Cor Scorpii
Attergangar


4.5
superb

Review

by Nepenthe USER (5 Reviews)
August 14th, 2006 | 13 replies | 5,620 views


Release Date: 2005 | Tracklist


1 of 1 thought this review was well written

Cor Scorpii - Attergangar

Lineup
Gaute Refsnes - Keyboards
Rune Sjøthun - Rhythm Guitars
Stian Bakketeig - Lead Guitars
Thomas S. Øvstedal - Vocals
Inge Jonny Lomheim - Bass Guitars
Jørn Holen - Drums

Background
From the ashes of Windir, arise Cor Scorpii. After the tragic death of Valfar (R.I.P.), the other members of Windir found it best to lay the band to rest with him. Several months after his passing, Gaute Refsnes decided to assemble a new band. He enlisted the help of Stian Bakketeig and Jørn Holen, former bandmates, and filled the rest of the holes of the lineup with unknown Norwegian musicians. Attergangar is a four song demo released in the final days of 2005, and is Cor Scorpii's only recorded material thus far. Judging from this demo, it is obvious that Cor Scorpii are going to become one of the top bands of the Folk/Viking Metal world, as the legendary status of the three founding members is clearly apparent on this demo.

Pros
Due to the short length of this demo (23:06), I'll just be doing a shorter pros and cons review. The music found on Attergangar is a largely guitar oriented affair. Very similar to many of Windir's material, this is definately a guitar based outfit. And a very talented one at that. The guitars on Attergangar are phenomenal. No riff is too extremely technical, but the playing is always tight, precise, and tasteful. Ranging from fast tremolo picking, to heavy riffing, to melodic leads, Stian and his new recruit Rune hold the band together with some of the best guitar playing you will ever hear on a Viking Metal album. Though I hate to have to compare Cor Scorpii to Windir so much, it's inevitable, as the two bands are so closely intwined that an obvious similarity is bound to happen. And it does. The guitars still have that dreamy sound about them, and they even break out into the crazy, pseudo carnival riff style that was made ever so popular in Windir (think the final minutes of The Blacksmith And Troll Of Lundamyri) on the last two tracks. The Key playing in Windir was never at the forefront of the music, but was always used to great effect minimally to create the epic sound they were known for. Well, the playing remains largely the same, save for it being even a little bit less in the foreground. It is mostly used only as a backup to the music, and rarely ventures out for a solo. I like them this way very much, as it is one of the few things that defines Cor Scorpii as something other than just Windir with a different vocalist. Which brings me to the vocals. A newcomer to the music scene, Thomas handles himself in fine fashion. He may not be Valfar, but both his clean and harsh vocals are very well done. Nothing spectacular, but incredibly solid. The music, much like it was in Windir, stays at a very fast pace at all times, never taking a break. This does not, as it does in many cases, equal a boring listen though, not by any means. The songs are all between five and six minutes long, all jam packed with upwards of seven riffs per song. That's right, five minute songs featuring near ten riffs to a song. The music is played out in an ever changing style, never going back to a riff once it has been played through once, so don't expect anything along the lines of choruses and verses. I really like this style, as it keeps the songs amazingly fresh throughout, and allows them to feel like twenty minute epics, when in reality they are normal lengthed.

Cons
There are very few downsides to this demo, and none of them are glaringly obvious, the only one that is being the obvious similarity to Windir. It is not to the point that it's a ripoff, but anyone listening to Cor Scorpii can easily tell that the band is the successor to the throne of Windir. The only real flaws on this album musically would have to come from the rhythm department. Both the Bass and Drumming are done very solidly, and the bass is even well heard, but neither of them really do anything outstanding. They do not detract anything from the music, but they do not add much either. Also, I have to mention that the short playing time is definately a con. Yes, it is a demo, and is actually a very generous length for one, but by the time Nar Enden Er God (the best track of the demo) is done playing, you begin to really wish there was more to it.

The Atmosphere
The atmosphere created is much like that of Windir, grandiose, but to a much lesser extent. On Fall Of Man and Attergangar, the Keys are barely heard at all, and only appear in the form of a Piano on Transcendental Journey (apart from the symphonic intro). On Nar Enden Er God though, they do take a much more prominant role as Choirs back the music up beautifully. Though the keys are used very sparingly, they are used very tastefully, and always make the music that much better. The array of different voices is nice too, as you'll get to hear Pianos, Trumpets, Choirs, Sci Fi sounding noises, Symphonies, and many others. The Guitars, though, are what really make the atmosphere on this album. That dreamy style that was ever so popular in Windir is back, and in full force. The riffing on Nar Enden Er God will leave a swirling scar in your head as it 'floats' on towards the end of the demo.

So, How Much Does This Sound Like Windir?
Well, this is the big question when it comes to Cor Scorpii. The answer is quite a bit. It is a given that when you take the main musicians from a band to create a new one, that the new one is going to sound a lot like the old one. The only noticeable differences lie in the more aggressive Guitar playing, the less up front Keys, and, of course, the new Vocalist. Does Thomas match up to Valfar? Of course not, no one ever will, but what Thomas does do is an incredible job, and I think that he is worthy to be the spiritual successor to Valfar. Although I've made it seem like this is just Windir reincarnate, you cannot go into the demo expecting Windir, as there are differences in sound, and of course they are not quite as good as Windir. With time, though, I think Cor Scorpii have a chance at becoming just as good as Windir, once they have a few albums out and have more time to play with each other and develop their own sound a bit.

Closing Comments
One of the best debuts I've heard in a long while, Cor Scorpii have made it clear that they will be a name to remember with this demo. I could easily see them becoming as big as Windir in time, and with good reason. When I first heard of the band, I really had grim expectations as I thought they were nothing without Valfar, but they have definately proven me wrong with Attergangar. An excellent cd for fans of fast paced, melodic, aggressive metal.

Short Pros And Cons
Pros:
Guitars
Keys minimalized
Song structure
Cons:
A bit too similar to Windir
Unoriginal rhythm department
Too short

Recommended Track
Nar Enden Er God


user ratings (17)
Chart.
4.1
excellent
related reviews

Monument
recommended by reviewer
Windir Arntor

Comments:Add a Comment 
Nepenthe
August 14th 2006



62 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Sheesh, not a very popular review.

Tyr
August 15th 2006



2 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Great review of a great band. A little too close sounding to Windir, maybe. Still a joyfull listen.This Message Edited On 08.15.06This Message Edited On 08.15.06

Txus
August 15th 2006



75 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Great review, Anthony. I really love this album, the Windir influences do show a lot but it's not really a copy-cat.

BallsToTheWall
July 3rd 2008



44164 Comments


The new album is quite breathtaking. Sounds a bit similar to Ikuinen Kaamos but not too much. Nice review and it's a shame these guys don't see much light here.

Top 5 metal album of the year for sure.This Message Edited On 07.03.08

foreverendeared
July 3rd 2008



14678 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

ah f*ck. i kinda forgot about these guys. i used to listen to them quite a bit last year but got lost in other music. it feels good to give this another spin

BallsToTheWall
July 3rd 2008



44164 Comments


uhh.This Message Edited On 09.26.08

foreverendeared
July 3rd 2008



14678 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

no i haven't. i'll definitely check it outThis Message Edited On 07.03.08

BallsToTheWall
July 3rd 2008



44164 Comments


Monument. I just added it and will possibly review in short time. It should hold all of us Ikuinen Kaamos fans still for a while. Also similar to this is the new album Kaoskult from Helheim. Get that as well.

FR33L0RD
September 22nd 2008



1461 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

IMHO, Superb album

FR33L0RD
September 25th 2008



1461 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

One of the best demo(album) in the melodic_black_metal scene.

foreverendeared
November 19th 2008



14678 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

this is a demo? i just though it was a lengthy EPThis Message Edited On 11.19.08

deathmetal101
November 28th 2009



300 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

this demo is great

Hawks
July 25th 2010



35362 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

This is pretty fucking great for a demo.

Digging: Brutal Truth - Extreme Conditions Demand Extreme Responses



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy