Puzzles
11.07.12 | Chris's voice was so much better back then, though. |
Foaming
11.07.12 | Very tough choice, both comebacks are excellent. I think I'm leaning a little more towards KA though.
Fantastic songwriting as usual, really good collection of songs. |
FCY
11.07.12 | King Animal for me. I've always enjoyed Soundgarden more than AIC because they are more diverse and experimental. |
VermicideReloadead
11.07.12 | Hard choice kid, but I have to choose king animal because I prefer Cornell's voice over Duvall. Otherwise Duvall was a good replacement of Layne. |
InFiction
11.07.12 | Black Gives Way To Blue, but I am a bit of an Alice In Chains fanboy. |
Cipieron
11.07.12 | King Animal no question |
PistolPete
11.07.12 | Iunno BGWTB is an amazing album and while King Animal sounded good, it would be tough to top that one. |
truekebabpower
11.07.12 | BGWTB no question |
anarchistfish
11.07.12 | I gave BGWTB a 4.5 so I doubt king animal will top it |
savaah
11.07.12 | Too soon to tell, I already fucked bacchanals with BGWTB although KA is giving me a nice blow for the moment. |
Relinquished
11.07.12 | king animal
bgwtb had some meh songs |
PastorOfMupp3ts
11.07.12 | still waiting for that new nirvana album
|
Sapient.
11.07.12 | didnt think i'd say this, but even though BGWTB was a fantastic comeback and i overall prefer AIC, King Animal is the better record of the 2 |
VermicideReloadead
11.07.12 | Me too, Alice in Chains is my favorite grunge band and their comeback was solid. But king animal is more consistent. |
slagun
11.07.12 | Im not entirely sure just yet but it seems like it's gonna be King Animal for me, having that said, BGWTB was a serious kick-ass album and I'm happy that an even better album from a Seattle band is gonna top it |
Maniac!
11.07.12 | BGWTB
if you disagree, you're an idiot |
truekebabpower
11.07.12 | BGWTB is a 5 for me and King Animal so far 3-3.5, so it's really no competition, and AIC managed to pull it off with a new singer so AIC hands down |
Puzzles
11.08.12 | "I've always enjoyed Soundgarden more than AIC because they are more diverse and experimental."
I always thought there were some extremely diverse and experimental moments on the self titled, even Dirt. On another note, I've more or less gotten used to Chris' voice on this record and it's as if it never changed. |
Gecimen
11.08.12 | I'm a fan of both bands and BGWTB pleased me a lot. It sounded like self titled AIC album and had some songs that are as good as old AIC. But KA is totally in a different league, now. It's a fresh, solid, rich and heavy album and it still manages to sound oldschool. No need to be opinionated, give it a go I'd say. |
Puzzles
11.08.12 | I'm glad I'm not the only one! |
