Pikazilla
01.11.21 | agreed |
Veldin
01.11.21 | You're a damn fool |
parksungjoon
01.11.21 | never seen this list before |
Pikazilla
01.11.21 | Apart from 2, 4 and 9, I'd say he is very much on point |
Veldin
01.11.21 | Tho Carrie & Lowell is pretty overrated imo |
Pikazilla
01.11.21 | And 1 is a classic
Carrie & Lowell is trash, yea |
Ryus
01.11.21 | never seen this list before [2] |
rellik009
01.11.21 | remove 5 and 10 and we're good. |
goonmob
01.11.21 | never |
Emim
01.11.21 | Add 5 and 10 a second time |
JohnnyoftheWell
01.11.21 | [2]
|
rellik009
01.11.21 | I'll have to confiscate your vinyl collection then |
JohnnyoftheWell
01.11.21 | You couldn't confiscate a box of tissues |
rellik009
01.11.21 | A box of tissues would be useful to our motherland. |
cordwainerbird
01.11.21 | id say queen is dead does not suck but it IS morrissey on vocals so. list checks out |
Sinternet
01.11.21 | brave |
sonictheplumber
01.11.21 | thats fine |
RadioSuicide
01.11.21 | no primus fake fan |
rabidfish
01.11.21 | I agree with the sentiment most of these are actually worthless/mediocre/trash |
fogza
01.11.21 | 1,2,3,7,8 and 9 are classics. So pretty good list, you got close with 40% |
rellik009
01.11.21 | primus sucks |
Sinternet
01.11.21 | all of these except 10 rule ahrd m/ |
kalkwiese
01.11.21 | I guess that photo is the real you |
ian b
01.11.21 | 6 and 9 are def classics in their respective genres, and 3 + 5 are also great if you have the patience for them, but otherwise yeah i mean i thought most active users (as in excluding lurkers) were p much in agreement that all of these are way too hyped, especially 1, 2, and 10. also fuck morrissey |
Morningrise767
01.11.21 | 3 and 4 are great stfu |
ian b
01.11.21 | 3 is great if youre in the mood for it but 4 has aged like dogshit |
RadioSuicide
01.11.21 | stop |
ian b
01.11.21 | not until yall say fuck morrissey |
RadioSuicide
01.11.21 | you're upsetting my cognitive dissonance ian pump the brakes and then come to a complete stop |
Egarran
01.11.21 | Funny, I've had Paranoid Android on the mind for days.
Have to admit it's an amazing song. |
MO
01.11.21 | Def 2 yep |
RadioSuicide
01.11.21 | i will defend every album here except funeral that shit sucks |
JohnnyoftheWell
01.11.21 | Funeral is the best album on this list lmao |
RadioSuicide
01.11.21 | too all over the place for me. i guess for 04 it was ahead of its time, didn't get around to it til 2012 or 13 iirc |
fogza
01.11.21 | Lol OP is probably a troll, but it sounds like you genuinely think funeral is a bad album. So weird |
faustuscopernicum
01.11.21 | 8, Yeahhh!!! Sucks |
Rowhaus
01.11.21 | 4 is the only good one |
gryndstone
01.11.21 | 2 7 and 10 yeah those suck especially 2 there's literally nothing good about 2 |
Doibhin69
01.11.21 | this list is a big oof |
Cimnele
01.11.21 | 10 acclaimed albums that are pretty good |
dbizzles
01.11.21 | I can get on board with most of this, but they are mostly all just overrated. |
JeetJeet
01.11.21 | Yea all that shits pretty weak except for 6 |
RadioSuicide
01.11.21 | "OP is probably a troll, but it sounds like you genuinely think funeral is a bad album. So weird" not at all it's a solid 3.3, but compared to the insane hype it gets..... it doesn't deliver for me, at least not for longer than sporadic 10-20 second intervals throughout the album |
Egarran
01.11.21 | agerd |
NeroCorleone
01.11.21 | agreed with all but 5 |
LeddSledd
01.11.21 | "overrated" more than anything with these albums, but that Sufjan was pretty lame yeah |
sixdegrees
01.11.21 | Ah |
RadioSuicide
01.11.21 | hey nero i remember you from the evil heat album thread a few months back. oxbow shits on all of these guys so if that's the line I am now resigning from defending any of these albums |
NeroCorleone
01.11.21 | I like Swans, but yeah Oxbow > |
wham49
01.11.21 | 1 doesnt suck but def. not as good as everybody says |
RadioSuicide
01.11.21 | i still need to borrow gira's autobiography from my buddy, he said it's fucking nuts |
combustion07
01.11.21 | Two Headed Boy is my jam but the rest of the album I never return to. Never got into Radiohead either. Remember enjoying 3 but I don't know if I've heard anything else here in full. Maybe the Tool ages ago |
RadioSuicide
01.11.21 | fucking love nmh but growing up they were always synonymous with p4k dipshits |
ian b
01.11.21 | idc radio it's still fuck morrissey til the day i die |
RadioSuicide
01.11.21 | reported |
Squiggly
01.11.21 | Should I give a 2 2 2? I think so |
Squiggly
01.11.21 | 6 and 8 are the shit tho |
ian b
01.11.21 | fuck morrissey, also yes Squiggly that is the correct rating for that album |
ian b
01.11.21 | i will die for 6, but yeah 8 is shit compared to all the records that tackle that concept way more impactfully |
RadioSuicide
01.11.21 | o yea what records would those be ian |
RadioSuicide
01.11.21 | would love to hear them |
aydross121
01.11.21 | My teenage dream ended |
SharkTooth
01.11.21 | 6 is the only album I have strong feelings on, so.. good list I guess(?) |
RadioSuicide
01.11.21 | "My teenage dream ended" welp when i'm wrong i'm wrong |
heck
01.11.21 | 4 and 9 have no place on this list |
EddieMarais
01.11.21 | lmao this list is wack |
ian b
01.12.21 | My Teenage Dream Ended is genuinely more enjoyable and entertaining than every record here besides 6 (and i actually love 9, plus i like 3 and 5 when i have the time for that kind of shit) |
ian b
01.12.21 | also 4 deserves to be here fuck Morrissey, he's one of the only musicians besides Jesse Lacey that's genuinely tainted an entire bands' discography for me |
DaveT0738
01.12.21 | 9 and 10 definitely don't suck |
ian b
01.12.21 | i understand why 9 gets the hate that it does but idc shit is still a phat 4.3-4.8/5 record imo |
courthouse69
01.12.21 | 100% agree on 2, tool sucks too |
fogza
01.12.21 | "i will die for 6, but yeah 8 is shit compared to all the records that tackle that concept way more impactfully"
I found it pretty heartbreaking so I'm not sure what records you speak of, they must be devastating |
goonmob
01.12.21 | yes thats me in my picture lol. ive tried so hard to like the smiths :( id say 9 is the closest to not sucking. still sucks. |
RadioSuicide
01.12.21 | Hatful of Hollow and Louder than Bombs prob won't change your mind but i prefer them to their studio LPs. |
naughtcturnal
01.12.21 | 9 is literally the best rock album from the 2000s |
sonictheplumber
01.12.21 | can we get this shite off the front page and spread some positivity? come bump some talking heads you fuckin cunts |
RadioSuicide
01.12.21 | lmfao alright I'm in |
gravityswitch
01.12.21 | You shut your whore mouth about GYBE right now. |
rellik009
01.12.21 | Brit gangsters itt |
parksungjoon
09.07.21 | yea |