Mort.: Review a random album game 2023

Mort. 02.03.23	hmmm now is also a good time to point out that i have a list of albums that need reviews that always needs suggestions https://www.sputnikmusic.com/list.php?memberid=1034844&listid=200131 and i will nominate - please inform the captain this is a hijack - defeat or humiliate the united states of america
Zac124 02.03.23	Diablo Swing Orchestra - Swagger and Stroll Down the Rabbit Hole
JohnnyoftheWell 02.03.23	Astrobrite - Whitenoise Superstar lfg
Mort. 02.03.23	added
DadKungFu 02.03.23	Nominating Andrew Hill - Point of Departure
someone 02.03.23	i would've loved to join in (and by god i'm trying to write more now), but i haven't even finished my last review assignment yet. but maybe maybe
Mort. 02.03.23	the review doesnt have to be amazing. im trying to get into the habit of just writing and not overthinking. quantity is practice for quality
Demon of the Fall 02.03.23	I should really consider that perspective I'll get thinking
SlothcoreSam 02.03.23	Ok why not Egschiglen - Zazal
Demon of the Fall 02.03.23	'Xiu Xiu - Angel Guts: Red Classroom' I'm too intimidated to review this one myself, so unlucky punks... (am also worried about how this might go, but it might be interesting to find out!)
anat 02.03.23	I nominate the wedding present - watusi!!!
DavidYowi 02.03.23	There’s no review for Big Country’s Steeltown There should be a review of Big Country’s Steeltown
cor22222 02.03.23	I want to nominate Viagra Boys - Street Worms to review
Mort. 02.03.23	added
pizzamachine 02.03.23	Nominating Anubis Gate - A Perfect Forever
BitterJalapenoJr 02.03.23	Nominating Punchline - 37 Everywhere
Trifolium 02.03.23	Yes yes yes please! Count me in. I nominate: Weval - Weval
PitchforkArms 02.03.23	Haven’t written a review in YEARS, but I will throw my hat in the ring… I’m nominating Billie Holiday’s self-titled Commodore Records release. Some of these old jazz releases are annoying to track down and have lots of slightly different versions, so I’m just going to attach a Spotify link (: https://open.spotify.com/album/4MkdTflpaaGGcXb5vtOYRs?si=e_c8t7hoSg2CqLzRlZxjzg
Trifolium 02.03.23	Ooooooooooh nice one! We can always do with more jazz around here 😍
mkmusic1995 02.03.23	Dig, Lazarus, Dig by Nick Cave and The Bad Seeds
Mort. 02.03.23	added
tyman128 02.03.23	Freakin loved this a few years ago when I first started reviews, definitely gonna need to jump in on this! idle threat - Blurred Visions
AsleepInTheBack 02.03.23	Gidge - Autumn Bells
Trifolium 02.03.23	Oooh nice, Gidge!
JohnnyoftheWell 02.03.23	o shit forgot Autumn Bells and Dig Lazarus had no revs good luck to anyone writing on them or Xiu Xiu lol
MillionDead 02.04.23	I’m down. Cult Ritual - Cult Ritual
Sinternet 02.04.23	ooh might as well join in this time i'll nominate Catherine Ribeiro + 2 Bis - s/t
LouBreed 02.04.23	Van Der Graf Generator - Do Not Disturb (2016). I've been meaning to write a review for that for ages, but maybe someone else will do harder, better, faster, stronger.
AsleepInTheBack 02.04.23	Oh boy some of these recs are scaring me lol someone submit Converge’s debut
someone 02.04.23	I kinda want to review the Weval debut, but idk if my head will produce the words for it
Demon of the Fall 02.04.23	Praying for one of these, not saying which as I think the powers that be may be purposefully ‘challenging’ with their selections
someone 02.04.23	so screw it, i'm in Mazzy Star - She Hangs Brightly
someone 02.04.23	damn, that Cult Ritual album looks gnarly. gonna check that for sure
JohnnyoftheWell 02.04.23	mort gimme album distribute this shit release the hounddogs
theBoneyKing 02.04.23	I’ve been wanting to write more, this seems a good enough way to force myself to do so. I’ll nominate Bedhead - WhatFunLifeWas
anat 02.04.23	@gene why don’t you review using clipart
Mort. 02.04.23	guys instead of the 10th we will give it to the end of the weekend. so either sunday night or monday morning i will distribute picks.
Zig 02.04.23	you can remove 5 from the list
Mort. 02.04.23	i need to message dadkungfu now because of your shenanigans, how dare you
Zig 02.04.23	can i nominate a record?
Mort. 02.04.23	yes if youre willing to review an album on the list once they all get assigned
Zig 02.04.23	Fausto - Por Este Rio Acima it's a 60min double record. is it ok ? i will, Mort. you have my word
Trifolium 02.04.23	Yeeeeeeeessssss gene that's such a nice pick, more Maaazzzzzzyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy!!!!
Mort. 02.04.23	yeah thats fine 60-80 mins is acceptable double record length, just not gonna be making anyone listen to like a 2 hour long record multiple times you know
PitchforkArms 02.04.23	Hey Mort. Hate to be a stickler here, but I don’t think the addition you’ve included is the right one for the Billie holiday record. Any chance you could look at the Spotify link and possibly connect the dots? (:
Mort. 02.04.23	ah so its the album thats actually listed as 'volume 2' in our database?
DadKungFu 02.04.23	K, new one: Swamp Dogg - Total Destruction to Your Mind
PumpBoffBag 02.04.23	On this for sure Mobb Deep - Amerikaz Nightmare
JohnnyoftheWell 02.04.23	BOFF
PumpBoffBag 02.04.23	The party’s arrived
deathofasalesman 02.05.23	Drug Church - Hit Your Head i'm down for cult ritual tbh
Mort. 02.05.23	last calls for nominations you have until midnight tonight (uk time)
theBoneyKing 02.05.23	Are you gonna be assigning the albums randomly? I’ll do whatever I get I just know there’s a lot of these that I won’t be able to do justice lol
PitchforkArms 02.05.23	@mort Lol nope, shit let me do some rooting around and maybe I can clean up the Billie holiday page while I’m at it. It’s a mess of improper additions and whatnot. When are you dishing out albums?
Mort. 02.05.23	so when i asked for a record that didnt have a review in the database, you recced me an album not even entered in the database properly?? (im just joshing)
Demon of the Fall 02.05.23	Yeah, as much as I’m up for anything, Boney may have a point unless we want a collection of very ill-informed reviews 😄 Maybe SOME vague ‘matching’ could be done?
Mort. 02.05.23	i will be glancing at pie charts yeah dont worry
JohnnyoftheWell 02.05.23	tbqh, having hosted a not-great version of this where the matches were skewed in line with taste, I think these are always more fun when they're totally random and that any who threw an album into the ring was hopefully aware that the chances of someone with zero background knowledge were relatively high. the anything-goes non-prescriptive spirit is what tends to mark the more successful iterations of these fests
Mort. 02.05.23	sweet will literally just do the whole on a complete whim then
JohnnyoftheWell 02.05.23	RNG that shit boi
ffs 02.05.23	i'll play nom. Stick Men With Ray Guns - Some People Deserve to Suffer
Demon of the Fall 02.05.23	yeah ngl my pick was half troll / half I actually want the damn thing reviewed, I knew it could have consequences in the wrong hands, lol
theBoneyKing 02.05.23	Yeah I was mostly just asking out of curiosity, I’m perfectly fine with some chaos! I’d love my nominee to have a good review but the band’s other albums already do have reviews so not exactly a crime if some pure metalhead trashes a slowcore classic, if anything I’d love to read that take lmao
pizzamachine 02.05.23	I’m excited to get started
DDDeftoneDDD 02.05.23	23 needs a rev so much! I can't believe that will actually happen
PumpBoffBag 02.05.23	what a cool mix of nominations. Rolling for xiu xiu
AsleepInTheBack 02.05.23	I apologise in advance for getting paired with something I know nothing about and mashing out something horrendous on my keyboard
Demon of the Fall 02.05.23	says the guy with 68 reviews! Try having 2 😂
pizzamachine 02.05.23	Try having 459, my burden is heavy
JohnnyoftheWell 02.05.23	t-minus three hours wow i am excited
anat 02.05.23	if my nomination doesn’t get a 5.0 review what was this all for
PumpBoffBag 02.05.23	humility
Mort. 02.05.23	you have an hour left to join this
pizzamachine 02.05.23	Join us or die. Sorry, didn’t read the room
AsleepInTheBack 02.05.23	Join us and die. I read the room.
Mort. 02.05.23	ten mins to closing
SlothcoreSam 02.05.23	Yo, can I change my album to Tragic Mullato - Locos Por El Sexo. My first choice will be difficult, unless your Mongolian.
Mort. 02.05.23	yes you can but youre also a prat for leaving it 5 minutes before closing to do this
SlothcoreSam 02.05.23	Actually..... I was just giving the thread a bump. Just kidding. Thanks Mort
Mort. 02.05.23	locos por el slotchcoresam's conduct aware that probably doesnt make sense but im not foreign innit m8
Mort. 02.06.23	ok it is time. putting names into a randomizer now.
PumpBoffBag 02.06.23	gassed with mine. also sorry million.
pizzamachine 02.06.23	Listening now :)
SlothcoreSam 02.06.23	Ok I found the correct album, now gotta figure out how to do this justice.
theBoneyKing 02.06.23	Lmfao I got a recent album by a 70s prog band? This should be fun.
SlothcoreSam 02.06.23	Also, I don't think it's in the Database at all. So I'll wait for PFA to fix that.
ArsMoriendi 02.06.23	She Hangs Brightly didn't have a review? :o Pizza pls do it justice, It's so good
DadKungFu 02.06.23	Very excited to do Catherine Ribeiro, hope I can do it justice
pizzamachine 02.06.23	Justice will be done, hope Sputnik agrees
bloodshy 02.06.23	Subscribed.
AsleepInTheBack 02.06.23	I can’t find 18 anywhere lol million send help
AsleepInTheBack 02.06.23	Hol up, I assume it’s this? https://youtu.be/i3JFlN-MBgM The album art and name are different but the year matches.
anat 02.06.23	alright cool let’s do it!
Trifolium 02.06.23	Niiiiiice, a 90s record!!! Hope my review will satisfy Boney!
Jasdevi087 02.06.23	absolutely fucking wild that Dig Lazarus Dig didn't have a review lmao
ffs 02.06.23	out of my comfort zone for sure but thats fun. apologies in advance to shoegaze fans
someone 02.06.23	i can do Tragic Mulatto
Demon of the Fall 02.06.23	I received something I really didn't want, lol (possibly bottom 3 if I was choosing myself) ah well, good excuse to give Nick Cave another go
MillionDead 02.06.23	lol I got one of Mobb Deep's worst rated albums. Who would make someone listen to a whole hour of mid?? I at least rec'd some heat. :((
mkmusic1995 02.06.23	I've only listened to the latest Drug Church album so should be interesting to dive into them a bit.
pizzamachine 02.06.23	Haha this is gonna be wild
Demon of the Fall 02.06.23	Yeah, what the hell have you done… Reckon I should properly check some old school Nick, but that just might make this one seem worse. Most of the tracks are twice as long as they need to be on initial inspection, argh! I’m sure this closer is the least eventful 8 min song I’ve ever heard 😄 A couple of tracks did show some promise, we’ll see… (my review will be of ‘slightly higher quality’ than this comment… but still, let’s keep expectations low)
MillionDead 02.06.23	Anybody got a review up yet? Nearly done with mine.
pizzamachine 02.06.23	Mine for Mazzy Star is up
Demon of the Fall 02.06.23	didn’t realise it was a race Only heard mine once
MillionDead 02.06.23	Mine for Mobb Deep is up. Bout to peep yours in a bit, pizza.
Trifolium 02.06.23	Haven't even heard mine yet. Hope to write in the weekend.
JohnnyoftheWell 02.06.23	starting out on mine atm hmm
Mort. 02.06.23	its not a race guys take as long as you want only prize is i will make a list extolling your virtues
Zig 02.06.23	will check 8 tomorrow
SlothcoreSam 02.06.23	Ok, I'm tapping out, I can't review a compilation of Billie Holiday songs. I could write a poor historical essay of her importance, but I'll leave that for the experts. I'm happy to swap someone, or if PitchForkArms wants to rec something else.
Mort. 02.06.23	lol why cant you review an album of billie holiday songs?
Zig 02.06.23	good listen, sinternet! hope you enjoy it as much as I did.
SlothcoreSam 02.06.23	Cus I have no appreciation for vocal jazz, and cannot get through 2 songs without falling asleep. Not saying that it's terrible, I just can't do it the justice it deserves.
DDDeftoneDDD 02.06.23	"good listen, sinternet! hope you enjoy it as much as I did." As much will be hard, but possible! At least he has 9% of folk there lol
Mort. 02.06.23	'Cus I have no appreciation for vocal jazz, and cannot get through 2 songs without falling asleep. Not saying that it's terrible, I just can't do it the justice it deserves.' pathetic. dont enter one of these in the future if youre not willing to actually engage with the random album youre assigned
Zig 02.06.23	sin will know it's a masterpiece ;)
Mort. 02.06.23	slothcoresam, go and bother pitchforkarms for a different rec or i shall make a list calling you out for chronic plebbery
SlothcoreSam 02.06.23	Like I said I'm happy to review something else. I'm just being honest, i have no idea how to write a review for this album, that isn't even in the Sputnik database, the one that is there had the incorrect track listing. And I was getting conflicting information from Wikipedia, Spotify, RYM and discogs.
Mort. 02.06.23	yes pitchforkarms was supposed to sort that out, and tbh it seems like they chose a very shitty album to rec like i said, go bother them for a better one and ill update this list
Storm In A Teacup 02.06.23	Such a dangerous game, one might end up hearing a 1! 😳😬
LouBreed 02.07.23	I am not at all familiar with the band I ended up with or indeed the style they play, so I will need some time to get into the album in question. But I'm glad I didn't get to review any of the options that are well known to me. I mean, if I had anything to say about a Nick Cave or Anubis Gate album I would have done so already
Sinternet 02.07.23	"good listen, sinternet! hope you enjoy it as much as I did." looks good, although as per usual with sput recs im always the one stuck with something 75 minute long album haha. not something thats come up on my radar before so excited to get to it, my knowledge of portuguese music exists barely beyond a vague familiarity to fado
Demon of the Fall 02.07.23	'pathetic. dont enter one of these in the future if youre not willing to actually engage with the random album youre assigned' yeah, I wasn't best pleased with mine just because I'd have preferred something obscure that I may not have discovered for myself otherwise... or a completely different style would've been nice, but I'm persevering regardless and giving it a fair chance having said that choosing something not present in the database at all is certainly an odd decision
Gnocchi 02.07.23	Pantheon: empire in ruin (death metal) Should be able to find someone to cater that
JohnnyoftheWell 02.07.23	no mercy in this thread lol fking good
AsleepInTheBack 02.07.23	If you’ve got something waaay out of your comfort zone, just take your time? Explore the genre a lil first, hit up a classic or 2, check the relevant artist’s most beloved material, then circle back to what you’ve been tasked with writing about. I’d find it astonishing if you’d have absolutely nothing to say or take away from it. It’s also, as mort said, literally the point of this list/collaborative project.
theBoneyKing 02.07.23	Yeah it’s gonna be a bit until mine comes out, haven’t even listened yet.
Trifolium 02.07.23	Just gave those Bed-hair people a go Boney! Liked it, curious where further exploration leads me.
Demon of the Fall 02.07.23	I should check Bedhair too
Mort. 02.07.23	now pitchforkarms is replying themself in their own shoutbox. my god. slothcore sam and pitchforkarms you will both be exposed for your chronic plebbery soon
LouBreed 02.07.23	Next year I'm going to impose reviewing of an LP by a random Ukrainian band upon thee!
Mort. 02.07.23	listening to viagra boys now after having only ever heard Sports they are good but not great incredibly predictable
JohnnyoftheWell 02.07.23	Viagra Boys are kinda lame yh
Mort. 02.07.23	stfu i dont care about your opinion, you dont even get down to boys a liar
JohnnyoftheWell 02.07.23	denwa shinaide kudasai
Mort. 02.07.23	also you didnt respond to my follow up regarding the ice spiceless version
JohnnyoftheWell 02.07.23	i tried and failed to have a nap and still haven't recovered
Mort. 02.07.23	goddamn i love napping gonna go put some washing on and then eat some lunch and then get on with epistemology work
Demon of the Fall 02.07.23	'listening to viagra boys now after having only ever heard Sports' fails to go hard, agreed
mkmusic1995 02.07.23	Just about to throw up my review of that Drug Church album.
SlothcoreSam 02.07.23	Ok, I'm on again. PitchForkArms recc'd The Dirty Nil- Master Volume. This I can do.
JohnnyoftheWell 02.07.23	is that a fucking pop punk album is this random
ffs 02.07.23	whitenoise superstar is post
deathofasalesman 02.07.23	LETS GO MK! shit i got a metal swing album
PitchforkArms 02.07.23	Thank you for the accommodation, Mort (:
PitchforkArms 02.07.23	btw, I got a house record and I think the only electronic records I’ve ever heard all the way through are Aphex Twin and Massive Attack (and C418, which is goated). Awwaaayyyyy we go. Gonna take some time because, “sounds like I should be driving through a foggy inner-city” ain’t gonna cut it LOL
ffs 02.07.23	smh at the cowardice itt. you think i know shit about noisy shoegaze dude? going into something completely random with total ignorance is whats fun about this. challenge yourself!
Ryus 02.07.23	enjoy the best genre pitchfork
bloodshy 02.08.23	I'd like to make a recommendation, am i too late? I recommend The Wall by a band called Pink Fjord or something. Cult classic. My friend from work was introducing me to some Dad Rock. Never heard of like any of these people. Also Rolling Stone magazine is named after a band wtf. Next you'll tell me People magazine is named after people.
Demon of the Fall 02.08.23	noob reviewer technical Q: I take it one can review a release with score x and then simply change their rating afterwards to score y? ...I don't necessarily believe in objectivity, but maybe it would be fair to make a minor adjustment of +0.5 (because my own personal rating scale is quite harsh for the Sput realm)
AsleepInTheBack 02.08.23	Yes, you can - post the rev with the rating you want associated with the write up, then just change your personal rating after. If you ever edit your review after posting, it will reset your personal rating to the rating in the review, but you just need to change it again.
AsleepInTheBack 02.08.23	Also enjoy, pitchfork! If you want to do some wider listening to get better acquainted with the style, check The Field - From Here We Go Sublime and/or Four Tet - There Is Love In You. I’m very new to the genre as well, but trust me it’s that good shit if you allow it to sink it’s hooks into you.
Demon of the Fall 02.08.23	Quick response, thanks... I was going to add that I was almost sure you could and that I could simply test this theory with my current review scores! Apologies for having answered my easy-to-ascertain query, I should've thought about it for a second.
Demon of the Fall 02.08.23	I suppose a better Q would be: is this a reasonable thing to do in a reviewer's world? i.e. having separate scores for personal and 'public' evaluation
Trifolium 02.08.23	I've done this before. For instance initially thinking an album was a 3.5, thus writing a 3.5 review, yet the album grew on me afterwards and it is now a 4.0 for me personally (the review still says 3.5). Don't think that is a bad thing, you can't really prevent that.
MillionDead 02.08.23	Yeah. I feel like I definitely have a review or two where I bumped down my personal score and kept the review score the same.
Demon of the Fall 02.08.23	I'm not talking about changing your mind later, but purposefully awarding different scores at the same time - what your describing Trif is clearly perfectly natural / reasonable
MillionDead 02.08.23	Well, I could see it. I think I did that with my Code Orange review. I'm of the opinion that your review score should be more "objective" than your personal score if you're feeling mercurial about an album.
Trifolium 02.08.23	Ah OK, I understand what you mean now. I personally never do that, but I guess it depends on what you think the purpose of a review is. If you want your review to represent your opinion of /experiences with /enjoyment of a record, I think awarding different ratings does not make sense. To me, this seems the most natural way of writing a review. It can also involve some background info, some info on how influential or singular it was, but it is mainly opinion-driven. If you want to try and place the record in context without showing any personal preferences/enjoyment whatsoever, solely trying to connect it to how influential it was/is, it might make sense to use separate ratings from the start. I feel it is very difficult to write a review in this manner though. A mixture of the two makes most sense to me, but as I said, I've never used this two-different-ratings approach from the get go.
Demon of the Fall 02.08.23	Interesting... I suppose taking my current example, it isn't a difference of opinion or perspective between my own subjectivity (or attempting to be objective), necessarily. I was merely looking to re-adjust my rating scale for the purpose of reviewing, because Sput has a tendency to over-inflate scores and thus calling this one 'average' feels unfair in the context of the website maybe I should just care less about Sput's ways and do whatever, I'm probably being too 'accommodating'
Trifolium 02.08.23	Oh man I know, this over-inflation thing, brrr! If it's an average album it's an average album though. It's good to have those reviews too. If you go that way, however clean you are, you'll sadly receive some negs for sure. Curious to hear what others think about the matter!
ffs 02.08.23	i think you're over thinking it and should back your gut rating
ffs 02.08.23	100% approval rating is the badge of a meek reviewer with a lack of conviction
JohnnyoftheWell 02.08.23	if your rating scale isn't appropriate for review scores, it's been useless all along and you're living a lie so which is it?
Pheromone 02.08.23	how has that bedhead album not been reviewed wow mort why didnt u tell me about this
Trifolium 02.08.23	Phero don't worry it will happen! I'm on it! Just heard it for the second time ever, slowly working towards writing during the weekend probably.
Demon of the Fall 02.08.23	'if your rating scale isn't appropriate for review scores, it's been useless all along and you're living a lie' 2.5 for Dig Lazarus confirmed then, this is gonna be fun (or not)
Trifolium 02.08.23	15 people agree with you Demon! (At least 15!)
Pheromone 02.08.23	trif can u speak about the song powder as it is one of the greatest songs of all time [i]sometimes i think i've never thought about anything[/i]
Demon of the Fall 02.08.23	'100% approval rating is the badge of a meek reviewer with a lack of conviction' I'll use this as solace when mine inevitably falls then, haha
Trifolium 02.08.23	OK will do. I'm going to do some research on that!
Demon of the Fall 02.08.23	These thoughts were partially sponsored by the current ongoing transferral of all my ratings to RYM and the realignment of some older scores that seemed a little too 'kind' don't worry, I'll still be Sputting! (bet you were all panicking at the thought of losing me for a sec there)
Pheromone 02.08.23	demon if i give you my rym log in details can you also transfer my ratings every time i try to do it i get sooooooo bored
Pheromone 02.08.23	also never leave
Demon of the Fall 02.08.23	lol, no thanks... it is admittedly a massive chore (also vaguely interesting when you're rediscovering something... 'oh yeah THAT exists' etc.)... but mostly a chore all of last year's ratings are already on and I'm currently adding new ratings to both sites, have been since the turn of the year as for the backlog I'm doing it alphabetically and just added Bruno Pernadas... so yeah, quite a way to go!
Mort. 02.08.23	'how has that bedhead album not been reviewed wow mort why didnt u tell me about this' you have eyes dickhead
DadKungFu 02.08.23	Having trouble uploading the Ribeiro album, on the dropdown menu it's giving me Captain Beefheart album titles and random other stuff
DadKungFu 02.08.23	K posted the Ribeiro album
deathofasalesman 02.08.23	nice! almost done with my review as well
JohnnyoftheWell 02.08.23	got a draining scientific translation about pleasure conditioning in bees on the go atm, might put it on hold and rattle off the rest of mine soon cutting a ur mom joke and am big sad
Demon of the Fall 02.08.23	that sounds genuinely interesting though 🐝 >
Mort. 02.08.23	the article itself might be interesting, but translating academic work is fucking difficult/long
JohnnyoftheWell 02.08.23	idle threat idle thread dun https://www.sputnikmusic.com/review/86275/idle-threat-Blurred-Visions/ o fuck need to finish article now
JohnnyoftheWell 02.08.23	also mortbort maybe mark up which revs are completed so we can shame those that aren't !!
Sinternet 02.08.23	yeah would be good to post links to the done ones under each entry will get to mine on saturday or sunday!
Mort. 02.08.23	good idea will put a big old 'completed' next to each one
Mort. 02.08.23	wont be posting links tho because clicking on the album from here will take you there !!!!
pizzamachine 02.08.23	Do u get extra points for reviewing all the albums
Mort. 02.08.23	no u get less points for going against the point of the game by taking away the non-reviewed albums from other people by making them reviewed
pizzamachine 02.08.23	Yeah you’d have to be crazy to do that
theBoneyKing 02.08.23	Digging into my album now…
Mort. 02.09.23	worried that a fair few people just nominated an album then completely blanked on this due to their complete lack of follow up comments since nominating, so will be shoutboxing and corralling at some point
LouBreed 02.09.23	OK, status report: I gave a cursory listen to some of Weval singles and to their second LP (i. e. NOT the one I'm supposed to review) yesterday while doing some kitchen chores. Now I am planning to get through the album that I am actually assigned to in a couple of focused listening sessions, and then I guess the review itself will come sometime during the weekend.
deathofasalesman 02.09.23	let's gooooo i finished my review. i actually really enjoyed this experience, thanks :] https://www.sputnikmusic.com/review/86279/Diablo-Swing-Orchestra-Swagger-and-Stroll-Down-the-Rabbit-Hole/
Zig 02.09.23	oh man .. Big Country is clearly not my kind of jam
Demon of the Fall 02.09.23	@LouBreed: your draw was the one I wanted, Weval are rather good!
fogza 02.09.23	"oh man .. Big Country is clearly not my kind of jam" I would have taken part if I'd been assured of getting something like that one
Pheromone 02.09.23	fogza should we play our own rec an album game
Mort. 02.09.23	if you both rec an album i can literally just add you to the list and give you eachothers rec
Pheromone 02.09.23	but do we want to play by your rules sir
JohnnyoftheWell 02.09.23	mort is a lawless sap he has no rules
Mort. 02.09.23	i literally couldnt give less of a shit this is genuinely just a way to push users to review albums that dont have a review yet and have some fun horizon pushing for users still listening to post-hardcore all day every day
Mort. 02.09.23	but i tell you what, my arm smells amazing right now
fogza 02.09.23	I'd do it, but I fear for the pressure on our newly employed legal wunderkind
Mort. 02.09.23	wait phero is gainfully employed? excellent
Trifolium 02.09.23	I love how thorough your approach is Lou! Looking forward to it. My reasoning was: there should be at least one Weval review on this site. I'll be a regular occupant of the thread, be warned!
bloodshy 02.09.23	Did any albums officially get dumped on the roadside yet?
deathofasalesman 02.09.23	“ oh man .. Big Country is clearly not my kind of jam” swing-infused prog metal is definitely not my jam but somehow I enjoyed it. The mix tho….
AsleepInTheBack 02.10.23	18 is live boyos have at it
PumpBoffBag 02.11.23	You can mark 12 as completed mort, I is done. Much love
Trifolium 02.11.23	Mine is done. I had fun.
LouBreed 02.12.23	Please mark mine as completed. This was an interesting experience. Let's do this again sometime later!
Mort. 02.12.23	added, cheers guys
Trifolium 02.14.23	11/24 completed so far. Not bad, almost halfway there! Loved yours Lou, thanks for making Weval un-reviewless.
Mort. 02.14.23	im still working on my viagra boys rev. have heard it about 4-5 times now, so just need to finish up the writing
Demon of the Fall 02.14.23	I've heard mine a few times too, don't want to listen anymore which is preventing progress. Probably could rustle something up.
Sinternet 02.14.23	mine is too damn long lol its a lot to get through, should hopefully be done by the end of the week
BitterJalapenoJr 02.14.23	I'm about 50% done with my review - also hoping for completion by the weekend.
Demon of the Fall 02.16.23	I'm 50%-ish too I reckon now, thrashed something out in the last couple of days I think the majority of the words / ideas are there, now I just to rearrange / delete some so it actually makes sense, lol so 10% adding new bits, 40% editing
BitterJalapenoJr 02.18.23	#2 is live. I loved this album - thanks to Mort for bringing it to my attention. If I'm honest, I really struggled to review it. Hopefully I did it justice somewhat. @SlothcoreSam - you should get on this if you don't already know it.
Zac124 02.19.23	I have finally done mine. It was a hard one to write for so I hope it ended up alright.
theBoneyKing 02.19.23	I’m gonna try to pump mine out tomorrow.
theBoneyKing 02.20.23	…and it’s up. Sorry loubreed.
Trifolium 02.20.23	Wow we were a cute little circle, you, lou and me!
AsleepInTheBack 02.20.23	Oi. Pitchfork. Where’s my fucking money. (and that review xxx)
LouBreed 02.21.23	@Boney, I don't mind a negative review, I just wanted it to, well, exist. It's your honest opinion and it's well justified. For some reason I felt a compulsion to review this album ever since it was released, and now I don't have to.
Demon of the Fall 02.23.23	not including the summary and one parting separate line at the end, my paragraphs feel off, currently... 151, 344, 78 words I might just throw it out there and anyone (who wants to) can suggest edits, because I'm going insane now.
Trifolium 02.23.23	Do. It. It might not even be problematic at all!
Sinternet 02.23.23	golly my album is a bit of a toughie to review with the language barrier, its really good but struggling to say much about it so will likely end up being rather a short one, should be done in the next couple of days
Demon of the Fall 02.23.23	oh crap, I was going to post mine but how do you get Sput to italicise? Is it (i) or something? Once I copied / pasted they all disappeared.
Zac124 02.23.23	[i]words[/i]
Demon of the Fall 02.23.23	thanks, I couldn't remember for the life of me not even sure it is 100% necessary, but I've noticed that band / album names usually get italicised in a lot of reviews here. Then speech marks for track names. It probably just aids readability. I'm not sure if there is actually a widely accepted 'correct' way of formatting.
Trifolium 02.23.23	I don't think there is one standard way but Johnny has strong opinions on this matter so you might check his reviews for how he handles it. It's almost there HYPE!
Demon of the Fall 02.23.23	yeah, I am consulting staff reviews as we speak (type) please lower your hype levels appropriately, I need to keep expectations at a minimum for this, lol
Mort. 02.23.23	just hurry up and get your reviews in you lazy useless fucks
Trifolium 02.23.23	Oh whoop-de-dooo, yet another review from this posted... 🥱 (That better, Demon?)
Ryus 02.23.23	tyman please
Mort. 02.23.23	https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a-T0UIgTbDE me every time one of you actually finishes the assigned review
JohnnyoftheWell 02.23.23	mort plz start shaming everyone who hasn't uploaded or procrastinated their ongoing struggles into this thread, i need blood
Pheromone 02.23.23	procastination is so uncouth
Mort. 02.23.23	anat, someone, zig, yowi, slothcore sam, pitchforkarms, sinternet and tyman you have all been identified as big dumb losers.
Pheromone 02.23.23	thank god none of them are contrib reviewers, right anat?!
Demon of the Fall 02.23.23	my review has been pushed back by 24 hours due to Sput's archaic formatting / everything, please have my sincerest apologies
Pheromone 02.23.23	chelsea fans
Mort. 02.23.23	i was a contrib once, literally means nothing and ill be a fucking contrib again, gonna post like 3 revs this year that should be enough hey phero, mr 20 rev man
JohnnyoftheWell 02.23.23	mort for president eat a slug anus
Mort. 02.23.23	im listening to iowa by slippyknot right now, will that help or hinder my presidential chances??
Pheromone 02.23.23	mort me and johnny are coming to norwich to gobble u right up
Mort. 02.23.23	i havent lived in norwich for like 2 years you stupid cunt
Demon of the Fall 02.23.23	‘chelsea fans‘ ‘there’s been an administrative error’ is my new excuse for everything, that must be why the league table looks wonky
tyman128 02.23.23	"you have all been identified as big dumb losers." damn right... anyway, college has been absolutely crazy recently and I finally have some free time I'll get this review done over the weekend for y'all
Ryus 02.23.23	bless
tyman128 02.23.23	Yeah, I feel bad for not getting to it y'all, I had to push myself to even get my first staff review out lol... should be getting back into a better groove now that I'm used to the chaos of my schedule
Ryus 02.23.23	lol ur good i just love that album
anat 02.23.23	I tried to get chatgpt to write my review for me but it was better than anything mort could write so I felt bad about posting :-(
Mort. 02.23.23	My writing far surpasses the feeble scribbling of a juvenile mind such as yours
Ryus 02.23.23	ajcollins invented chat gpt long ago
Mort. 02.23.23	I’ve decided that I might be the winner of this competition. All bask in my effervescent radiance. Sup from the chalice of my intellect. Indulge in my buttery smooth debonair dialect
anat 02.23.23	the nerd what suggested the album I’m meant to review wasn’t given one of his own
Mort. 02.23.23	Shit wtf. How did that happen
Mort. 02.23.23	Oh no it’s just been removed from the list without me noticing. It was all fucked up in the database so something must have happened like a page move
anat 02.23.23	fine. then I am not absolved of my sins, whatever
DadKungFu 02.23.23	Yep that's the thing that happened
DadKungFu 02.23.23	pull yourself together anat
anat 02.23.23	dad, how bout we strike a deal, and you take the wedding present album??? that’ll surely motivate me to get mine done
DadKungFu 02.23.23	I'd say hell yeah but don't think Mort'd go for it
pizzamachine 02.23.23	Adorable thread
Mort. 02.23.23	if i say i dont allow it, what exactly even happens? i am as powerless as all of you
pizzamachine 02.23.23	Even more powerless because I poisoned your soup
tyman128 02.23.23	Not the soup!
Demon of the Fall 02.24.23	15 is done, sorry it took so long!
Mort. 02.24.23	you are forgiven and will be strucken off the feckless dumbass list
DavidYowi 02.26.23	goddamn y'all have been flying through these reviews. Need to get cooking on mine but have no idea where to start.
Mort. 02.26.23	Start with words and move from there
DavidYowi 02.26.23	ok but what words?
anat 02.26.23	start with a 5.0 rating and reverse engineer from there
Mort. 02.26.23	hurry up with yours as well anat goddamn burnout floozies
anat 02.26.23	right well you put some shifts in for me and I’ll get straight on it
JohnnyoftheWell 03.07.23	how many useless saps do we have left
Sinternet 03.07.23	alas me i am about half way done
Mort. 03.07.23	youve all had like a whole fucking month
someone 03.07.23	working on it. got like 500 words, so i'm about halfway through
Mort. 03.13.23	anyone still working on their reviews has until the 20th to get it done. then i will be reading all the reviews and choosing my favourite one. chosen user will get a list dedicated to their honour with lots of kind words and smooches
DadKungFu 03.13.23	Don't forget I'm in this even though sput fuckery deleted my album from the list
Mort. 03.13.23	ah yes thank you for the reminder
anat 03.13.23	I have a job
PitchforkArms 03.13.23	I'm one of those useless saps! I'm working on it, though. It is a genre that I am extremely unfamiliar with so I took some time to try and have a bit more perspective, then got discouraged because I felt like I still wasn't able to give it a fair shake, then started sorta vibing with it a bit more - then started writing.
Mort. 03.13.23	'I have a job' shouldnt have fucking put your name in the hat for this then should you, you silly cunt?
someone 03.13.23	man, if i'm on a deadline then i'll just throw out whatever i have at the moment i guess. cause i know it'll take me longer to reframe and rewrite the review. it's a wonky lil piece but maybe fitting idk
someone 03.13.23	'I have a job' and you also have a moral duty
anat 03.13.23	never said I’m not gonna do it luv I might well be the last but I’m not about to spaff out a shitter to placate the mob
Demon of the Fall 03.13.23	what a beautifully poetic sentence, can this be included in the review perhaps?
Mort. 03.13.23	spaff out a shitter to placate the mob yeah im just a shitheeled crude-voiced slob
AsleepInTheBack 03.13.23	“ I’m not about to spaff out a shitter to placate the mob” bitch placating masses with my shit is my entire reviewing philosophy step up
JohnnyoftheWell 03.13.23	spodging out bollocks to placate the hordes is 95% of everything wrong with mainstream music journoing and the worst thing a writer can do penning with brakes off for the sake of pissing them off, however...
PitchforkArms 03.16.23	Nearing completion of Gidge review - finally.
someone 03.18.23	there you go Mort, choke on it https://www.sputnikmusic.com/review/86530/Tragic-Mulatto-Locos-Por-El-Sexo/
Mort. 03.18.23	shut up dickhead
tyman128 03.18.23	I'll get mine in, attack me for forgetting, I've had chaos in my life but this will be done
Purpl3Spartan 03.18.23	when does the sex begin
someone 03.18.23	whenever you like, we're all just waiting for you, Spartan
Mort. 03.19.23	remember that by the end of tomorrow your unifnished reviews will be ignored and you will be assigned a 'big dumb loser' status
kalkwiese 03.19.23	Looks like this one got more reviews done than last year's
PitchforkArms 03.20.23	https://www.sputnikmusic.com/review/86543/Gidge-Autumn-Bells/ :)
Sinternet 03.20.23	ugh i got given the hardest one of the fucking lot this isnt fair
Mort. 03.20.23	boo hoo
Mort. 03.20.23	users anat, zig, david yowi, slothcore sam, sinternet and tyman you have all been identitfied as big dumb losers who get other people to review albums but bail on their own obligations. i shame you shame shame shame shame
Sinternet 03.20.23	ok next time mort you can try to review an 80s portuguese prog folk maritime concept album where half the tracks are sea shanties bozo
DadKungFu 03.20.23	Um fuck I might take that one that sounds rad
Mort. 03.20.23	'ok next time mort you can try to review an 80s portuguese prog folk maritime concept album where half the tracks are sea shanties bozo' sounds easy as fuck so its prog folk with a maritime concept featuring sea shanties? that sounds like it could be described in numerous ways and you already have a grip on what it is dont excuse your laziness, i doubt you even tried to review it
Demon of the Fall 03.20.23	I think Sint is trying to do it justice Mort. I know you said it's possible to just throw something out there as any review is better than none - but yeah, I could see why you wouldn't want to. I certainly didn't want to.
Sinternet 03.20.23	i literally did real-world research asking my portuguese friend about it trying to get a good angle and he was like yeah its ok i have currently 400 words written and had them for a month, there's just very little to say about it when it's cultural significance (of which any source i can find claims to be significant) is kinda lost on me, both through a language barrier and a lack of cultural knowledge surrounding it. ive been on and off adding bits over the last month but its kinda draining. regardless i'll get their eventually, but man even though i like the album and am glad i heard it i could have cranked out any other album on this list in a couple days max
Mort. 03.20.23	thats fair and i will say zig is a bit of a dickhead for nominating that in the first place
tyman128 03.20.23	I’m still reviewing it, but yeah call me a big dumb loser, been rough out here
Sinternet 03.20.23	i will try to finish this week anyway, i do wanna finish it haha but its one of those things ive had open in a tab for ages
ffs 03.20.23	well done all
someone 03.20.23	nothing harder to review than a passable mid album yikes
PitchforkArms 03.22.23	While I was mere moments away from being labelled a big dumb loser, I am actually incredibly happy to have done this. The record I got assigned was way outside my comfort zone and required multiple approaches to listening, analyzing, and inevitably reviewing in order to sound off without sounding like a complete buffoon. Thank you, Mort.
LouBreed 03.22.23	Yeah, my own comfort zone was miles away from what I was destined to review here, but if there's anything to be dissatisfied with, it's not what I was given, but what I myself ended up giving. If I gave it a bit more thought, I would have suggested a different album for reviewing.
Mort. 03.22.23	am busy over the next couple of days but come the weekend i will sit down, read each review through carefully and assign a winner said winner will get a list all about them and how cool and talented and wonderful they are
PitchforkArms 03.22.23	awaiting my crown and adulation
Zig 03.22.23	"thats fair and i will say zig is a bit of a dickhead for nominating that in the first place" what? that record is a masterpiece. gfy, Mort.
Zig 03.22.23	@Sinternet sorry if that record is getting you trouble.
Mort. 03.22.23	its not its masterpiece status i deny perhaps i should have made a rule for no non-english language albums
fogza 03.22.23	this looks to have been successful Mort. release a course on productivity
Zig 03.22.23	8's out
fogza 03.23.23	I think it's rich how some people on this list are getting put on blast for not living up to their commitments that they understood when they signed up, when the person running this project and dealing out the abuse has kindly participated in Song of the Day and has not provided a second rec which they are not obligated to do. The hypocrisy! At this point you might say "but fogza, those two things are not remotely the same" to which I say a pox on your house and may a rodent nibble your toe in the night. Point is the only way to get revenge is to recommend a song on https://www.sputnikmusic.com/list.php?listid=202571 it doesn't make sense but sometimes life leads us in strange directions
AsleepInTheBack 03.23.23	Lol rip. Mort you have been mort-ed.
Mort. 03.23.23	oh shit i must shame myself wheres my flagellation stick
someone 03.23.23	"I say a pox on your house and may a rodent nibble your toe in the night." fogza the poetic type
DavidYowi 03.25.23	MORT WHERE ARE YOU I HAVE COMPLETED MY TASK I AM A BIG DUMB LOSER NO MORE https://www.sputnikmusic.com/review/86594/The-Wedding-Present-Watusi/
Mort. 03.25.23	youre still a big dumb loser for taking so long but i will put completed next to it
PitchforkArms 03.29.23	How has reading 30 random ass reviews been going, Mort.?
Mort. 03.29.23	its not been happening cos ive been busy, is on the agenda tho dont worry, i havent forgotten
PitchforkArms 03.29.23	Very understandable, yo. I am also realizing that it is closer to 20 due to bigdumbloser behavior
someone 03.29.23	you got until Friday or you'll be labelled Big Dumb Loser
Mort. 03.29.23	oh shit
someone 03.29.23	i am somewhat tempted to review some of the unreviewed albums here just to show the kids how it's done
mkmusic1995 03.29.23	Do it!
pizzamachine 03.29.23	Love to see it
deathofasalesman 03.30.23	lots of big dumb losers here damn
tyman128 03.30.23	I'm one of them!
Mort. 03.30.23	sorry for being long with choosing a winner guys. just got my first philosophy student so have been focusing on that. annoyingly theyre completely uninterested and apathetic about philosophy and they spent the whole last session with their mic and camera off and then ghosted me today so i have been elated to finally get a student and incredibly frustrated but most importantly more busy than usual
SteakByrnes 03.30.23	are you tellin me mort is a big dumb loser
Mort. 03.30.23	basically yes
DavidYowi 03.30.23	get him the dunce cap
Mort. 03.30.23	suck my david yowies
pizzamachine 03.30.23	Does this mean I win automatically?
DadKungFu 03.30.23	Catherine Ribeiro + 2 Bis
Mort. 03.31.23	i wont forget baby cakes
someone 04.04.23	Hmm
Mort. 04.04.23	i wont forget baby cakes
SlothcoreSam 04.05.23	Mark mine as complete, I submitted it as soon as I got back from holidays.
tyman128 04.05.23	Who is baby cakes and why are we not forgetting them
Mort. 04.05.23	i wont forget baby cakes
someone 04.05.23	mort cannot handle big cakes, he can only eat baby versions
Mort. 04.05.23	i wont forget daddy cakes
tyman128 04.05.23	What about mommy cakes?
Mort. 04.05.23	dont be crass
tyman128 04.05.23	Sorry cake
someone 04.05.23	i wish i were Crass, they were a great band as it stands i am Le Tigre at best
Mort. 04.05.23	isnt that the group that made a cringe political 'im with hillary clinton' track? youre better than that
someone 04.05.23	they had better days. shame how many once great artists get overshadowed by them being old people
PitchforkArms 04.05.23	do they owe us a living fucking BANGS
Mort. 04.05.23	ok i have read all the reviews not submitted late two people are currently tied for first review imo yes papa kung fu i remembered your review dont worry
DDDeftoneDDD 04.05.23	Respect for Sint []
PitchforkArms 04.06.23	let's hear them juicy juicy results, babycakes
Mort. 04.06.23	look at my lists you stoooopid
PitchforkArms 04.06.23	eggonmyface