mindleviticus: What Justifies A 5 Rating To You?

StallionMang 01.27.13	It has something to do with nostalgia, consistency, and just overall classic-ness. Is this something you're gonna listen to the rest of your life?
foxblood 01.27.13	it's a 5 if it's a 5
bach 01.27.13	It's all about how an album makes you feel.
demigod93 01.27.13	if its rly good
Omaha 01.27.13	No sense in thinking about it a ton. I 5 amazing albums, end of story
Wolfhorde 01.27.13	Replay value over longer periods of time.
Jacquibim 01.27.13	I really, really, really, really, really, really, really, really, really, really, really, really, really, really, really like it. I guess.
DotEight 01.27.13	I mean it's subjective, what a broad question. If it makes you giddy everytime you spin it and you find you'll be listening to it for years to come, then it's a 5.
oltnabrick 01.27.13	if its hybrid theory = 5
suppatime 01.27.13	my 5's are pretty much albums that i have a really strong emotional connection to, whether it got me through something tough or it just means a lot to me. they are also, obviously, killer albums
LifeAsAChipmunk 01.27.13	you just feel it you'll know when you do
linguist2011 01.27.13	Well, it means "classic", and I know a lot of people say a lot of albums are classics, but you have to know yourself if the album you're listening to is truly classic.
Dunwich 01.27.13	5 star album is the one you would consider listening to it, before you kill yourself.
Propose 01.27.13	It has to have a 4.2 average on sputnik or higher
thumbcrusher 01.27.13	if i like it lots
pissbore 01.27.13	gotta s8n hard
TheMoreira 01.27.13	It's just classic.
Inferis 01.27.13	I like your 5's maaaaannn. For me it's something I can't live without. Sometimes I throw in some objective 5's (classics for the time/in their genre) which I really need to stop doing, though.
newjunk2 01.27.13	If it inspires me to grow my hair out or get a nipple piercing or something then it's a 5.
KSK1 01.27.13	Something you can listen to that never gets old. And every song on the album is just as amazing as the others with maybe a few that stand slightly above.
sixdegrees 01.27.13	if I really, really like every or almost every song and there are lots of moments on the album that make me go "whoa"
DrMaximus 01.27.13	Like other people said, it's all about the feelz man
demigod93 01.27.13	if its a really fucking good album
bloc 01.27.13	An album where all the tracks are still enjoyable years after its release.
Chortles 01.27.13	yeah basically it's the feel when it's a 5 you just know
Havey 01.27.13	18 ye
Asdfp277 01.27.13	If it hits the right spot. It might be emotional, nostalgic, or just plain fun. If I don't get bored of it, and if it makes me feel all artsy and shit. Or if it's a 4.5 but higher.
TheSupernatural 01.27.13	Pretty much any album where I can say out loud, "holy shit this is what I'm talking about!!"
JokineAugustus 01.27.13	Its got to have at least 70% of the songs that I can individually 5.
Spag 01.27.13	Nostalgia, the feeling I get from it, replay value and accessibility.
Dolving999 01.27.13	No filler included.
Trebor17 01.27.13	A 5 can have filler bro
evilford 01.27.13	A 5 can have filler. And there may be albums that have no filler and all great songs and they aren't 5s. It's what it does overall. A 5 means it is a classic album. The best of the best, etc
evilford 01.27.13	Like through silver in blood... Even if the rest of the album was filler and it still had Purify I'd prob still fucking 5 it
oltnabrick 01.27.13	So basically Hybrid Theory