Green Day
American Idiot


3.5
great

Review

by Robby Roark (The Sludge) USER (26 Reviews)
November 5th, 2006 | 17 replies | 2,758 views


Release Date: 2004 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Disclaimer: There are poop jokes proceeding in the following unnecessary review.

5 of 5 thought this review was well written

Straight from the realms of a punky poppy boy band roots, Green Day has submitted their way into the pre-teen wet dream fantasies hall of fame along with New Kids On The Block and Bon Jovi. As hardcore as a baby diaper, Green Day played the brutal Berkeley punk scene until the big suits chased after them, taking them to Disney world to persuade them selling-out is the way to go. I guess it took Billie Joe in a dark shady room with Mickey and Mickey Jr. to sell his soul to Reprise records. POOF! Dookie was born in February 1994. There it was, simple 3 chord structures was the it thing to do. Soon, 12 year olds paraded the streets on skateboards and green mohawks with Green Day patches. Sickened at the sudden success, the Berkeley crowd had enough of this pop muzik and started pooping in their sinks. The band took it hard, they pitied over their sudden loss. Now what do they do? Play the same 3 chords... faster. Insomniac is the bastard child in the GD library. You know, the underappreciated scapegoat whom's efforts went unnoticed because not it wasn't as smart or as big as the "older" child was (***ers).

Once they came to terms with their metrosexual brand of punk music, Nimrod came out in a big way. Not being memorable for doing anything different, yet paved a solid sound for longetivity down the road. Warning reminds me of the old grandpa sitting on the porch with a Lucky Strike, telling stories stories on how to live life. Very rootsy and actually quite a boring listen coming from the once hXc Berkeley punk group. Now with a total Queer Eyed make over and a silly little concept. Green Day is back to take their thrones of the overplayed pop assholes of the universe.

American Idiot is a romp through a so called "punk-opera." Along with the punk-opera comes two completely over hyped, yet vaguely interesting 9 minute 'epics'. The reason I placed the word 'epic' in paraphrasing tones, is because they are just a mesh of shorter Green Day songs blended to make 9 minutes. Nothing like actual 9 minute songs you can hear from many metal/prog acts. Jesus Of Suburbia is very catchy. Bring forth the thickening silly little plot which is refered to throughout the album. Angsty, yet not losing the signature bubble punk GD has been known for. Homecoming is the closest song that can carry such a label as an opera sound. With more mood swings than your pedophile uncle on cocaine, Homecoming varies with depth on instrumental playing, which isn't found too much on here. Tre Cool makes his first vocal appearance since the hidden track on Dookie with part 4 "Rock and Roll Girlfriend." And releases one of my favorite taglines to use on my mother "Nobody likes you, everyone left you. They're all out without you, having fun." She hates it, since she is already contemplating driving her entire family into a lake, killing us all. That kidder she is. Anyways, lyrically the album is different than previous efforts because of the plot line. It does seem the plot line doesn't lead anywhere, instead looping itself in a familiar pattern.

See what happens when aging veteran punkers try to capture the limelight once again? They claim to create a work of art that will revolutionize the pop world and waiting for bites. Over 5 million bites to be exact. Perhaps they should have learned to write something that hasn't been written umpteen times before, or put some fatal earwigs within each bait they've set out. Sure, the concept idea is unique in a way and will more in likely spark a new fad in the future with many useless concept albums to come. But the musicianship has became more dull over the years. Billie Joe for the most part kept it simple, without expanding as much as his ego has. Also, if he wears any more 'guy'liner, I think I'm going to puke up my ham sandwich. Mike Dirnt (with some special exceptions in the 9 minute 'epics') follows along with Billies mildly played guitar licks. And who is this dip**** performing on stage with them, why doesn't he have a spot in the band as he does provide many good fills on guitar to pick up on Billie's slack. Tre Cool is the exception to the sad progression as a musician line-up. He is still more wild than ever and keeps my interest in this shish-kabob of an album.

Cheese.

Many older fans bitch and moan on how they've abandoned their past sound for a more conforming pop-culture way of life. Yes and no.

The Green Day that you know and love is still here. And is more evident in tracks like St. Jimmy, which can sound like it can be in albums from Dookie to Nimrod. The title track American Idiot's ear catching ever so recognizable guitar lick, which (like some of past material) is hard to shake out of your head. Holiday can also be found on past GD material, if it wasn't for the political turn of lyrics that proceeded. And my personal favorite Letterbomb, which is placed perfectly on the album to recapture my wandering interest. Letterbomb to me is a summary on why Green Day has been in my musical library in the past. Keeping a frantic pace while not overdoing it, Letterbomb starts off with my mothers favorite "Nobody likes you" line and comes in with clean power chords. This song actually reminds me of Kerplunk days in a way. Also gives a nice uplifting line "It's not over 'til you're underground." Sure, it's no Eye Of The Tiger, but it fuels my fire.

