Rush
Hold Your Fire


3.0
good

Review

by Brendan Schroer USER (186 Reviews)
June 20th, 2014 | 67 replies


Release Date: 1987 | Tracklist


Chapter XII: Pop Commands Prog

Following the success of the solid Power Windows and its subsequent tour, Rush took a much-needed break so they could be with their loved ones and relax. However, after a mere few months had passed, the band members quickly started letting the creative juices flow again and they started writing material for their follow-up release Hold Your Fire. Once the promotional single "Force Ten" was released to the public, it was clear to everyone that Rush hadn't given up on the poppier arrangements of the previous record; in fact, it seemed even more accessible than usual! With punchy drum work and flashy synthesizer bursts from Geddy Lee's trusty keyboard work, it sounded as though Rush were really going off the deep end with their pop-rock phase this time around. And... well... yeah. In a way, they kinda did.

Don't get me wrong; there are indeed progressive moments scattered about Hold Your Fire. In fact, the album's big hit single "Time Stand Still" is ironically one of the most typical and classic-sounding Rush songs on this entire thing because of its frequently altered tempos and more experimental character (with the female vocals, heavy atmosphere, the works). Unfortunately, this is also one of the first times in Rush's career in which some of their choices end up really biting them in the collective ass. There's only so much someone can take of a more watered-down Rush, and songs like the bland power-ballad "Second Nature" and the overly cheery instrumentation of "Mission" are begging for a songwriting overhaul. The emotional weight is here in top form, but - and I do hate to say this - the music has a tendency to be just plain boring. It's not that Rush have to be technical to be good, and the band's instrumental prowess shines in tunes like "Prime Mover" and the mystical "Tai Shan," but the synthesizers are really what kill a good chunk of this record. Why? Because they're so damn overbearing. As with Signals and a decent chunk of Power Windows, it feels as though Alex Lifeson has been once again shoved off to the sidelines as Lee's large array of keyboard effects comes in to take command of the record.

There are, however, some nifty things here and there that provide a good contrast to this, my personal favorite being the highly guitar-driven rocker "Turn the Page"; while there is still a high amount of synthesizer work when the song occasionally slows down, Alex's presence is strong and provides a uniquely stark atmosphere to the track. As for Neil Peart, he's certainly very commendable on this album because of his ability to transform simplicity into an immersive experience. He could easily have just followed what the other instruments are doing, but instead offers his own unique takes on these poppy tracks. The fills on "Time Stand Still" and "Turn the Page" are among his finest, and his highly involved performance in closer "High Water" positively contrasts the song's slow tempo and simple instrumental work.

Still, it's quite upsetting to hear a band's sound become diluted to the point of genuine boredom, and Rush were quite close to hitting such a mark. Hold Your Fire isn't a bad album, but it's one of the band worst records regardless; the emotional content and atmosphere are strong, but not as powerful when coupled with the overdone synth arrangements and weaker songwriting. This just barely escapes its 2.5/5, but what a dangerously close call. However, to the Rush fans out there: you should get this if you're a completionist or into 80s Rush. Otherwise, I'd say this one's more for pop rock fans than the ones who adore the band's more progressive 70s material.



Recent reviews by this author
Rush PrestoAgainst Me! Transgender Dysphoria Blues
Taylor Swift 1989Joni Mitchell Blue
Porcupine Tree Fear of a Blank PlanetMichael Jackson Off the Wall
user ratings (518)
Chart.
3.4
great
other reviews of this album
Chuck H. (4)
Like Alan Alda in the later seasons of M*A*S*H, Geddy Lee takes on three important jobs for which he...

sonictheplumber STAFF (3.5)
...

Chris K (5)
...


Comments:Add a Comment 
Necrotica
June 19th 2014


10147 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Meh, I'm not sure how I feel about my review this time around. But I had a really hard time thinking of what to say about it :/

ExplosiveOranges
June 19th 2014


3913 Comments


Keep going, Necro! You only have 7 albums left!

Digging: Millicent Waffles - Under Dark Blue Blanket

Necrotica
June 19th 2014


10147 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

I know, dude! And yet this is the beginning of the toughest stretch of albums in their discog to review :[

ExplosiveOranges
June 19th 2014


3913 Comments


Eh, you'll be fine. Review is solid, but Jesus Christ, dat second paragraph.

Gyromania
June 19th 2014


16117 Comments


shame this didn't get the 4 it deserves

BMDrummer
June 19th 2014


10098 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Not a bad review, but I might recommend splitting up the middle paragraph into two. As for the album, it's probably my least favorite from Rush for all the reasons you stated.

Necrotica
June 19th 2014


10147 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Just split up the paragraph :3

ExplosiveOranges
June 19th 2014


3913 Comments


Much easier on the eyes now

BMDrummer
June 19th 2014


10098 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

: )

Necrotica
June 19th 2014


10147 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

This was one of the toughest reviews for me to write, because I love the regular Rush traits on this but the album left such a small impression so many times that I didn't really know how to go about it

ExplosiveOranges
June 19th 2014


3913 Comments


I guess it's one of those albums in a band's discog that isn't really bad, but isn't too memorable either.

fallenbird
June 19th 2014


4126 Comments


That was fast. The last Rush review is still on the homepage.

TheCrocodile
June 19th 2014


346 Comments


This might be tied with Test for Echo as my least favorite Rush album.

fallenbird
June 19th 2014


4126 Comments


Can't wait for the Clockwork Angels review

Necrotica
June 19th 2014


10147 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

That's the review I'm really excited about doing :]

fallenbird
June 19th 2014


4126 Comments


I'm actually listening to that album right now and I can't help gawking at The Garden

Necrotica
June 19th 2014


10147 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

I gave the album a 4.5, the only album of theirs I've given that rating to since Grace Under Pressure :3

BMDrummer
June 19th 2014


10098 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

I once flagged KILL's review, it didn't work : (

Necrotica
June 19th 2014


10147 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

I wish either his review or the Tokeman 5000 review was flagged, they're both wonderful :D

ultimatethrasher
June 19th 2014


163 Comments


good review Brendan not sure if I want to check this out I'm not a fan of pop rock or pop music in general, but I do like Time Stand Still



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy