thebhoy
12.19.08 | City and Colour and Anathallo suck. Grand Archives was really really average, other then that from what I've heard, the list is decent. |
myhigherpie
12.19.08 | disagree completely.
needs more metal...
PtH's fortress needs to be on here.
Meshuggah's Obzen
Enslaved's Vertebrae
Opeth's Watershed
Amon Amarth's twilight of the thunder god |
OllieS
12.19.08 | ^ PTH don't need to be on any list. |
Electric City
12.19.08 | whoa its so weird to see someone like the envy corps too. |
Mendigo
12.19.08 | I don't think this is bad, it would be much worse if it had Protest the Hero on it :)
there are some albums here I dislike (6, 10, 19 and 40 most of all) but I'm happy with most of them |
donovr
12.19.08 | Write an album better than City and Colour and Anathallo and then tell me they suck.
I doubt I'll add much metal to my list because I don't frankly like metal too much. |
LittleTinGodess
12.20.08 | donovr - i hate your last comment. I dont get why some people think we cant critise others. You read it all the time when some says a sports person or musician or actor sucks, "Well i'd like to see you do better so shut up". I dont get it. If a taxi driver goes the wrong way you can complain, I a chef fucks up for order you can complain, i am a teacher and if im shit at teaching, parents blow their minds. Why are some people so precious we cannot critise their work. Its bullshit. |
seanmc22
12.21.08 | Top list. Finally a list on here that isn't so completely obsessive with metal. Good work donovr. |
barbarian
12.25.08 | CITY AND COLOUR SUCKS
HAR HAR HAR |
donovr
01.18.09 | Your argument has no bearing in the realm of opinion. One ought to criticize if a taxi driver, chef, or teacher makes mistakes. There is an objective upon which both parties have agreed. In contrast, when I put up a top 40 list. The list is relative to what I like. To criticize me as if I have an inferior knowledge of good vs. bad music is in poor taste. For example, saying an artist sucks because he doesn't sweep pick on his guitar is ludicrous because it assumes a particular definition of good music. To the point, good music is relative to the ears that listen to it. So don't belittle another human being for the sake of musical taste. |
