SmurkinGherkin
User

Soundoffs 2
Album Ratings 408
Objectivity 75%

Last Active 09-03-13 11:34 am
Joined 05-27-09

Forum Posts 111
Review Comments 1,770

 Lists
10.23.12 The Tallest Man On Earth @ Hmv Forum Lo10.21.12 How Do You Rate Albums?
02.02.12 Rec Me Balls To The Wall Electronic09.13.11 Personal Statement
08.31.11 Reading Festival 201108.31.10 Reading Festival
06.19.10 Moar Indie Pop Plz01.09.10 Responses To Me Setting A Lady Gaga Lyr
12.31.09 New Years Eve Plans?12.26.09 Made A Last Fm Last Night
11.21.09 Ipod Or Zune?11.16.09 6th Form Applications Suck
10.03.09 Dubstep, Anyone?07.10.09 So All My Friends Went To Guilfest
07.08.09 Need Some Non Heavy Music...07.02.09 The Blue Album Ranked
06.16.09 Me Needs Some Help...06.09.09 Argh Fucking Bnp
More »

How Do You Rate Albums?

Curious as to what criteria different people ascribe to the rating system on rhere and what rralbums need to do to meet those criteria.
1Arcade Fire
Funeral


5: Personal Classic, essentially perfect.
2Elliott Smith
XO


4.5: Amazing, pretty much perfect but not quite.
3Burial
Kindred


4: Brilliant, highly recommended. Heavy rotation for a fairly long period of time.
4Sleigh Bells
Reign of Terror


3.5: Very good, recommended. Decent rotation.
5Of Monsters and Men
My Head is an Animal


3: Decent, worth a listen.
6dredg
El Cielo


2.5: Alright, mediocre, nothing special.
7Architects
Daybreaker


2: Boring, bland on the point of poor. Wouldn't bother.
8Muse
The Resistance


1.5: Poor, steer clear.
9Millionaires
Bling Bling Bling!


1: Absolute wank.
Show/Add Comments (54)

FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy