EuphoricDysphoria81
10.05.10 | Flame me, faggots!® |
qwe3
10.05.10 | 7 is just a no
it's like saying the best rock album ever is a doors album. it's just not true |
BigHans
10.05.10 | I thought Aggression was the best melo-hardcore? Agree with 6 |
ConsiderPhlebas
10.05.10 | fucking yes to 2 and 10 |
SeaAnemone
10.05.10 | Emery's latest may just be post-hardcore's finest ever! |
EuphoricDysphoria81
10.05.10 | Lol Sea.
I like how qwe thinks his opinions are relevant. |
ConsiderPhlebas
10.05.10 | Something tells me that exclamation mark isn't sincere |
jingledeath
10.05.10 | what qwe said |
qwe3
10.05.10 | "Something tells me that exclamation mark isn't sincere"
in the original it is
and dude i know so much more about post metal than you also i have better taste so yeah |
EuphoricDysphoria81
10.05.10 | Yeah, that makes sense, Qwe. Keep up the good work doing nothing with your life. Next! |
Pyosisified
10.05.10 | hahaha |
Inveigh
10.05.10 | well yeah I think Oceanic is the best post-metal album ever released by a band not named Neurosis.. so, you just left out a couple of words
also, it's much easier to argue against Biggie being the best lyricist of all time than it is to argue against that being the greatest hip hop album ever |
EuphoricDysphoria81
10.05.10 | Blake, I'd agree that Neurosis is much better than Isis, but Neurosis isn't post-metal.
There. I said it. |
DiceMan
10.05.10 | 7 lol just... just... no... |
EuphoricDysphoria81
10.05.10 | Diceman lol just... just... no... |
wyankeif1337
10.05.10 | Diceman lol just... just... no... [2]
I think Panopticon beats out Oceanic, though... |
qwe3
10.05.10 | " Keep up the good work doing nothing with your life. Next!"
don't know what that has to do with anything but ad hominems aside your thoughts on post metal are still retarded. neurosis created post metal dude. and that's not why they should be here, its because no one else comes close. not even CoL or Rosetta or whatever. not even Streetcleaner comes close |
EuphoricDysphoria81
10.05.10 | Lol, listen to Neurosis, then listen to the rest of post-metal. Tell me how Neurosis is just "post-metal" please. |
GnarlyShillelagh
10.05.10 | Panopticon is better than Oceanic
36 Chambers, Liquid Swords, and Lifestylez... are all better than 6. |
qwe3
10.05.10 | dude are you serious....
you don't have to exclusively play "post metal" to have released the best post metal material. Neurosis has released about 6 or 7 albums better than oceanic that are definitely post metal. just because it's not boring as shit doesn't mean it isn't post metal |
EuphoricDysphoria81
10.05.10 | Nope, gnarlyshillelagh. I was expecting that from the Sputnik crowd, considering if one elite says the album is the best, the rest of Sputnik follows suit in hopes of being "elite." Good try, though. |
EuphoricDysphoria81
10.05.10 | "you don't have to exclusively play "post metal" to have released the best post metal material. Neurosis has released about 6 or 7 albums better than oceanic that are definitely post metal. just because it's not boring as shit doesn't mean it isn't post metal"
Lol, so Isis is boring as shit? Wow, your intelligence meter went down about 2 notches with that comment, Qwe. |
qwe3
10.05.10 | isis isn't boring as shit but most of post metal is.
isis was good till oceanic. from then on they blow. and they were only good at the start because they basically worshipped neurosis. oceanic was good because it was a balance between their own sorta style and what they'd been trying to emulate.
but now they're shit. good thing they broke up their next album would have put the whole world to sleep |
EuphoricDysphoria81
10.05.10 | Oh, I do agree with that, qwe. After Oceanic, it's been downhill. |
Inveigh
10.05.10 | yeah I've always viewed everything from Enemy of the Sun onwards as post-metal... but at the same time I think Oceanic is the best non-Neurosis post-metal album I've heard. I've never listened to Cult of Luna though |
EuphoricDysphoria81
10.05.10 | Cult of Luna is fantastic. Amazing band.
I guess I just don't see Neurosis as post-metal. I never really have. They have the elements of it, but they have so much more going on than every other "post-metal" band out there. |
Inveigh
10.05.10 | that's true... but they also invented the genre. that's a little Chinese riddle for you Rhonda... |
EuphoricDysphoria81
10.05.10 | Oh, they definitely invented the genre, but I think it was more indirectly than anything. Listen, if we're all going to call Neurosis post-metal, Through Silver in Blood would be here instead of Oceanic, but I wouldn't be able to forgive myself for doing Neurosis, nor Isis, that injustice. |
qwe3
10.05.10 | inveigh check out The Beyond and Salvation. Those are the best CoL releases |
EuphoricDysphoria81
10.05.10 | ^
Wow, qwe comes back and totally redeems himself with those recs. |
qwe3
10.05.10 | Through Silver In Blood is basically the perfect post metal album though. That and The Eye of Every Storm |
Inveigh
10.05.10 | yeah Salvation's been on my list of albums to get for a long time. would you say The Beyond is better? |
EuphoricDysphoria81
10.05.10 | qwe, I see where you're coming from, but I disagree, respectfully of course.
The Beyond is better, Blake. Not a lot better, but better. |
qwe3
10.05.10 | I dunno man it depends on what you like. I prefer the Beyond just because it has a rawer sound to it and it keeps it more interesting. |
Inveigh
10.05.10 | t'word, oh baby i like it rawwwww |
AnotherBrick
10.05.10 | where are all the good genres? |
ConsiderPhlebas
10.05.10 | The Eternal Kingdom and Somewhere Along the Highway dick all over The Beyond and Salvation |
EuphoricDysphoria81
10.05.10 | They'll be on pt. 2, anotherbrick.
Jewel, no they don't. |
BigHans
10.05.10 | Aside from being massively boring, post metal always brings out elitist discussions that bring the lulz |
qwe3
10.05.10 | eternal kingdom sucked ass |
EuphoricDysphoria81
10.05.10 | It didn't suck ass, qwe, but it wasn't nearly as good as The Beyond or Salvation. |
ConsiderPhlebas
10.05.10 | You've mistaken the act of dicking with sucking there qwe |
qwe3
10.05.10 | no i've just recognized a crap album |
accompliceofmydeath
10.05.10 | 1- go back to being a proponent for 13 Songs
2- Jersey's Best Dancer's? :(
3- Black Flag- Damaged
9- agree
10- I'm not sure, but I wouldn't pick Shai
Commence with tasteful arguing. |
EuphoricDysphoria81
10.05.10 | I hate you accomplice. |
accompliceofmydeath
10.05.10 | Glad we could talk this over. |
EuphoricDysphoria81
10.05.10 | It's good to clear the air. |
Deviant.
10.05.10 | "neurosis created post metal dude."
Oceanic is actually credited as the first post metal album
You're missing a few genres Pit |
EuphoricDysphoria81
10.05.10 | Once again, dev, if you look about 10 comments above you, this is part 1 of a 3 part series of lists that will dominate and change the way Sputnik looks at music. |
qwe3
10.05.10 | "Oceanic is actually credited as the first post metal album"
yeah. by isis fans and other people who know nothing about sludge or post metal |
EuphoricDysphoria81
10.05.10 | Okay, qwe. Calm down, calm down. No need to have your period on my thread. I don't like the color red. |
qwe3
10.05.10 | no one's overreacting. you just want someone to be so you can make shitty "must be that time of month" calls.
all i'm doing is asserting something that's actually a reality, and what i was doing before was asserting my opinion, which is naturally better than everyone else's |
Deviant.
10.05.10 | "Once again, dev, if you look about 10 comments above you, this is part 1 of a 3 part series of lists that will dominate and change the way Sputnik looks at music."
Really couldn't be bothered reading them all
"yeah. by isis fans and other people who know nothing about sludge or post metal"
k
|
Maniac!
10.05.10 | TsiB is the best post metal album.
if we assume (wrongly) that neurosis isnt post metal, then you should have panopticon on here |
EuphoricDysphoria81
10.05.10 | Where ya been, botched abortion? |
BigHans
10.05.10 | lmfao |
qwe3
10.05.10 | panopticon is a joooke |
patroneyes
10.05.10 | 3 is correct and 1 is very different from what i would put |
Maniac!
10.05.10 | at least 3 is correct |
EuphoricDysphoria81
10.05.10 | Brandon's father: "At least he's not gay!" |
Emim
10.05.10 | super uber mega major gay list. |
EuphoricDysphoria81
10.05.10 | Emim: super uber mega major gay user. |
cvlts
10.05.10 | wtf? 2? no descendents. |
EuphoricDysphoria81
10.05.10 | Dude, descendents are pop punk(mostly on the punk side), not melodic hardcore. |
cvlts
10.05.10 | lol u high? they may have influenced it but its that band that made gorilla biscuits and lifetime who they were. |
EuphoricDysphoria81
10.05.10 | I'm a little high, but it's not because I want to be lol. I understand that, This Life, because melodic hardcore has some elements of early pop punk in it, but that doesn't make the descendents melodic hardcore by any sense of the word. |
