Circle Takes The Square
Decompositions: Volume Number One


3.5
great

Review

by Martin L. USER (44 Reviews)
December 22nd, 2012 | 257 replies | 19,429 views


Release Date: 2012 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Like clockwork witchcraft / One must suffer to pass / Suffer to Pass

18 of 20 thought this review was well written

The one aspect about Circle Takes The Square that continues to astound me release-after-release is their ability to advance so little between albums and EPs and manage to make the most of it. The screamo monarchs have little to hide, as the formula is pretty established by this point. We’ve witnessed their ability to create a sense of drama and story between well-crafted songwriting and ostentatious lyrics, we’ve heard the “pillaging through rubble” and “ooo-hah-ah” chanting effects, and we’ve seen them stretch thin soft-loud dynamics. Still, Circle Takes The Square employs all of this into a surprisingly cohesive and captivating release that revels in its own supposed faults. Decompositions:Volume Number One is very much a continuation of the band’s ethic, and how much return one receives from it is simply a matter of perspective.

With less than a day’s forewarning, Circle Takes The Square have released their latest Decompositions piece, the first volume which is a continuation of the Rites of Initiation EP released last year. The aforementioned EP makes up the first four tracks of the album, and they remain the base, the roots of the album, as the rest branches off from there in the same tenor. Some might mistake the more economic use of space in Decompositions as “heaviness” or a more “metal” edge, as Rites of Initiation was described. Rather, the album simply feels more compressed, and the airiness of Roots Undo is gone. The closer is an anomaly -- but instead of intermissions from screams or crashing guitars, the quieter interludes of Decompositions, of which there are less, have a sense of existing only to accentuate the more chaotic moments. Winding songwriting that erupts into languished screams with about as much warning as we were given for the release of this album gives the album an aura of super über-complexity, but is that really the case? Maybe it’s simply the fact that I’ve heard As The Roots Undo’s twists and turns so many times that they’ve become conventional, but Circle Takes The Square employ a rather simple device to their songs. The soft-loud technique where there’s a sing-songy-talkiness that strolls through meandering guitar lines (see: first half “Enter By The Narrow Gates”) is just another platitude by this point, but that doesn’t mean that it’s not effective. Circle Takes The Square have always covered such ground with such a shallow tool because of their ability to stretch it and mold it into this self-aware, overwrought monster of a track. Decompositions takes these predicatable norms and, with Drew Speziale’s songwriting creativity combined with the convenient lag-time in-between releases, makes the album feel fresh and exuberant. It all depends on perspective. For those eagerly anticipating the followup to As The Roots Undo, expect more of the same.

Another main strength of a Circle Takes release, and Decompositions is no exception, are the keystones of catharsis riddled throughout. The obvious, preferential moments are the first and last tracks (the latter ditches the piercing screams for a mewithoutYou-esque, story-telling venture among dancing guitar lines that basically epitomizes everything so atrocious/awesome about CTTS) with the middle mostly filling out the highlights, giving it a body and insides. It’s important to note that Volume One epitomizes the band’s ability to create gargantuan albums in terms of both scope and run-time and not have them seem too big for their own good -- it isn’t overlong, and there’s plenty more to uncover in the bulk of the middle tracks. “Singing Vengeance Into Being” has a particularly strong bite, and “Prefaced By The Signal Fires” has an interesting anthemic quality to it that isn’t nearly as present in past tracks. Still, like I keep harkening back to, this is still the same band employing the same techniques, and they still end up with a product better-than-average, especially in this age of lessened screamo competition. There’s nothing coercive about Decompositions. It will presumably to little to convert many to their camp; but again, perspective is paramount. Always been uninspired with the band’s flair for the overdramatic? At least give Circle Takes The Square credit for their candor and ability to mold something that should, by all means, be atrocious into something that’s utterly captivating for so many. Those that were astounded by As The Roots Undo, prepare to be presently surprised as to how fresh and exuberant Circle Takes The Square makes it all seem on Decompositions. I can see the merit of both camps, but I’ll be damned if I wouldn’t rather be in the latter, reveling in everything so overwrought and meticulously-crafted by CTTS on their latest-released behemoth.... poetry-spouting, shrill-shrieking, behemoth.



Recent reviews by this author
Aidan Baker Already DrowningPity Sex Feast of Love
NoMeansNo WrongHuata/Bitcho Split
The Men New MoonGiles Corey Hinterkaifeck
user ratings (326)
Chart.
3.8
excellent
other reviews of this album
speedkills1995 (4)
Circle Takes the Square pound out a new album filled to the rims with fury and complete evisceration...

Eli EMERITUS (3.5)
Devoured, digested, cast out...Decompose....

Idioteque (5)
Masters of apocalyptic punk return after the end of the world with a vengeance...


Comments:Add a Comment 
carouse
December 22nd 2012



300 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

The album is up for download, for free, from the band for a limited time, here:
http://ctts.bandcamp.com/

johnnydeking29
December 22nd 2012



8961 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

Pos'd

Havey
December 22nd 2012



9608 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

You're a great writer, I've loved you ever since you reviewed Harvey Milk (possible my fav band omg)

Digging: Cecil Taylor - Dark to Themselves

taxidermist
December 22nd 2012



7195 Comments


Good review, but still a little TOO soon to review. I guess you had to get yours in before the flood of reviews.

Hyperion1001
Staff Reviewer
December 22nd 2012



17998 Comments


damn cant wait to not listen to this

Digging: Autechre - Draft 7.30

demigod!
December 22nd 2012



43785 Comments


finally a review that isnt mounds of hyperbole

Digging: Black Flag - My War

johnnydeking29
December 22nd 2012



8961 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

So, barely a review

carouse
December 22nd 2012



300 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

It's simply a three-paragraph summary of my impressions after five or seven listens or so. I had strong feelings about it when I had heard it, and that's when I write reviews for new releases -- it doesn't matter if those feelings occur 1 day after its release or 100 days after its release.

elephantREVOLUTION
December 22nd 2012



2727 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

good review. i'm hoping i will like this more than rites of initiation

demigod!
December 22nd 2012



43785 Comments


this isnt free you guys lied

costs at least 50C!

Cygnatti
December 22nd 2012



21349 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

best reviewer in da game

Digging: The Avalanches - Since I Left You

ShadowRemains
December 22nd 2012



20219 Comments


good fucking review

carouse
December 22nd 2012



300 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Thanks for reading, everyone.

figure337
December 22nd 2012



420 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

I think you put a little too much emphasis on how "little" the band has changed. I'm a handful of listens through this and it's already a whole different beast than the first album. Well written though.

DrMaximus
December 22nd 2012



8864 Comments


Demi, it says name your price.

ViralOblivion
December 22nd 2012



7679 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Yeah I just put 0.00 and then it gave me a download

botb
December 22nd 2012



9517 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

this isnt free you guys lied

costs at least 50C!


your reading comprehension is bad you deserve no free downloads

DrMaximus
December 22nd 2012



8864 Comments


Album is sweet.

Havey
December 22nd 2012



9608 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

the 2 negs are bs and i'll fight the neggers when i find em

demigod!
December 22nd 2012



43785 Comments


I didn't think that nothing was an acceptable price. Because it really isn't a price at all

and fuck bringonthebreakdown, and your greg puciato avatar



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2013 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy