Devin Townsend
Lightwork


2.5
average

Review

by TheCrow USER (24 Reviews)
November 27th, 2022 | 9 replies


Release Date: 2022 | Tracklist

Review Summary: After three years of waiting and a couple of experimental albums in between, Devin Townsend returns with a new album called "Lightwork"! Sadly, it was not the comeback that we expected.

On this occasion, Devin Townsend collaborated with an external producer when recording this album, named Garth Richardson, famous for having worked with artists such as Danko Jones, Alice Cooper and Rise Against. In any case, the sound doesn't differ too much from what was found on previous Devin Townsend albums, and the truth is that Richardson's work, in my opinion, doesn't let itself be noticed so much.


Stylistically, what we have in “Lightwork” is a sort of comeback to the most commercial passages of albums like "Addicted!" and "Epicloud", with new age touches in the style of "Ghost", resulting in a somewhat monotonous and uninspired album, whose baroque aforementioned production is not able to hide.

That monotony is broken by the more progressive Heartbreaker, which reminds me of the more elaborate passages of the much superior "Transcendence", and a kind of homage to his most industrial phase in the interesting Dimensions, which includes a good solo by the always willing to collaborate Steve Vai.

Therefore, the fact that "Empath" didn't quite live up to expectations and that this "Lightwork" is a downright average album, makes me think that the golden boy of prog metal is slowly losing his magic touch.

But hey... We'll always have his great albums from the past!

Best Tracks: Moonpeople (good chorus and great guitar riffs), Heartbreaker (wonderful guitar work and a central part that brings back some of the chaos and genius that made Devin great in the past) and the aforementioned Dimensions (these growls!!!)



Recent reviews by this author
Marea RevolconExtremoduro Agíla
Extremoduro Rock TransgresivoExtremoduro ¿Dónde Están Mis Amigos?
Marea La PateraExtremoduro Pedra
user ratings (193)
3.7
great
other reviews of this album
Dizchu (4)
An attempt to find order in a time of chaos...

pizzamachine (3.5)
One album to rule them all, and in the Devin-ness bind them....



Comments:Add a Comment 
BookoftheFallen
November 27th 2022


1072 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Empath didn't quite live up to expectations? I dont think thats accurate.

TheCrow
November 27th 2022


20 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

Sorry, that's my opinion.



I think that "Empath", just like this "Lightwork", is one of Devin's weakest albums.



And I'm saying as a fan of Devin since I heard "Sex and Religion", back in 1995.

BenThatsMyJamin
November 27th 2022


4012 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I agree that Empath was a let down.



On the other hand, I'm loving this album and I say that as an old-school Dev fan. I had low expectations but it's honestly been a huge surprise for me.



I don't get the common criticisms about this being another Epicloud or Sky Blue. Certainly Dev set it up to be so, but there are only two pop metal songs on here: Lightworker and Celestial Signals, and for what it's worth I think they're both better than basically anything on the aforementioned albums, especially Celestial Signals which is simply excellent. Call of the Void is a pop song but different to anything he has written before. It's a really varied album and consistently great. Heavy Burden has been stuck in my head for the past week.

bgillesp
November 27th 2022


8867 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Not my favorite but still consistently great agreed @Ben

zaruyache
November 28th 2022


27410 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

DELET THIS RIGH NOWW

WalrusTusk
November 28th 2022


1812 Comments


You received a coupled negs, so here's my unsolicited feedback for your review.

In your second paragraph you take the time to mention production, but then state that does nothing for the record. If that's the case then there is no need to mention the production. If the production lends itself positively or negatively then there is a reason to bring it up. Otherwise delete the paragraph.

With your third paragraph, go talk about it being monotonous, but then don't really provide a reason for it. Be more specific and intentional with your language. I'm not sure "baroque" is the word you want to use in that instance.

You then mention "Empath" but because it just comes out of the blue it almost reads like you've been reviewing "Empath" the whole time. If you're going to mention that album take a paragraph to develop an idea on it and then transition your reader into how that correlates to "Lightwork"

TheCrow
November 28th 2022


20 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

Thank you for your feedback, WalrusTusk!

WalrusTusk
November 28th 2022


1812 Comments


I think there are some things we can do to make your 2.5 seem more justified, but in general make sure each time you transition from one idea to the next that you guide your reader through it. Provide them with a little context and then shift focus. But decent first draft!

Tundra
March 27th 2023


9694 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

I agree with the review, though you could have gone more in-depth with why you find the record to be average. Must explain the negs



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy