Silversun Pickups
Carnavas


4.0
excellent

Review

by Bron-Yr-Aur USER (39 Reviews)
August 26th, 2006 | 216 replies


Release Date: 2006 | Tracklist

Review Summary: An accessible marriage of grunge and indie rock.

When reviewing a debut album, one must tread the path lightly. If you over-praise a band’s effort, that very same band that you heartily commended could present you with over-indulgent or profoundly meek crap next time they put forward an album. The flip side, and usually the more worn-out path where debut albums are concerned, is inherently more dangerous. Take for example, the cheek of Rolling Stone magazine, who felt it appropriate to slander and defecate all over Jimmy Page and his “Led Zeppelin”. The same feisty conglomerate also added Nirvana and Queen to the list after word, as well as other groups I am admittedly too lazy to research. The grandiloquent irony in this is, of course, that all three of the aforementioned bands more or less rose to the status of Gods, generation spokesmen, and irreverent innovators, respectively, and is a prime reason why when someone wants to brand a new group with any such adjectives as “pretentious”, “obnoxious”, or “Barbara Streisand”, they should perhaps step carefully. Of course, there are bands that put forth something that one knows how to brand upon first listen; the kind of group that you know your opinion on right after finishing the album. Well for me, dear reader, that band is Los Angeles own Silversun Pickups.


Going back to the Queen/Nirvana/Zeppelin referencing, each one of those groups had something naturally special about them. Freddie Mercury was how Jesus would have acted if he was bi-sexual. Kurt Cobain was introspective and killed hair metal. Robert Plant wore his shirt unbuttoned. So, what makes these Silversun Pickups unusual? First and foremost, the leading man and resident exclusive of the group guitarist/singer Brian Aubert. The very first thing one takes note of on first hearing is Aubert’s unique voice, which ranges from mellow and soothing to fierce and emotional. Aside for his very unique vocal style, he has a knack for subtle guitar playing; a style that can make a simple powerchord section vibrate with wall-shaking power. However, he is at least a fairly skilled player in his own right, coloring the album with strings of appregiated triads and other such nonsense, and even throws in a solo or two. Reverting back to the subject of vocals, bassist/vocalist Nikki Monninger has a rather pleasing knack of providing harmony vocals, which tends to make whatever song you’re listening to far better than it would’ve been. Occasionally, she’ll score her own individual vocal sections, as found in the fuzzy and grooving Little Lovers So Polite, a song which, for all it’s merit, would be a shadow of it’s former self without her.


Speaking of fuzz, you could drown in it when listening to this record. Whether it helps define Aubert’s tastefully subtle guitar playing or is manipulated by keyboard/crazy noise master Joe Lester, the textured and often melancholic atmosphere becomes even more endless than it was before, which actually says a lot as Lester is constantly complimenting Brian’s bittersweet melodies and lyrics with either eerie or downright soothing backdrops. As a matter of fact, that pretty much defines this album. Throw in a few choice words like ‘melancholic’ and ‘atmospheric’ and you’ve got the very essence of Carnavas. Going from a song like Lazy Eye, which exudes mountains of hopeful disappointment lyrically with music to match to a tune such as Rusted Wheel with its’ emboldened frustration (again with creepily fitting instrumentals) is not an easy feat for a veteran groups third album, let alone a band’s debut (full-length, that is).


Ah, the groove. Such an interesting musical feature. When done properly, you’d be hard-pressed to find something that expels such emotion, be it joy, sorrow, angst, anger, whatever. Should you fail to create one properly, you’ll probably sound something like… Limp Bizkit. As shown on the EP Pikul, and more specifically on the track Kissing Families, the Pickups are already masters of the groove, and display it virtually all throughout the album. Rusted Wheel, Well Thought Out Twinkles (the most rocking song on the album), and the album closing Common Reactor are perhaps the shining examples of the groups’ mastery of the art. Even more delightful, instead of recycling the same feel to each one, every individual groove not only fits and enhances the song, but has a distinctly different feel than the others and more over a personality of its own.



Perhaps the most relieving thing about the group is its’ ego. I guarantee you now; you will never stumble across a two and a half minute guitar solo, an irritating drum solo, or an insufferable keyboard binge. Everything done on the album by each individual band member is tasteful and relevant, usually to the point where the song just wouldn’t be the same without it. The shining example of this is the rhythm section, made up of bassist Nikki Monninger and drummer Christopher Guanlao. Neither of them are technically astounding in any sense of the word. However, both do their respective roles, and actually very interestingly. While Monninger has a tendency to thump along on a root note for some time, she’ll also mix it up by shifting the melody whilst the others keep to the original course, or maintaining it as the rest of the group descends into chaos. Guanlao, for his part, tends to take simple beats and spin them differently; that is to say, put variations of the standard formula into a song, often to the point that it seems almost improvised. Out of the two, Guanlao is superior at his respective instrument, but Nikki more than makes up for this by providing stunningly poignant back-up vocals and for being a girl in a rock band. ROCK!


However, as with all debuts, the album is certainly not without fault. Remember that whole spiel about descending into chaos I mentioned? Yeah, well it could be argued they do it a little too often. It’s rather like a Pink Floyd sound-binge, though mercifully much shorter. Some, I included, can look past this. Others may not be able to. Also detracting from the album’s score is the track Waste It On, which for all it’s crazy time-signatures and idealistic structures fails to provide any of the goodness the rest of the album conjures up, and overall comes off as a rather poor attempt at originality, especially compared to the rest of the record. While these are the main detractors, there a few other irks, most notably in the song Dream At Tempo 119, which tends to get a bit uncomfortable as it switches from hazy, poignant tones to stomping, unadulterated rock and back again. And again. While not a major hindering, a song like it does appear a little indecisive in itself, which does kill some merit.

I suppose the main question you’re wondering is should you bother to listen to this band. A fine question it is, too. Well, chances are it’s not exactly everyone’s cup o’ tea, but I fail to see how you could not come out of a listen for the better. You could end up as I have, loving the album and eagerly awaiting their sophomore effort and for a stop in my/your town, or you could slowly and cautiously back away; wiser from the experience. Soaring melodies, oodles of texture, thumping grooves and introspective lyrics are well worth the time it takes to download, or the money it costs to purchase this, the Silversun Pickups full-length debut album. Besides, there’s a real live GIRL in the band! Which totally makes up for any fault ever, right? Uh… Right?



From Me To You

Melatonin
Well Thought Out Twinkles
Little Lovers So Polite
Future Foe Scenarios
Rusted Wheel
Common Reactor


4/5



Recent reviews by this author
Pink Floyd The Dark Side of the MoonThe Haunted The Haunted Made Me Do It
The Beatles Please Please MeLed Zeppelin Led Zeppelin
Rage Against the Machine The Battle of Los AngelesEvanescence Fallen
user ratings (797)
Chart.
3.9
excellent
other reviews of this album
Max R. (5)
Because maybe if we're loud we'll stay alive....

backinhindsight (4.5)
A+ Fuzz Rock...

Porter W. Richards (4.5)
Comparisons to Smashing Pumpkins are inevitable, but the band makes an album that was almost perfect...

Michael Schmitt (4.5)
Silversun Pickups blast their way beyond their live act and into their first album. Carnavas shows w...


Comments:Add a Comment 
The Jungler
August 27th 2006


4827 Comments


Awesome, Bron reviewing indie!
The song they have up on the site is a bit annoying, but I've learned not to trust those. Good review and stuff.

Iluvatar
Staff Reviewer
August 27th 2006


16088 Comments


You can get banned for using a fake name btw. I do believe thats what mx said when he first implemented the rule.
Good review, but I just can't stand the band at all.

Pyramidman
August 27th 2006


1340 Comments


i really like what ive heard

Bron-Yr-Aur
August 27th 2006


4405 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

[quote=Iluvatar]You can get banned for using a fake name btw.[/quote]
I'll probably change it soon or something.

Thanks for the praise.

Channing
August 27th 2006


497 Comments




Bron-Yr-Aur
August 27th 2006


4405 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Hi Custimus :wave:

Have you heard this band, perchance?This Message Edited On 08.27.06

Channing
August 27th 2006


497 Comments


Hey babe :wave:

Nope.

Activista anti-MTV
August 27th 2006


3140 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

Who is this Lord Xenu? Who is this warrior, that battles not with mail and sword, but rather wielding a stainless syntax and an unending quiver full of wit? Slaying misinformation where it sleeps, bringing it\'s head to the villagers. Who pay a high ransom for the sense of security that the knight has provided. Good work indeed, my friend.This Message Edited On 09.01.06

Channing
August 27th 2006


497 Comments


GAY

Hey Bron, should I check these guys out? I probably won't get around to it ever, but yeah.

Activista anti-MTV
August 27th 2006


3140 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

[quote=chan]GAY[/quote]
Your such a cutie.

Bron-Yr-Aur
August 27th 2006


4405 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

http://sputnikmusic.com/party.php?party=3

Fairly good introduction there, Channing. If you like that, their myspace has two other one that are just as good, but might take some growing time. I don\'t go there though, because I\'m too pimpin\' for myspace.This Message Edited On 08.27.06

Channing
August 27th 2006


497 Comments


sorry but i have dialup so yeah

Your such a cutie.

wuvz u


Bron-Yr-Aur
August 27th 2006


4405 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

You can't listen to a sputnik listening party with dial-up?

Activista anti-MTV
August 27th 2006


3140 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

[quote=chan]wuvz u[/quote]
I am totally hetero trippin on this review right now :smoke:

Channing
August 27th 2006


497 Comments


You can't listen to a sputnik listening party with dial-up?

It takes awhile and I don't feel like waiting.

Oddsen
August 27th 2006


1127 Comments


Did you ever finnish reviewing all the led and beatles albums? Good work as usual.

Bron-Yr-Aur
August 27th 2006


4405 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I've still got some Beatles albums left, and I'll eventually get around to them.

Channing
August 27th 2006


497 Comments


yeah in about three years

heyseuss
August 27th 2006


384 Comments


Hey good review, but I never heard these guys. Sounds very interesting though so I'll look into it.

ALL THANKS TO LORD XENU HEIL XENU

Channing
August 27th 2006


497 Comments


Sounds very interesting though so I'll look into it.

Stop lying.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy