|UserReviews 31Approval 99%Soundoffs 255News Articles 16Band Edits + Tags 277Album Edits 132Album Ratings 2697Objectivity 78%Last Active 02-24-16 8:12 pmJoined 03-07-07Forum Posts 188Review Comments 24,397
Last night, I decided to bump For Emma, Forever Ago up to a 5 after
months of it sitting at 4.5. The list is other albums that are close to
For Emma, Forever Ago
There's no point in me justifying a 5 for this. It's been done several times
This album single-handedly convinced me that singer-songwriter albums are
worth my time.
|3|| ||Godspeed You! Black Emeror|
F# A# (Infinity)
The apocalypse never sounded so awesome.
Mean Everything to Nothing
I so badly want 2009 to produce a classic album for me. This is my
favourite album of this year, but it's not quite a classic.
|5||Protest the Hero|
I took me a while to realize that this is significantly more interesting than
The Crane Wife
I don't know what to say about this album other than it owns my face
whenever I listen to it.
|7||Animal Collective |
Merriweather Post Pavilion
I think this is the first album (or of the first few) that I bought based off of
praise from this site. If I'd gotten a mediocre album that this site was going
apeshit for, I would have probably questioned the collective musical integrity of the site and peaced out. Lucky for you guys, I stuck around!
|Questions, comments, concerns?|
|100% agree with comments on 5 and 6|
|I support anyone rating Kezia as classic.|
METN is awesome but not a 5.
|i like how before you listen to it, you might pronounce it "kez-ee-ah"|
|3 is absolutely a 5.|
|1 and 3 are definitely 5's for me, i agree with 2 and 4 being borderline|
|I would have gotten the fuck out of here if I had done what you did for 7. Haha cool list though.|
|1 and 3 are a 5|
4 I'm not sure about, i prefer like a virgin more which I've been debating wether to bump to a 5
7 is awesome, but I dunno if its a 5
|2 is such a great record, there's absolutely nothing wrong with it, yet, like you It doesnt feel like a 5.|
|Is 7 really that up there? I listened to snippets a few months ago and was unimpressed, but listened to their earlier stuff and really enjoyed it.|
3, though. Motherfucking 3.
|The people on this site seem to either love Merriweather or hate it. I happen to love it.|
There's something about FA Infinity keeping it from a 5 for me, I can't quite put my finger on it. Lift Your Skinny Fists is superior (I feel) and most definitely a 5.
|5 is indeed a classic.|
7 is also damm near the 5 star rating.