Frippertronics
12.06.16 | the sequencing nobody asked for but got anyways
kinda wanted it to keep a mellow vibe with the rockers ("revolution", "helter skelter", "u.s.s.r") being the flashes of unrest or something
In keeping with the limitations of vinyl, I aimed to keep it to one LP (in which what the album should've been in the first place) and wanted it to be somewhat more focused, even if it meant sacrificing the diversity of the original album. |
DoofusWainwright
12.06.16 | Glad you didn't chop 'Dear Prudence' in the end D: |
guitarded_chuck
12.06.16 | no thanks |
Frippertronics
12.06.16 | "the sequencing nobody asked for"
"but got anyways"
take it, you know you want it |
altertide0
12.06.16 | you threw out some of the best songs |
Frippertronics
12.06.16 | and the result is a better album
a necessary sacrifice
"it is what it is" |
altertide0
12.06.16 | so you made a well flowing shitty album. congratulations |
onionbubs
12.06.16 | Id rather the original, but most of my favorites are here so i cant complain too much
The inner light helllllll yes |
Rowan5215
12.06.16 | decent stuff here webby, I'd keep Martha My Dear and Cry Baby Cry but you've got the best songs here rly |
onionbubs
12.06.16 | I'd keep Cry baby cry [2]
Have that replace i'm so tired. I'd also keep mother nature's son and glass onion |
guitarded_chuck
12.06.16 | the album was meant to be a bit eccentric collection of work rather than a flowing album to change up what they had been doing so it's fine as it is |
onionbubs
12.06.16 | Every double album has people bitching about the length and how it wouldve been better as a single album. This is one of the only times ive seen it with the white album tho |
Titan
12.06.16 | where is Bungalow Bill man? |
altertide0
12.06.16 | ^exactly |
wham49
12.06.16 | totally disagree with this whole thing
"In keeping with the limitations of vinyl, I aimed to keep it to one LP (in which what the album should've been in the first place)"
what! |
Titan
12.06.16 | fripp dude.....do the astonishing next! |
altertide0
12.06.16 | Lol there's not enough good material on the astonishing for a single |
ArsMoriendi
12.06.16 | This track list really makes me think you hate the original version.
I mean seriously no Everybody's Got Something to Hide, Yer Blues, or Martha My Dear? All those are so essential for me |
wham49
12.06.16 | if there is one to cut it is ussr, and the inclusion of Hey Jude is ridiculous. It has its own record entitiled HEY JUDE, which has turned with the release of the cd version into past masters vol 1
no savoy truffle, Racoon, Monkey all the things that make this such a joyful listen |
TVC15
12.06.16 | Quite interesting but there's so many good tracks to keep it as one CD or below an hour
Not as controversial as my Nevermind resequence tho |
ArsMoriendi
12.06.16 | The inclusion of Hey Jude and The Inner Light really make it seem like Fripp was struggling to even find enough songs he likes on the White Album to make 1 disc |
wham49
12.06.16 | tv, it doesnt matter what sequence Nevermind is, will still be overblown and overrated |
onionbubs
12.06.16 | Inner light is an absolute jam tho. Top 20 beatles songs easy |
ArsMoriendi
12.06.16 | It's an awesome song, but it doesn't make sense at all in the context of The White Album. |
onionbubs
12.06.16 | I dont think it would make sense in the context of any album tbh. I guess it would make most sense here because its such a hodgepodge of different stuff, but im hard pressed to find anywhere it could go |
Royl123
12.06.16 | I would include Cry Baby Cry [3] and Mother Nature's Son [2]. I also think the album should end with Black Bird followed by Good Night. |
ArsMoriendi
12.06.16 | Nah it'd work on Sgt Peppers or Magical Mystery Tour |
onionbubs
12.06.16 | Mystery tour maybe. Gives of a very slight baby your a rich man vibe at times |
TVC15
12.06.16 | None of the songs on The White Album make sense next to each other which is what makes it so great, although yeah there are some songs dropped from the album that are just as amazing like What's the New Mary Jane, Hey Bulldog, etc |
onionbubs
12.06.16 | Haven't heard whats the new mary jane yet. Ill check today
Hey bulldog is great. 2nd best on yellow submarine (if its all too much isnt my top 1 beatles song, its at least top 3) |
zakalwe
12.06.16 | An album with the power to galavanise a cultist nutter to say there was a utopia at the centre of earth accessed by the Californian desert once a race war had been instigated which in turn lead to the brutal murder of several people.
2.5 it. |
Frippertronics
12.06.16 | "This track list really makes me think you hate the original version."
I've no desire to sit through 90 minutes just for a couple songs in all honesty. It isn't that I don't like it, it's just far too bloated imo.
altertide in with the contrarian opinion congrats dude
|
Frippertronics
12.06.16 | Also, Martha My Dear and Glass Onion were considered but again, I wanted to keep it to one LP's worth of material
The main issue with the album is that the highs are some of greatest works of the past century, but the lows are just inexcusable. |
ArsMoriendi
12.06.16 | Martha My Dear gets even better when you realize that Paul had a sheepdog named Martha at the time and that song is pretty much obviously about her :) |
Rowan5215
12.06.16 | Yer Blues is probably one of the worst songs ever made |
Frippertronics
12.07.16 | A note, The Inner Light was added just to have another George composition and to keep the eccenticity of the original album somewhat present. It may not work in context of the album, but it came out in 1968 plus it worked better than Lady Madonna being included |
ArsMoriendi
12.07.16 | "Yer Blues is probably one of the worst songs ever made"
wut How? It's literally just a heavy blues rock song. An awesome one at that |
ArsMoriendi
12.07.16 | Fripp is probably going to think I'm weird for feeling this way, but Lady Madonna is probably my favorite Paul Beatles song |
neekafat
12.07.16 | As long as "While My Guitar Gently Weeps" is on there, I suppose I don't give much of af |
TVC15
12.07.16 | Nah Lady Madonna is def one of Paul's best Beatles songs |
ArsMoriendi
12.07.16 | It makes me so happy |
Frippertronics
12.07.16 | not too weird really
the aim here was to make a coherent album, the opposite of the original album. the whole "it's intentionally a mish-mash that's why it works" thing is like a moon shaped pool being so inconsistent and a total clusterfuck in consideration to its overall flow. the best beatles album had a perfect sequence and this album should've followed suit |
ArsMoriendi
12.07.16 | True, both Revolver and Magical Mystery Tour were both incredibly flowy
Unless you mean Abbey Road... |
TVC15
12.07.16 | The White Album is my fav Beatles album so I mean |
Frippertronics
12.07.16 | revolver, ars |