I used to listen to the same songs a lot, but then stopped and started listening to albums as a whole more. Therefore, my top played songs are mostly made up of my older favorite bands.
Just checked, and there are only 5 bands on on my top 25 most played lists, Avenged Sevenfold, Incubus, Red Hot Chili Peppers, System of a Down, and Velvet Revolver, 13 of those songs are from Incubus, shows how obsessed I used to be with them (and I still love them)
My top 5:
Incubus-New Skin (243)
Velvet Revolver-Slither (210)
Incubus-Take Me to Your Leader (168)