She and Him
Volume Three


2.4
average

Review

by Rudy K. STAFF
May 8th, 2013 | 67 replies | 8,460 views


Release Date: 05/07/2013 | Tracklist

Review Summary: You know, if we fix up this car, it could be make-out city, you know that.

It’s hard to tell whether She & Him have moved past the point of novelty or remain tarnished by it. On the one hand, the group’s collection of records has had nary a “bad” song on it. Forgettable, at times? Yes. Uninspiring, at others? Almost certainly, but throughout Volume One and Volume Two and now Volume Three the pair have maintained a reliable pop professionalism that has occasionally created sparks of black-and-white brilliance, an unerring portrait of a time when “I could’ve been your girl / you could’ve been my four-leaf clover,” was all that was needed for one starry-eyed girl to tell the heartbreaker in his varsity jacket. Few artists have recreated (and, arguably, mastered) a specific sound as lovingly as She & Him. The playful pop instincts of the Beach Boys rub shoulders with the wistfulness of ‘60s girl groups; doo-wop meshes imperceptibly with Brill Building melodies and hints of Nancy Sinatra sass; sweeping Phil Spector symphonics unfurl like a velvety blanket next to carefree fingerpicking and aw-shucks guitar pop. At their best, She & Him transport you to somewhere else, where Zooey Deschanel isn’t a star and M. Ward is just the man behind the curtain, another in a long line of faceless studio hired hands. It’s a place where the magic is in the simplicity of the songs and the everyday romance they conjure, effortlessly and innocently. But, shit – a Christmas album? And now Volume Three, a record so tightly and painstakingly circumscribed by its period sounds and M. Ward’s polite production that it loses any mild sense of personality She & Him have managed to acquire in the past few years, just at a time when Deschanel should be staking her own artistic identity loudly and firmly.

Here, M. Ward indeed becomes that man behind the curtain, his signature blues touch only a faint whisper among the carefully manicured jazz inflections and retro indie pop tailor-made for a summer Sunday – preferably spent down at the local soda fountain. When things are spiced up, as on the faux-disco of “Together” or on the rumbling cover of Blondie’s “Sunday Girl,” it barely registers a notch above the rest of Volume Three’s flawlessly produced, entirely inoffensive sounds, lest Ward disturb the neighbors. Previous records reveled in these same sounds, true, yet they did it with some vigor, a certain punchiness and spice that kept them bouncing around in your head far longer than they rightfully should have. Volume Three prefers to keep the focus on Deschanel, and while the melodies remain, they too often seem like just another part of the tapestry, not the selling point. Yet where Volume Three might have been picked up accordingly by a more prominent performance by Deschanel, the singer remains just as suppressed by the strict adherence to this genre exercise as Ward. Deschanel has never had trouble sounding wounded, but her voice here rarely jumps out at you – she prefers to just play the role rather than live it. Even when she’s obviously having fun, as she does on the whimsical “Sunday Girl” or the quintessential torch song (“Hold Me, Thrill Me, Kiss Me”), it inevitably feels rote, a meticulous tastefulness that is pretty and nostalgic, yet largely uninteresting.

It’s unclear whether this is a result of Ward’s unusually subdued production or Deschanel’s own limitations as a songwriter, but this is where She & Him’s self-imposed restraints tend to sabotage their artistic growth. Deschanel writes fine pop songs, but at this point, the tired ‘50s tropes and Grease-styled romantic calamities unfairly handicap her palette and diminish her talents. As a result, Volume Three can’t flourish under the force of her considerable personality or Ward’s craftsmanship, because the latter has been deadened and the former is unwilling to break the illusion. Until one or the other makes a change, it seems doubtful that She & Him will ever become more than a particularly well-credentialed homage.



Recent reviews by this author
First Aid Kit Stay GoldLily Allen Sheezus
Woods With Light And With LoveEels The Cautionary Tales of Mark Oliver Everett
Tokyo Police Club ForcefieldThe War on Drugs Lost in the Dream
user ratings (40)
Chart.
3
good

Comments:Add a Comment 
klap
Staff Reviewer
May 8th 2013



10258 Comments

Album Rating: 2.4

"Never Wanted Your Love" - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MdJbqGeYM6E

Digging: The Bilinda Butchers - Heaven

Trebor.
Contributing Reviewer
May 8th 2013



49791 Comments


shit agreed

Digging: Empire! Empire! (I Was a Lonely Estate) - You Will Eventually Be Forgotten

SgtPepper
Staff Reviewer
May 8th 2013



4381 Comments


Maybe it's because I have soft spot for Zooey and baroque pop, but I kind of liked that song you linked. This is one of those groups I've been meaning to check out, but never have. Might look into them this week.

Great review, Rudy.

klap
Staff Reviewer
May 8th 2013



10258 Comments

Album Rating: 2.4

good songs but the album as a whole pales in comparison to their other two albums

tommygun
May 8th 2013



23597 Comments


MY SISTER GAVE ME ALL HER RECORDS AND NOW SHE'S A STEWARDESS?

Digging: Obliteration - Black Death Horizon

klap
Staff Reviewer
May 8th 2013



10258 Comments

Album Rating: 2.4

i dk i really blame the production on this more than i do her. can't comment on her acting as i haven't seen her in anything lately

Trebor.
Contributing Reviewer
May 8th 2013



49791 Comments


Our Idiot Brother was coo

PunchforPunch
May 8th 2013



5896 Comments


First it was butter then it was sugar and white flour, bacon, eggs, balogna, rock 'n roll, motorcycles.

Jash
May 8th 2013



4244 Comments


Great review Rudy, we feel the same about these two. I don't think they'll ever do anything really memorable but I don't think they could ever do anything really bad either

tommygun
May 8th 2013



23597 Comments


andcas dude she's cool in almost famous

klap
Staff Reviewer
May 8th 2013



10258 Comments

Album Rating: 2.4

yeah Volume One was one of my favorites from that year. this one is just so....staid

SgtPepper
Staff Reviewer
May 8th 2013



4381 Comments


THIS IS A HOUSE OF LIES!

PunchforPunch
May 8th 2013



5896 Comments


FECK YOU!

SgtPepper
Staff Reviewer
May 8th 2013



4381 Comments


@andcas
500 days of summer? That was a good one.

tommygun
May 8th 2013



23597 Comments


dude she turned william onto rock n roll and changed his life

Omaha
Staff Reviewer
May 8th 2013



10009 Comments


500 Days of Summer < 3

If you get uncomfortable while watching it with your girlfriend, realize that the two of you may not have a great future ahead of you.

Digging: Deniro Farrar - Rebirth

Omaha
Staff Reviewer
May 8th 2013



10009 Comments


Yeppp.

It really finds a way to underscore the shitty moments in one's relationship, haha.

tommygun
May 8th 2013



23597 Comments


just broke up with mine gonna watch it solo m/

Aids
Contributing Reviewer
May 8th 2013



23798 Comments


if klap is giving this a 2.4 then I have very little hope that I'll like it at all

PunchforPunch
May 8th 2013



5896 Comments


I am a golden god!



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2013 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy