Feeder
Echo Park


3.5
great

Review

by Med57 EMERITUS
January 14th, 2005 | 10 replies | 7,677 views


Release Date: 2001 | Tracklist


The Band: Grant Nicholas (Guitars & Vocals)
Taka Hirose (Bass Guitar)
Jon Lee (Drums)

Released: 2001 (Echo)

Echo Park is the third full length album from Welsh band Feeder, and was the last recorded with then drummer Jon Lee before his tragic suicide in January 2002. It marks a progression from their sound on previous albums, which was, at the risk of slipping into clichť, more pub rock than anything else. Although there are moments that can only be classified as rock on this album, there is added subtlety here, which shows the beginnings of the change in sound that 4th album, Come Back Around, would showcase. However, in the eyes of many critics, including my own, this album remains the most complete, and indeed the best thing that this band has yet put out.

Feederís change in style is evident as early as the opening track, with repeated changes in dynamics and tone of the song, with Nicholas singing softly and with tenderness at times, and with a rock swagger at others. Whatís also notable is Jon Leeís pounding drumming, which confirms my belief that he was one of the more underrated drummers in mainstream music. However, if the opening track is impressive albeit slightly odd, Buck Rogers is a revelation. This defines anthemic in my opinion, with seemingly nonsensical lyrics belying the fact that this song is so blatantly about hope and genuinely good things with a chorus largely consisting of, ďI think weíre gonna make it". Again, itís nothing original, but itís strangely impressive nonetheless, and definitely a standout track on here that still gets played on the radio on summer days over here. Itís just got that feel to it where you canít help somehow feeling good when you listen to it.

Piece By Piece is another precursor to the ďnew" Feeder, as itís another song that wouldnít sound out of place at all on Comfort In Sound. Grant sings with eerie foresight that ďnothing ever lasts forever", but this is a slower song all the way through, without any of the crazily dramatic dynamics of Standing On The Edge. One of the strengths of this album, in my opinion, is that only 3 songs go over 4 minutes, showing that Feeder know what they are good at, writing anthemic soft rock music. While this leaves this open to accusations that they are not challenging themselves musically, I would say that this album does show a definite progression in their music, albeit one that many bands have done before. They just arenít a band that is suited to writing epic songs.

Seven Days In The Sun is another of my favourite songs on here, with more strange lyrics over a feel good melody, as the title suggests. This shows off the solidness of Taka Hirose as a bassist, with an impressive bassline, but also the drumming power of Jon Lee, who makes this song for me with regular fills and a beat driving it on. This is another rock song, but when you look at British bands that Feeder get compared with, for example The Stereophonics, I think this shows that Feeder are vastly better when making the same sort of music. We Canít Rewind is more of a ballad, with a power-pop chorus, but itís another very good song that inspires hope in the listener, with the chorus ďThis is our time, we canít rewind, our place to shine now". It also features the first real guitar solo of the album, that while it isnít exactly Steve Vai fits the song very well, and takes it to a new level for me. So far the album has been an outstanding Britrock album in my opinion, with enough variety to keep the listener interested, but it really starts showing a new style at this stage.

Turn features effects-laden guitars playing music reminiscent of The Thrills mixed with Coldplay more than anyone else to me, but somehow it sounds fresh despite the again, not overly original lyrics. Itís another good song, and one thatís just made to be played live and get the crowd on their feet. Itís songs like this that make Feeder regulars at most UK festivals, as itís got that summer feel to it again, as does much of this album. Choke is the first song for me where standards dip somewhat, as itís more of a shouty attempt than anything else, and the production sounds strangely off, maybe with the drums just not sounding quite right. Oxygen though is a very broody, far better song, with a mournful guitar line leading into Nicholas warning ďWeíre all connected". The chorus becomes slightly more upbeat, although this is a song thatís somewhat atypical of the album, but still very compelling and impressive. The layered vocals here show, possibly more than anything else, the fact that while they can write a great anthemic soft-rock tune, they do have a side that can experiment; they merely know where their limits are, but this song shows a Feeder that you wouldnít know existed on the strength of the first 2 albums.

Tell All Your Friends has a very funky bassline as an intro, and itís a song that builds with some pounding drumming before fading again as Grant seems to reign in his band. One of the things I most like about Feeder is the feeling you get that they are a band that love playing together, and this is the case on this song, with more genuinely joyful lyrics and vocals over inventive drumming for a band with a sound like this. Under The Weather is another of the more experimental songs on here, with what I think are vocal samples at the beginning before distorted vocals singing about a wish for return to youth, and ďDebbie Harry and Steve McQueen". Itís sung from very much a teenage point of view as well, and is yet another anthem on here that everyone can sing along with. This is a prime example of a band pushing their sound beyond where it was before, while making music that they know will appeal to their fanbase. Itís not exactly Radiohead, but itís another song that hits the spot.

Satellite News is comfortably the longest song on here, and is another slower song that could easily have been a single off the next album. Grant Nicholas for me has an underrated voice that is displayed here very well, showing that heís not one of these British singers that settles for not getting the most out of himself and his band (the Gallaghers anyone?) but someone who is determined to make the most of the opportunity he has, with what is not the most talented of bands ever to grace the big stage. Bug is a strange ending to the album, as a vaguely punk sounding track to me, which takes the listener somewhat by surprise, also due to the heavier riffing than many of the tracks on here. Itís a good end though, that again shows some of their different types of music. The song ends in a hail of feedback, before what sounds like a computer gameís music ends the album. Itís a strange end, but nevertheless a good one.

I hadnít listened to this album for a while before I refound it about 2 weeks ago, and decided to give it another listen. For some reason Iíd associated it with all the other Britrock bands like Supergrass, but this album really does go beyond that stereotype. If you like that sort of music, then this is a must-buy, but even if not, I can recommend checking it out. This is not an earth-changing album, it's not full of complex time signatures and strange instruments, but it offers a lot of anthemic music, which I can tell you from experience sounds brilliant live. This is a band that work very hard (along with Muse, they are probably the most prolific tourers among UK bands), and that shows with their dedication to making the best music they can on here. Comfort In Sound was a bit of a dissapointment for me after this, although that was possibly inevitable after Jon Lee's death, but this remains nonetheless, a good album.

Download: Buck Rogers
Seven Days In The Sun
We Can't Rewind
Under The Weather

Final Rating: 3.5/5



Recent reviews by this author
Guns N' Roses Appetite for DestructionHanoi Rocks Two Steps From The Move
Savage Garden AffirmationTool 10,000 Days
Scott Walker TiltThe Pogues Rum Sodomy & the Lash
user ratings (83)
Chart.
3.7
great
other reviews of this album
Benjamin Bland (3.5)
The album that took Feeder from an indie fan's curiosity to a mainstream concern - anthems galore!...


Comments:Add a Comment 
Med57
Moderator
September 14th 2004



1001 Comments


Any opinions on the band, this album, or my review? Or is the silence the only message I need? :upset:.

The Ashtray Girl
September 14th 2004



108 Comments


Sorry, missed it first time around. Most impressive review :thumb:, and I'm downloading the tracks right now. Always forget how much I like Feeder.

Adam Jones is GOD
April 11th 2005



113 Comments


Feeder's last decent album IMO, and one that's still strangely absent from my collection. Terrible review Med, just sums up the album brilliantly well in a terrible way

/sarcasm

Did they ever release a version with just A Day on, or did that stay as an EP?

feeder_4ever
June 14th 2005



17 Comments


Right you guys knows nothings.
Feeders 4th album was called Comfort in sound not Com back around.
Just a day was released on Echo park but only on one edition of the album and is now available on the limited edition B side collection: Picture of Perfect youth.
Brilliant review though, I love Feeder.
R.I.P Jon Lee.

Med57
Moderator
June 14th 2005



1001 Comments


Oh yeah, whoops...what's worrying is I got it right at one stage of the review, but wrong at the start. :-/

Iai
Emeritus
June 14th 2005



3553 Comments


I do that all the time. Just caught in my Opeth review that I called Mikael 'Michael', twice.

gladass
September 24th 2005



4 Comments


good review. i wouldnt say its their last good album, because their more recent two (comfort in sound, pushing the senses) are good but just a different sound. because of great fan feedback to their re-releasing of 'Shatter' (an old 90's, quite heavy track) its rumoured that they are going to try go back to their roots. good on them. RIP Jon Lee

jdrichie3112
February 5th 2006



7 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Hate to butt in here, but Med and Feeder 4ever, ur both slightly wrong. feeder's 4th album was actually a re-release of the 6-track Swim EP, this time with 11 tracks and 2 videos. Comfort In Sound was in fact the 5th album from Feeder. Oh and just so you know, Just A Day will also be available on the singles/greatest hits album later this year

thebassguy
June 23rd 2007



3 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

This is one of the few albums that I can listen to any time, any place without losing interest - every song has great hooks, and thats what makes it an awesome album.

Snooze00
November 7th 2012



229 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Sorry but you lost me at
"For some reason IÔŅĹd associated it with all the other Britrock bands like Supergrass, but this album really does go beyond that stereotype."


I would never associate supergrass with anything that may suggest that they are lesser in any way to this band and just simply stereotypically Britpop. They have a way more impressive overall body of work which is more diverse then feeder can come up with IMO. Now you can bow down to there awesomness. TY




You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2013 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy