Artuma
10.21.19 | discuss. i'll keep count |
Relinquished
10.21.19 | 1 all the fuckin way |
Relinquished
10.21.19 | also panopticon would be in the same era |
JohnnyoftheWell
10.21.19 | 1 all the fuckin way [2]
Salvation>[Panopticon]>Oceanic>>EOES |
Keyblade
10.21.19 | havent heard either of these for donkeys years, but def 3 |
StarlessCore
10.21.19 | Eye masterpiece salvation near masterpiece oceanic garbage |
Artuma
10.21.19 | "also panopticon would be in the same era"
chose oceanic because it came first and was a big leap from celestial |
JohnnyoftheWell
10.21.19 | "Eye masterpiece salvation near masterpiece oceanic garbage"
Terrible opinion
"chose oceanic because it came first and was a big leap from celestial"
Shrewd and fair, but by that logic A Sun That Never Sets could just as easily be up there (now THAT would make this tough)
|
Relinquished
10.21.19 | ok but all three came out in 2004 and not Oceanic. if you wanna put what were leaps towards their masterpieces then that's different. |
Artuma
10.21.19 | i was actually originally going for just salvation and oceanic but then i figured 'hey i guess neurosis went for kinda something similar with teoes so why not make it a wicked threeway' |
bigguytoo9
10.22.19 | I like Oceanic the most on this list for sure. |
Sinternet
10.22.19 | 3 is clearly the best of these |
calmrose
10.22.19 | Oceanic |
BlazinBlitzer
10.22.19 | All of them overrated.
Jk I'll pick 1 I guess. |
Coast
10.22.19 | Salvation |
Demon of the Fall
10.22.19 | 3 > 1 >>>>>> 2
Having to choose between Salvation and TEOES shouldn't be legal though, it could've gone either way, both are perfection and in my top 10 albums of all time. ISIS' popularity continues to confuse me to this day, cool album mind. |
qwenta
10.22.19 | The ocean - Pelagial is way better and the genere's peak.
Of this 3, I pick Isis - Oceanic. |
Demon of the Fall
10.22.19 | Pelagial is not even their best album. |
dedex
10.22.19 | "The ocean - Pelagial is way better and the genere's peak."
say what again |
dedex
10.22.19 | Rn would have to go with 1, but it's been some time since I jammed all 3 |
Scheumke
10.22.19 | I vote precambrian. Three years later than these, but still. |
qwenta
10.22.19 | Precambriam is overrated coz full screams. Pelagial is better. Paleozoic is better. |
Artuma
10.22.19 | "The ocean - Pelagial is way better and the genere's peak."
uh oh |
NeroCorleone80
10.22.19 | Eye |
Pikazilla
10.22.19 | The Eye of Every Storm |
Relinquished
10.22.19 | qwenta is hereby illiterate |
JohnnyoftheWell
10.22.19 | Pelagial is one of the 3.5est 3.5s ever |
FurtherDown
10.22.19 | Salvation all the way. |
DominionMM1
10.22.19 | teoes for sure |
Pikazilla
10.22.19 | Pelagial is one of the 3.5est 3.5s ever
Shots fired |
StarlessCore
10.22.19 | Actually its trash af |
Itwasthatwas
10.22.19 | 3 then 1 then 2. 3 and 1 are so different though it’s hard to compare |
mindleviticus
10.22.19 | Oceanic |
NOTINTHEFACE
10.22.19 | Oceanic, easy. |
Pikazilla
10.22.19 | Every time I see your username on the news page, I think it reads NOTINTHEFANNY and click on the link and get disappointed. Every goddamn time. Sorry for random post. |
Demon of the Fall
10.22.19 | Bad horny Pika.
Damn, now TEOES is winning I want to vote for Salvation instead. Conflicted. |
Pikazilla
10.22.19 | I have all three fived. It's a win-win-win situation for me. |
Demon of the Fall
10.22.19 | It's a win-lose-win situation for me, but currently I'm 'winning'. Woo! |
Artuma
10.22.19 | can't change your vote |
Demon of the Fall
10.22.19 | It wasn't a serious suggestion, can't be rigging shit like that. |
NOTINTHEFACE
10.22.19 | Pika i'm legitimately sorry about that lol. My teenage self who came up with the name was too dumb to think of that, and clearly too dumb not to submit an all cops username smh |
Demon of the Fall
10.22.19 | You can request a change in the meds thread on the forum, I think, well you could before. Not sure why you should be expected to think of that regardless, I certainly don't make the association, Pika is just a randy rodent. |
NOTINTHEFACE
10.22.19 | Yeah I know that I'm just a lazy fatass who can't be bothered to reset his forum password. |
SgtShock
10.23.19 | Oceanic for the snare sound alone. |
Deez
10.23.19 | I will very rarely go against Neurosis but Im gonna go Oceanic off the simple fact there isnt a dud on it where as I think 'burn' is one of my least fave openers from Neurosis but its tight |
Relinquished
10.23.19 | throwaway untitled tracks are duds |
Deez
10.23.19 | Youre a dud
HA!
take that |
calmrose
10.23.19 | damn |
Lord(e)Po)))ts
10.23.19 | ocean |
Artuma
10.23.19 | current scoreboard:
teoes and oceanic tied with 8, salvation not far behind with 6 |
JohnnyoftheWell
10.23.19 | So everything is back to front, nice lol |
Deez
10.23.19 | No thats actually perfect |
qwenta
10.23.19 | Salvation is easily worst CoL for me, I'm surprised so many ppl think is awesome lol |
sizeofanocean
10.23.19 | "Oceanic for the snare sound alone."
[2] |