in first, Hermann Szobel and Jordsjo are battling it out for second, and five different albums are battling it out for that last spot in the Final Four. |
TwigTW
08.03.21 | 1. Herman Szobel
2. Jordsjo
3. Regal Worm
4. Quiet Sun
It's a three-way tie for fourth for me: Quiet Sun, Kollektiv, and Yolk. Phil Manzanera pushed Quiet Sun just a hair above the other two. |
Friday13th
08.03.21 | I am not tallying until the end because it is a complicated calculation lol |
Inoculaeted
08.03.21 | “I can see a decent argument why any one of these should win.“
Agreed. I’m happy with any of those in the running as winner. The only album I seem to not feel as much as everyone else is Pendragon, even though it is admittedly masterfully performed. Just not my cup of tea I suppose. |
porcupinetheater
08.03.21 | Alright gonna go with
1. Yolk
2. Regal Worm
3. Kollektiv
4. Jordsjo
Biased choice, Yolk my pick, but I love that record from the bottom of my heart.
Regal Worm was the other had heard pre-competition, so also gets the familiarity benefit, but loved it from first listen, and the ground it covers cohesively is pre stunnin'
Kollektiv b/c hell yeah krautrock, riding out those longform motorik rhythms to snag on works with my lifestyle. And of all the straight ahead prog albums, Jordsjo has the most compelling atmospheres, the most vibrancy in the layers its putting together.
I would also like to subtract points from Pendragon if that is possible |
Pangea
08.03.21 | my last listen of pendragon didn't do it wonders tbh. it's pretty at times but it is so so corny |
porcupinetheater
08.03.21 | 1. Moose Loose
2. Moose Loose
3. Loose Moose
4. Moose Loose |
Pangea
08.03.21 | ^this endorsement is surely enough for moose loose to steal a semi final spot right? |
porcupinetheater
08.03.21 | C'mon Pange, we're couping this shit
Pendragon OUT
Moose Loose IN |
Pangea
08.03.21 | i'll set the mooses loose |
zakalwe
08.03.21 | The cheesiness is a real charmer with Pendragon. You can feel the joy. |
porcupinetheater
08.03.21 | In the sense that I can feel the shithammered townie pissing on my shoe is also approaching it from a place of joy |
Divaman
08.03.21 | I hate when that happens. |
Friday13th
08.04.21 | More like...Moose Lose ;)
Now I gotta make fun of mine as well. Syzygy? More like Sissy-G! |
Mythodea
08.04.21 | Having done my fair revisits, I think I will go with this order:
1. Seru Giran - La Grasa de las Capitales
2. Yolk - Solar
3. Regal Worm - Pig Views
4. Procol Harum - Live |
DePlazz
08.04.21 | Bookmarked, must czech |
bgillesp
08.05.21 | Nice with the Seru Giran love Myth. I’m the only one whos voted for Ibio still though I think |
MiloRuggles
08.05.21 | Comin' in H O T !
1. Yolk - o lawdy me what a gem
2. Jordsjo - snuck in a second listen when I was in the mood for proggy tomfoolery, and enjoyed this v much (I didn't even vote for it in round 1, whoops1)
3. Kollektiv - I'm selfish and subbed this album cause I like it so what fite me
4. Quiet Sun - I also trashed this album in the first round, but a second geez taught me that the fields of Canterbury are steeped in slowly unraveling at.mos.phere (album still ends shittily :( ):
Happy Thursday u cool cats
|
Mythodea
08.05.21 | @bgillesp Yeah, Seru Giran only lost by a hair in their round* and still might be one of the most memorable things on here! All 4 albums I've picked have been huge for me
*I mean for me, I went with Alas |
TheIntruder
08.05.21 | I have re-listened to all of my favorites and finally I am ready to vote. This was a tough decision but here they are my four candidates:
1. Quiet Sun
2. Jordsjo
3. Hermann Szobel
4. Pendragon |
bgillesp
08.06.21 | So 18 of us have voted now it seems. Excited to see the scoring system |
Friday13th
08.06.21 | OKAY! All tallied up. So the math is simple. The one that ranked "1" gets four points, the one ranked 2 gets three points, the one ranked 3 gets two points, and the one ranked 4 gets one point.
1. Regal Worm - 33 points
2. Jordsjo - 28 points
3. Hermann Szobel - 25 points
4. Yolk - 23 points |
Friday13th
08.06.21 | Next match is up and let's do that one more quickly, voting ends this Monday. |
Jethro42
08.06.21 | Good job, Friday, nonetheless! |
e210013
08.06.21 | I hope so. It seems to me that people is too much lazy in relation to voting. I think there's nothing new under the sun. So, please, vote in the next two or three days. In this part of the tourney people should must really know already their preferences. |
e210013
08.06.21 | I agree with Jethro. Great job Friday. You're the guy. Thanks for your patience and professionalism all over this difficult tourney. It wasn't an easy task, really. |
porcupinetheater
08.06.21 | Friday ur a beautiful mad lad, thank ewe |
bgillesp
08.06.21 | You’re awesome Friday! Who got 5th? |
Friday13th
08.09.21 | Quiet Sun got distant 5th at 17 points |