The counterpoint to the same Green Day you know, is that they quite possibly try too hard. Trying too hard to give off the impression that they've came of age too firmly. Are We The Waiting wants to be so much more. It wants to be living proof that Green Day's past of catchy hooks and simple song structures are a thing of the past. Yet falters because it fails to produce anything different outside of their sound. Two words to describe the track. Boring and repetitive. The chorus drags thought the end, making the song seem a lot longer than the 2:45 it was given. Whatsername I actually quite liked. It touched me in a place that isn't near my belt buckle. It's one of 2 ballad like songs and it happens to be the last track. It's about a girl whom got away, and wondering how she's doing. The instrumentals are simple, but does its job. The next ballad type of song is Wake Me Up When September Ends. In which is about the pains as a boy to deal with his fathers death. This song feels more epic than the 9 minute songs, being it's near 5 and it feels that way. Simply the best single from the album.

In conclusion, I would like to state that Green Day growing up has always been apart of my life. Since my aunt gave me a copy of Dookie on cassette on my birthday in 1994. Throughout the years it has helped to develop my taste in music since the tender age of 8. Now since this album was released, and also the aftermath. I've grown to realize how the attitude of the band has changed. It seemed they've used to be fun loving party punkers, but now a deeper serious tone has taken over. That doesn't take away that this is a solid album. The effort shows and perhaps they deserved the success they have received. Although I have very little hopes for the fading future of Green Day.

The Sludge's Thumb Ups:
Letterbomb
Wake Me Up When September Ends
Whatsername



Recent reviews by this author
Bon Jovi 100 Million Bon Jovi Fans Can't Be WrongThe Offspring Rise and Fall, Rage and Grace
New Found Glory From the Screen to Your Stereo Part IIRide Nowhere
Akon KonvictedAndrew W.K. The Wolf
user ratings (3669)
Chart.
3.3
great
other reviews of this album
1 of

Comments:Add a Comment 
Iluvatar
Staff Reviewer
November 5th 2006



16071 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5 | Sound Off

UH OH PREPARE FOR DICK COMMENT THAT YOU'LL WANT TO COMPLAIN ABOUT AND MAKE SHTTY RATIONALIZATIONS AGAINST LIKE "WE CAN REVIEW WHATEVER WE WANT"









Why?This Message Edited On 11.05.06

The Sludge
November 5th 2006



2169 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

I'm so awesome. I probably have the 4th or 5th best review for the album. But I had fun with it.

mynameischan
Staff Reviewer
November 5th 2006



17913 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

blah blah blah unneeded blah blah blah

The review was good. Although I do believe that some of the poop jokes were unnecessary. But for the most part, it was a fun read.

The Door Mouse
November 5th 2006



2092 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

iluv:^^^wut?
anywho good review. though i do hate this album. wmuwse gets me mad wenever i hear it.This Message Edited On 11.05.06

mynameischan
Staff Reviewer
November 5th 2006



17913 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Oh and this album is pretty awesome.

The Sludge
November 5th 2006



2169 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

I'll probably edit out some of the unecessary potty humor sometime when my computer isn't acting like it contained an STD.

Waterloo_Sunset
November 6th 2006



452 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

agree somewhat with what you said - but didnt quite get your rationale for giving it 3.5. I agree that it has a few good songs - but it has alot of average or worse songs... not a Solid album in my books. Nice effort, but I'll be dull and say it wasnt need!

godLike
November 6th 2006



126 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

I hope this is the last one of them, they reached their zenith many years ago.

The Sludge
November 6th 2006



2169 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

Woot. It went over well. No neg's by mourning :D.

Thanks guys, I seemed proud of this review as I didn't the past few ones I written. Maybe I just need to let loose and have fun with them.

nirvana1989_nb
November 6th 2006



98 Comments


if they do release another album they'll get laughed at
they shud have given up after nimrod


Serpento
November 6th 2006



2351 Comments


Ha, nice job. More breeding ground for the tumultuous GD-haters and fanboys. :P

Electric City
Staff Reviewer
November 6th 2006



15693 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

Yay, now thew occupation I have in my profile will make sense to noobs!

Digging: Nmesh - Dream Sequins [AMDISCS]

metallicaman8
November 6th 2006



4677 Comments

Album Rating: 1.0

Hate the album, don't hate the review.

The Sludge
November 6th 2006



2169 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

Yay, now thew occupation I have in my profile will make sense to noobs!

Welcome back to the work force.

Oddsen
November 6th 2006



1127 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Fun read. This would be a much better album with out all that radioplay and a couple of really poor and bland songs (extrodinary girl, shes a rebel) but overall its very good. Jesus of Suburbia is an amazing song.

The Sludge
November 6th 2006



2169 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

Yay thank you all, now I can be a real boy again.

foreverendeared
November 13th 2006



14678 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

haha good review..... by the way, i edited my first review on DC's new album that you commented on, hoping you could re-read it and tell me what you think since i think your reviews are always great. thanks



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2013 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy