Sarah McLachlan



by Jom STAFF
May 23rd, 2006 | 20 replies

Release Date: 1997 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Featuring essential McLachlan tracks such as Adia, Angel, and Building a Mystery, 'Surfacing' is one of the Canadian singer-songwriter's best albums.

There's always some reason to feel not good enough.

This album follows the popular Fumbling Towards Ecstacy from 1993, where McLachlan details her experiences working with World Vision, a Canadian-sponsored organization that made a documentary that centered on child prostitution, poverty, and famine in countries in Southeast Asia (most notably Cambodia and Thailand). The album was raw, sincere, and deeply introspective. Even with these credentials, along with her successes that include the founding of the music festival known as Lilith Fair, it would be Surfacing that pushes McLachlan to stardom in the adult alternative genre.

Released in the summer of 1997, Surfacing is more or less Sarah's encore performance, and it drove her into the mainstream spotlight. Some may argue that this album's success is directly attributed to its release around Lilith Fair. With the assistance of producer Pierre Marchand, Sarah hammered out ten incredibly solid tracks with her soothing voice and beautiful tone. Yes, it's a shorter album (approximately forty-one minutes), but it further exemplifies that an album does not need to be filled to its eighty-minute brim in order to be a fully captivating listen.

The greatest aspect of Surfacing upon listening is hearing Sarah's tremendous growth as a songwriter and a musician. It's no secret that Sarah has consistently written songs that touch the spirit of human existence and experience. She sharpens and narrows her focus for Surfacing.

When asked what the album means to her, Sarah explains:

Surfacing is about me finally growing up and facing ugly things about myself. We all have a dark side; it's bullshit to say that we don't. At some point we're going to have to face that.

In short: if you are unfamiliar with Sarah McLachlan's work, use this album as your starting point.

To a casual or new fan, most will turn to her radio singles to pass judgment. In this case, it would be a brilliant move, as McLachlan's growth as a musician is best exemplified in these tracks. Masterfully incorporating piano, guitars, strings, and other assorted instruments is an obvious strength, and she executes it to near perfection.

The first example is the album's first track, Building a Mystery, which is dominated with acoustic and clean electric guitar chord progressions. She flawlessly enters into each song, and she exhibits great control and tone with her voice, from her lower register to her falsettos. She playfully sings to a love interest throughout, but asks, "Can you look out the window without your shadow getting in the way?" Lines such as this haunt portions of her songs, but such is the magic of her lyrical arrangements: McLachlan effectively conveys images of light and dark, happy and sad, and black and white into her music. The guitar progressions are done impeccably well, especially in the intro and the instrumental bridge, which also features a clean guitar solo and McLachlan reprising the chorus. Reprising and ad-libbing portions of songs are yet another strength McLachlan showcases on this album.

Sweet Surrender and Adia were also singles, and are also two of the best tracks on the album. The former track has electronic foundations backed by solid basslines. Her practically angelic voice in the chorus melts with the instruments, which whimsically fall away as she croons in and out of each channel. The dubbed vocals that McLachlan employs help bolster the track, with the standard highhat-bass-snare rhythm driving the song when the electronic feel of the song dissipates. Adia highlights McLachlan's musicianship with piano, but again, it is her voice and storytelling that take centerstage on the track. The standout portion of the song is the second half of the chorus, with Sarah's higher register shining powerfully over the instruments as she sings to Adia that "[W]e are born innocent... it's easy, we all falter... does it matter?" The percussion serves as the song's metronome with the shuffling snare and sporadic crash cymbals, but again, McLachlan's wispy voice and discussion with Adia are the integral keys to this song's engine: throughout the song, Sarah addresses her friend Adia, saying she could show her all the beauty Adia possesses, if only she'd let herself believe it.

Whenever the songs on Surfacing are just McLachlan and her piano, it makes for absolutely chilling yet incredibly beautiful music. Do What You Have to Do is a somber ballad, featuring this combo and the addition of cello. Flawlessly, McLachlan hits her higher notes with ease, singing that she has "the sense to recognize" that she can't let go, with "every moment marked with apparitions of your soul." Again, the piano is what makes this track captivating; even when Sarah isn't singing, her work on the piano adds to the elegiac mood of the track. The instrumental and vocal crescendos performed by McLachlan further emphasize McLachlan, not only as a vocalist, but as a musician as well.

However, far and away the best track on the album is the incredibly melancholy Angel, which features only McLachlan and her piano once again. Her vocals, combined with the piano, soar in the most depressing aspect of the song - the chorus. In it, McLachlan sings to her friend ascending into Heaven:

In the arms of an angel, fly away from here
From this dark cold hotel room and the endlessness that you fear
You are pulled from the wreckage of your silent reverie
You're in the arms of the angel, may you find some comfort there

This track is a classic Sarah McLachlan track, much like I Will Remember You is a classic song: it invokes emotions of many degrees, and McLachlan's voice is incredibly soothing, even if somber.

Last Dance is an all-instrumental track, clocking in at 2:32. As predicted, the track features Sarah on piano, with a cello accompaniment. At 1:04, the next movement begins, with an interesting effect becoming more prominent between the piano and cello - it sounds like a whistle being blown underwater. The song slows to a faint decrescendo, and the last piano chord rings silent, ending the album.

The album falters only in a couple spots, mostly due to production and some passages of songs, such as Full of Grace, seem to plod along and drag. The orchestral accompaniments typically add another dimension to the tracks, but can be either pushed too high into the mix or rendered practically inaudible in others. However, as a whole, the album is an easy listen from start-to-finish because each track segues flawlessly into the next without much thought.

Overall, Surfacing is a necessity to fans of the singer/songwriter and/or adult alternative genre. The album exemplifies McLachlan's growth as a vocalist and musician to a spectacular degree. Again, for a newcomer to her music or a casual fan, this album is imperative to listen to because it showcases some of McLachlan's best material to date. The album, while rather short and does sport a couple rough patches, highlights McLachlan's lovely, radial voice and her proficiency on the piano, and is overall a beautiful listen.


Jom recommends:

Building a Mystery
Do What You Have to Do
Sweet Surrender

Recent reviews by this author
Ghost (SWE) MelioraStrung Out Transmission.Alpha.Delta
Alien Ant Farm Always and ForeverButch Walker Afraid of Ghosts
Hilltop Hoods Walking Under StarsThe Gaslight Anthem Get Hurt
user ratings (79)

Comments:Add a Comment 
Zesty Mordant
May 23rd 2006


great review, though I can't really tolerate her music too much. She is played CONSTANTLY on adult contemporary and top 40 stations all over Canada.

There is simply no escaping her.

I will definately agree that she has a great voice though.This Message Edited On 05.23.06

May 23rd 2006


Album Rating: 3.0

Yeah I've heard this album before only becuase my mom used to always play it. Its pretty good actually, despite being something i normally woulnd't like. The opening track is pretty cool. And great review Jom.This Message Edited On 05.23.06

Broken Arrow
May 23rd 2006


Yeah she's always on the radio here. I dont mind though, she has a great voice. She's one of my guilty pleasures so to speak.

Electric City
May 23rd 2006


I'm jw, why did you delete all your old ones if you're going to repost them again?

Great review, btw.

Digging: Foxing - Dealer

May 23rd 2006


Album Rating: 3.5

He's rewriting them slightly I do believe.

And god do I love this album for some reason. This is "Me-Mom bonding time" music. Excellent review as well.

November 4th 2006


Album Rating: 3.5

I really like this album. It faltered a bit at the end, but overall it was excellent. Nice review too. And Sarah Mclachlan's a babe.

February 10th 2007


Album Rating: 5.0

Sarah McLachlan is so unusual to me. I like everything about her, she has some sort of mystery about her, makes you curious. I was very curious after hearing "Angel". I looked for the "City Of Angels" soundtrack and I liked that song the most! Now after hearing this and a couple more of her albums I am a true fan, and great admirer. 4 Juno awards, one must admit she is very accomplished. Besides "Angel" which I couldn't get out of my head for weeks, the ones that stick are: Sweet Surrender, Black And White, Building A Mystery, Adia.

Afterglow is also an album full of sweets. I put the album on play from start to finish as I was resting before going out, and although the songs tend to lounge you to sleep (in a good way) one got stuck in my head through something like a waking sleep state. It was the song called "Stupid". I kept hearing the verses over and over again in my half-sleep and it was subliminal because when I went out I kept thinking about it and singing it more and more. I was under a spell, nothing from that nights out in town remained more wedged in my memory than words of the "Stupid" song...

"How stupid could I be,

A simpleton can see,

That you're no good for me,

But you're the only one I see"

Quite infectious!

February 10th 2007


Album Rating: 5.0

Yeah, by the way, the review was a fantastic reading material. You wrote it with heart ;)

September 8th 2007


Album Rating: 5.0

One of the best albums of its kind...

September 19th 2007


nice review. i've heard most of the songs from this already. i think she has one of the most beautiful and depressing voices around.

for some reason i can't vote on reviews anymore. any idea why?

September 19th 2007


Album Rating: 3.5

staff review, so you can't vote

anyway this album has building a mystery


it wins

May 2nd 2008


Album Rating: 3.5

also i've been listening to this since I was a kid considering this is a parental favourite

December 22nd 2008


Album Rating: 4.0

One of my favorite albums, it brings back childhood memories for me.

February 5th 2009


Album Rating: 3.5

Building a mystery is such a great song.

April 3rd 2009


Angel is pretty much the saddest song ever.

January 11th 2010


Sweet Surrender takes me back

January 20th 2010


So many amazing tracks.

December 23rd 2010


Building A Mystery is beautiful.

Digging: Armor For Sleep - What To Do When You Are Dead

December 23rd 2010


Surfacing + Fumbling Towards Ecstasy are both incredible albums, songs have such beauty and melancholy.

Contributing Reviewer
November 19th 2014


nice album

Digging: Ulvesang - Ulvesang

You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile


Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Site Copyright 2005-2014
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy