|kill me for 10, but they're part of the reason so many bands sound the same|
|because a lot of bands emulate them? how does that warrant a place on this list.|
and fftl were pretty different with their first albums but yes their selftitled is a pile of shit
|I Am Ghost used to bring the genre a good name. They used to be unique until Kerith left. All hell broke loose than. Lovers Requiem will always be a great album.|
|You should be slapped with a fish for 10...|
6 and 9 used to be pretty cool but not so much anymore...
Again...I really don't understand why 10 is on here...
|Last two don't belong. I Am Ghost didn't do anything groundbreaking, perhaps, but what they did do was done right. Was...because the components that set them apart have left the band. But for Lover's Requiem and We Are Always Searching, they gave the genre hope.|
Underoath is the same, but in the opposite way. They didn't do the genre any favors until their later two albums (though I still really like "TOCS"). "Define..." and "...Sound of Separation" are both amazing records, and give a lot of credibility to Christian Hardcore IMO.
The rest I haven't really heard enough, but from what others have told me, they probably earn their spots (but I like #'s 1 and 6).
|Underoath's last two albums are pretty awesome and not generic tbh|
|underoath and atreyu are at least popular... thats different than just sucking in 'the underground' right? ;-)|
|needs more Converge.|
|Yeahhh... 10 have always been pressing the boundaries of their music, even when they sucked. At any rate, you can't blame them for staying the same.|
and 6 used to be quite good, but now, yes.
|10 doesn't deserve a place on this list. The rest do though...well, apart from 1 and 5 but I havent heard them, so they might.|
|i agree with all the other Underoath lovers here. their last 2 albums definitely don't give their genre a bad name|
|I dont know why 10 is on there. With every album they are bringing something new to the table. Creating a new sound. But the rest I see where you're coming from.|
|you suck so hard|
|umm and what bands may I ask do a better job? more than half of these bands are some oof my favorites|
|Take Underoath off & yep you've got a good generic band list, not necessarily bad bands though.|
|Have you listened to I Swear... from Inhale Exhale? That is way better than most of the crap coming out now! It avoids most of the crap bands are doing now! |
1 and 10 should not be on this list.
|screamed vocals, sung choruses, pseudo-intellectual song titles.....all stuff IE and dozens of bands do. I gave the album a 3 btw.|
Also don't bump lists that are more than 7 months old k thanks.
|i like early fftl|
|apparently you like year old lists too. |
|Yeah, they're unorginal. But I Am Ghost has brought something different, some kind of Gothic feel to Post-Hardcore...|
|Agreed although IAG stopped beign relevant after Lovers Requiem.|
|i would have agreed with you if you made this a couple years ago|
|These are bands that bands rip off though|
|Stop stating the obvious, talking about how generic metalcore is generic in itself. |
Lot's of alt/indie that sounds the same ;) Why not get on that.
|old list |
|SKSK comes from a Cap'n Jazz song, which is awesome|