elgaberino
User

Reviews 3
Approval 33%

Soundoffs 6
Album Ratings 209
Objectivity 74%

Last Active 12-07-07 5:52 am
Joined 10-26-07

Review Comments 8

Average Rating: 3.57
Rating Variance: 0.58
Objectivity Score: 74%
(Fairly Balanced)

Chart.

Sort by: Rating | Release Date | Rating Date | Name


2010
Kula Shaker Pilgrim's Progress3.0

2009
The Rakes Klang3.5
DM Stith Heavy Ghost4.5
Neko Case Middle Cyclone4.5
Asobi Seksu Hush3.5
...And You Will Know Us by the Trail of Dead The Century of Self3.5
M. Ward Hold Time4.5
Dan Auerbach Keep it Hid4.0
Lily Allen It's Not Me, It's You3.0
Franz Ferdinand Tonight: Franz Ferdinand2.5
Coconut Records Davy4.0
Actor Jason Schwartzman's band shows up with a sophomore release full of simple indie pop tunes that get stuck in the humming part of your head. Schwartzman's plaintive tenor channels the likes of many smart indie pop vocalists of the last two decades, and lyrical topics remain interesting enough to justify their minimalist production setting. Those in the know will enjoy the reference to Schwartzman's stint as the drummer for underrated power pop outfit Phantom Planet.
Andrew Bird Noble Beast4.0
Bon Iver Blood Bank4.0
Animal Collective Merriweather Post Pavilion4.5

2008
Los Campesinos! We Are Beautiful, We Are Doomed4.0
The Dears Missiles3.5
Juana Molina Un Dia3.5
Cold War Kids Loyalty to Loyalty3.5
Calexico Carried To Dust3.5
The Verve Forth3.5
Bloc Party Intimacy2.5
Brendan Canning Something For All of Us...3.5
Grouper Dragging a Dead Deer Up a Hill4.0
Jakob Dylan Seeing Things3.5
N.E.R.D. Seeing Sounds2.5
Weezer The Red Album2.5
Bonnie 'Prince' Billy Lie Down in the Light3.5
Santigold Santogold3.5
Cut Copy In Ghost Colours3.5
Los Campesinos! Hold On Now, Youngster...4.0
Sera Cahoone Only as the Day Is Long3.5
Crystal Castles Crystal Castles3.5
Retribution Gospel Choir Retribution Gospel Choir3.5
Evangelista Hello, Voyager3.5
The Gutter Twins Saturnalia3.5
The Black Crowes Warpaint3.5
Kathleen Edwards Asking for Flowers3.5
Howlin Rain Magnificent Fiend3.0
Black Tide Light From Above3.5
Born Ruffians Red, Yellow and Blue4.0
Janet Jackson Discipline3.0
Goldfrapp Seventh Tree3.5
Say Hi The Wishes And The Glitch3.5
Grand Archives The Grand Archives3.5
City and Colour Bring Me Your Love3.5
Yip-Yip Two Kings of the Same Kingdom3.0
Bob Mould District Line3.0
Jack Johnson Sleep Through the Static2.5
Dead Meadow Old Growth3.5
The Mars Volta The Bedlam in Goliath3.5
Black Mountain In the Future4.0
moe. Sticks and Stones3.5
The Whigs Mission Control3.0
Matt Costa Unfamiliar Faces3.0
Cat Power Jukebox3.5
Lightspeed Champion Falling Off The Lavender Bridge3.5
Louis XIV Slick Dogs and Ponies1.0

2007
Wyclef Jean The Carnival Volume II (Memoirs of an Immigrant)2.5
The idea of a sequel to the carnival was a great idea, on paper. But about the time it becomes an over-collaborated behemoth, it gets a but clunky. Overproduced, under-impressive. Sure, there's some decent rapping on here, with some interesting world music arrangements, but that doesn't make up for the lack of cleverness. His duet with Shakira is not an answer to their previous collaborations. Norah Jones' vox is always beautiful, but this isn't a Norah album, and she feels like an afterthought, much like Paul Simon. Add Serj Tankian and an even less justified visit from overrated will.i.am, and we wonder whether Wyclef needs as much help as Sanatana does on his albums. He shouldn't; he wouldn't if there were any songs on here like "Gone Till November," or adaptations the caliber of "Guantanamera," or "We Be Tryin' To Stay Alive." The aftertaste: I feel like I just listened to Counting Crows collaborating with POD covering a collection of reggae and island music.
Bonnie 'Prince' Billy Ask Forgiveness3.0
Radiohead In Rainbows3.5
Band of Horses Cease to Begin3.5
Beirut The Flying Club Cup4.5
Enon Grass Geysers... Carbon Clouds3.0
Sharon Jones and the Dap-Kings 100 Days, 100 Nights3.5
Dethklok The Dethalbum 3.5
The Cave Singers Invitation Songs4.0
Listening to a lot of new music, this spooky throwback really becomes like an island of goodness amidst the dangerously swirling rapids of mediocrity represented in a lot of other crap.
Devendra Banhart Smokey Rolls Down Thunder Canyon3.5
Animal Collective Strawberry Jam4.0
Dirty Projectors Rise Above3.5
Bald Eagle Hot Shoulders3.5
Josh Ritter The Historical Conquests of Josh Ritter4.5
Caribou Andorra4.0
Justice 3.5
St. Vincent Marry Me4.0
Maroon 5 It Won't Be Soon Before Long2.0
The National Boxer4.5
The Angels of Light We Are Him3.5
Frog Eyes Tears of the Valedictorian4.0
Pale Young Gentlemen Pale Young Gentlemen4.0
Modest Mouse We Were Dead Before the Ship Even Sank3.5
Andrew Bird Armchair Apocrypha4.0
Arcade Fire Neon Bible4.0
The Besnard Lakes The Besnard Lakes Are the Dark Horse4.5
The Frames The Cost3.0
Barenaked Ladies Barenaked Ladies Are Men3.5
The Apples in Stereo New Magnetic Wonder4.5
Bowerbirds Hymns for a Dark Horse3.5

2006
Tom Waits Orphans: Brawlers, Bawlers and Bastards4.5
Sufjan Stevens Songs For Christmas3.5
Annuals Be He Me4.0
Califone Roots and Crowns3.5
Medeski, Martin and Wood Out Louder (w/ John Scofield)3.5
Barenaked Ladies Barenaked Ladies Are Me4.0
The Black Keys Magic Potion4.0
Yo La Tengo I Am Not Afraid of You and I Will Beat Your Ass4.5
Jars Of Clay Good Monsters3.0
The Roots Game Theory4.0
M. Ward Post-War4.5
The Casanovas All Night Long3.0
It's hard to play big-stage rock on the smalltime. The Casanovas carefully pack as much classic rock n' roll punch as possible into each song, with buzz-saw guitars and boot-heel stomping, driving rhythms. The problem is that the album plays like a lot of pretty good rock songs with very little to distinguish them. There's so much rock posturing, such sterilized stories of generic shame and running away to California, as to make the Casanovas seem like students in the school of rock, rather than profs. Generic rock vocals, generic rock guitar, generic rock drumming, all carefully classic and irrefutable, are surprisingly unexciting, forcing listeners to judge a rock reality show instead of melting their faces off. It's not bad - if you're looking for a solid album full of great rock sound, this is worth the purchase. But it's not any more awesome than that. It's a lot like a collection of Aerosmith, Lynyrd Skynyrd, and Kiss B-side rejects played by a proficient cover band.
Midlake The Trials of Van Occupanther4.5
Say Hi Impeccable Blahs4.0
Sufjan Stevens The Avalanche: Outtakes and Extras3.5
AFI Decemberunderground1.5
The Futureheads News and Tributes3.5
Red Hot Chili Peppers Stadium Arcadium3.5
Danielson Ships4.0
The Black Keys Chulahoma4.0
Gnarls Barkley St. Elsewhere3.5
Cities Cities3.5
Josh Ritter The Animal Years4.5
Calexico Garden Ruin2.5
Built to Spill You in Reverse4.5
Band of Horses Everything All the Time4.0
The Appleseed Cast Peregrine3.5
Bell X1 Flock3.0
Neko Case Fox Confessor Brings The Flood5.0
Anathallo Floating World3.5
She Wants Revenge She Wants Revenge1.5
These two guys clearly spent forever burying themselves deep in the dramatic mindset that typified goth music in the early 80's. While they've definitely caricatured that genre well, I think they meant this to be a tribute to it and executed it rather poorly. Those who like Joy Division are probably going to listen to Joy Division, and are probably not going to listen to this. Either way, this is perfect fare for wide-eyed adolescents who feel sorry for themselves, are unjustifiably obsessed with social drama, and want to have mindless sex immediately because they've just hit puberty and don't know what else to do. For the rest of us, it was nice to imagine another Interpol on the scene, but after listening to the disc, most of us feel like putting this album on someone else's shelf, having a stiff drink, and going to bed. Get over it, yeah? We have work in the morning. I say friends don't let friends wallow in myspace-era self-pity and isolationist sensuality.
Jenny Lewis with the Watson Twins Rabbit Fur Coat3.0
Cat Power The Greatest4.0
Bonnie 'Prince' Billy The Letting Go4.5

2005
Apollo Sunshine Apollo Sunshine3.0
Sufjan Stevens Illinois4.5
Hard-Fi Stars Of CCTV2.0
OK, this is gonna sound harsh, but bear with me. If the packaging hadn't been so faddish, everyone might have noticed that these guys aren't half a notch above the recently attempted comeback albums of 90's adult alternative bands like Smashmouth or Matchbox 20. Cash machine is such an annoying song, I've often felt deejays were merely playing it as filler while waiting for the real next sound to show up. Seriously, people, it's barely better than boy band music. The fact that someone compared this to Arctic Monkeys is not fair to the cleverness of said chilled primates. Go buy an Arctic Monkeys, Futureheads or Rapture album and forget this.
Nadja Bliss Torn From Emptiness3.0
Motion City Soundtrack Commit This to Memory2.5
Caribou The Milk Of Human Kindness4.5
Figurines Skeleton4.0
Queens of the Stone Age Lullabies to Paralyze3.5
M. Ward Transistor Radio3.5
Andrew Bird The Mysterious Production Of Eggs3.5
Bloc Party Silent Alarm4.5

2004
DeVotchKa How It Ends4.5
Devendra Banhart Nino Rojo4.5
Arcade Fire Funeral5.0
The Black Keys Rubber Factory4.5
The Snake The Cross The Crown Mander Salis4.0
The Futureheads The Futureheads3.5
Comets on Fire Blue Cathedral4.0
Danielson Brother Is To Son4.0
Midlake Bamnan and Slivercork3.5
Devendra Banhart Rejoicing in the Hands4.0
Modest Mouse Baron von Bullshit Rides Again2.5
Modest Mouse Good News for People Who Love Bad News5.0

2003
Al Green I Can't Stop3.5
Stone Temple Pilots Thank You4.5
P.O.D. Payable on Death1.5
The Shins Chutes Too Narrow5.0
Sufjan Stevens Michigan4.0
The Black Keys Thickfreakness5.0
Bathory Nordland II1.5
Deerhoof Apple O'3.5
Andrew Bird Weather Systems3.5
Calexico Feast of Wire4.5

2002
Bathory Nordland I1.5
Neko Case Blacklisted4.0
The Black Keys The Big Come Up3.5
Anathallo Sparrows3.5

2001
Midlake Milkmaid Grand Army3.0
P.O.D. Satellite2.0
The Shins Oh, Inverted World4.5
Angra Rebirth2.5
Iced Earth Horror Show2.5

2000
Switchfoot Learning To Breathe1.5
Sufjan Stevens A Sun Came3.5
Queens of the Stone Age Rated R2.5
Yo La Tengo And Then Nothing Turned Itself Inside...4.0
Comets on Fire Comets on Fire4.0

1999
Jars Of Clay If I Left The Zoo2.5
Medeski, Martin and Wood Last Chance to Dance Trance(perhaps) Best of 91-964.0
Switchfoot New Way to Be Human1.5
Bush The Science of Things2.5
P.O.D. Fundamental Elements of Southtown3.0
Jamiroquai Synkronized3.0

1998
MxPx Let It Happen4.0
Calexico The Black Light4.5

1997
Modest Mouse The Lonesome Crowded West4.0
Wyclef Jean The Carnival4.0
Live Secret Samadhi3.5
Danielson Tell Another Joke At The Ol' Chopping Block3.5
Switchfoot Legend of Chin3.0

1996
Bush Razorblade Suitcase3.5
P.O.D. Brown3.0
Modest Mouse This Is a Long Drive for Someone with Nothing to Think About4.5
MxPx Life in General3.0

1995
Jars Of Clay Jars Of Clay3.5
Red Hot Chili Peppers One Hot Minute1.5
Yo La Tengo Electr-O-Pura4.0

1994
Bush Sixteen Stone3.0
R.E.M. Monster3.5
Weezer Weezer4.5
Built to Spill There's Nothing Wrong with Love3.5

1992
R.E.M. Automatic for the People3.5

1991
R.E.M. Out of Time3.5

1987
R.E.M. Document3.5

1986
R.E.M. Lifes Rich Pageant4.5

1985
Accept Metal Heart4.0

1984
R.E.M. Reckoning4.5

1979
Thin Lizzy Black Rose: A Rock Legend4.0

1977
Thin Lizzy Bad Reputation4.0

1976
Thin Lizzy Johnny the Fox4.0
Thin Lizzy Jailbreak4.5

1971
Leonard Cohen Songs of Love and Hate4.0

1970
B.B. King Indianola Mississippi Seeds4.0

1969
B.B. King Completely Well4.0
1967
Cream Disraeli Gears5.0
STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy