Kenny G.
Breathless


2.0
poor

Review

by Daniel Incognito EMERITUS
February 10th, 2006 | 9 replies


Release Date: 1992 | Tracklist


It is hard to believe that a curly haired, talented young Soprano Sax player could have garnered as much criticism as Kenny G Much like his Adult Contemporary Pop brethren that he epitomizes, Kenny G has been given a very bad rap over his career. Although he may be a favourite of parents worldwide, Kenny G has turned into one of those artists that teenagers worldwide shudder at the thought of, describing him as 'That boring old crap my parents listen to.' Sadly due to the fact that Kenny G transcends the pop genre into Jazz, his music has also been harshly criticized by the Jazz world as well, usually for being uninspired and repetitive.

Kenny G has never professed to be the next John Coltrane, Sonny Rollins or Charlie Parker on the Saxophone. Although for some reason, many people judge Kenny G based on the standards set out before him by Soprano Sax virtuosos. When in reality this is a narrow-minded and slanted measure of comparison. Kenny G is a Contemporary Pop artist in every sense of the genre. Despite the number of people that loathe the music that Kenny G makes, he has become somewhat of a hit in America and other English language countries. Breathless has sold over eight million copies in America alone, a figure that helped it rocket up the charts to number two on the Billboard Top 200. It is easy to see how Kenny G. has appealed so greatly to adults worldwide. His Soprano Saxophone playing is not overly complicated, and what Kenny G does so convincingly is to transfuse his emotion into the song. Kenny G has been the first to admit that he is primarily a pop instrumentalist, which needs to be taken into account when listening to him.

Breathless starts out with The Joy of Life, a song which illustrates what Kenny G is all about, just like every other song on this album. It is a more upbeat song than others on Breathless and Kenny's smooth and steady Sax playing lends itself to the feeling of love. One of the primary ways Kenny G manages to capture his audience is by portraying the emotion of the song excellently. Even for casual listeners, like the parent demographic, the main theme of the song is boldly put on display for all to see and understand. The Joy of Life manages to recreate that feeling of 'newfound love' to perfection. In the Rain also demonstrates Kenny's ability to portray the various facets of love; with the notes gliding in and out with not a single harsh tone in it. One of the most upbeat songs on the album is G Bop, which features a funky pop beat with Kenny's sharper than normal Sax playing over the top. It provides a nice break from all the gushing with love songs that fill Breathless to the rim. G Bop is pretty much the only song that differs from Kenny G's tried and true formula. That said, G Bop still manages to revert back to Kenny's favourite theme of love, but this time with more of a enthusiastic funky feeling and beat. By the end of the song you'll be swearing you just heard The Joy of Life again but with a chirpier rhythm.

With only two songs on Breathless featuring vocals and the only real instrument being Kenny's Soprano Saxophone; repetition was always going to be evident. Sadly it seems little has been done to avoid this. Every song on Breathless follows the same recipe. An ounce of Saxophone, a smothering of cheesy Pop beat, a wallop of love and a pinch of passion. When listened to as a whole, the repetitiveness is not such a big deal. It gives Breathless a very unified theme, that is present throughout the album. However with almost every song blending into each other, none of the songs on this album manage to stick out in the listeners mind. Unlike most pop albums where there is a standout song that is purely designed to be a single, Breathless doesn't really have one. Kenny G could have released any of the songs as singles, and no doubt they would have all received the same reaction. Too much variety can make an album feel broken up and chaotic. Kenny G obviously wanted to avoid that at all costs, which has resulted in a somewhat bland album.

Like many other instrumental albums that feature a song or two with vocals, they usually fall up short. Even if my Heart Would Break features help from fellow Adult Contemporary artist Aaron Neville and his unique voice. Although the guest vocals do make for a slightly different song to the norm, the usual motif of love is present. The lyrics are pretty much what you would expect from a Kenny G song. 'I'm going to love you, even if my heart would break.' The lyrics in By the Time this Night is Over are similarly basic, with obvious references to love. 'And darling if it's right, by the time this night is over. The stars are going to shine on two lovers in love.' The vocals provided by Peabo Bryson in By the Time this Night is Over seem to suit the song more than Neville's contribution. Unfortunately neither of the vocal performances adds much to the depth or originality of Kenny G's songs. By no means are they bad tracks, they both feature simple but beautiful melodies. But once again, Kenny G. shows almost no creativity, resorting to that same formula over and over again.

There are some strong, purely instrumental tracks on Breathless. Songs like Forever in Love, End of the Night, Morning and Alone all have powerful melodies that can be quite moving in the right moment. If listened to in a random order, it would be very difficult to deduce which song was which. But when listened to at the right moment, this won't matter at all. What strikes me with Breathless is that it is meant for a certain type of person, in a certain situation. When listened to whilst sitting on a balcony, overlooking the sun set on a clear and crisp night, Breathless is quite magnificent. In a relaxed state like that, the emotion in the music matters a hundred times more than the technical skill involved. Alone starts off with a delicate Spanish guitar and keyboard intro that floats into Kenny's sensual and mellow Soprano Saxophone that seems to waft through the song. Another song that has a more sorrow filled take on love is Sister Rose. Kenny G really seems to excel at the more depressed songs on Breathless, which have a more down to earth feel to them than the at times cheesy 'newfound love' songs. Sister Rose features some of the most complex Saxophone melodies and patterns on the album, although that is over stating it a bit. Although Kenny G holds the world record for the longest note held on a Saxophone (an E-Flat for forty five minutes, forty seven seconds); he rarely shows off his technical prowess, almost always opting for a soulful and minimalist approach to the music.

At 6 minutes and 16 seconds, Sister Rose is the second longest song on the album. Kenny G rarely differs from the 4:30 to 5:30 length for each song, which once again shows how formulaic his approach can be. The album is quite a long one at almost 70 minutes long. However the repetitiveness of the album negates the length quite dramatically. Kenny G and the producers of Breathless went a little over board on the tracks included in the album, and a few of the tracks show a little too much of Kenny's single-minded approach to music making. Rather than adding depth, as was probably intended.

One could go on and on about each song in Breathless and describe each one in full detail, and then you would realise you had just written the same thing 14 times over. It cannot be understated how repetitive and at times boring Breathless can be. At the right time and place, Breathless is the perfect mood setter. The soulful, heartfelt and sincere melodies are perfect for a romantic candlelit evening. But of course that is where the album also falls terribly short. With such a focused intent on what purpose the album serves, it has resulted in an album that has alienated itself from almost every other demographic.

Breathless is a lot like clay court tennis. If you focus on clay court tennis, then you'll play pretty poorly on any other type of court. Breathless threw all its balls into one court, and has been rewarded with great success from its target audience. Sadly anybody else who has a different background will see it for what Kenny G failed to disguise. They will see it as a bland, highly incessant and recurrent album with tracks that feel like they're on auto-pilot. Some will question the passion behind the album, and call it manufactured emotions that have been processed into mush. This reviewer however believes that Kenny's emotions are truly present, with his themes of love and loss accentuated impressively.

I find it hard to recommend this album, when most people will hate it. It is a severely flawed album that offers nothing in terms of originality is far too high on repetition and lacks technical flair. With no real filler tracks to mention, you'd think this album would be a classic. Unfortunately that just reflects on how no song in this album does enough to distinguish itself above the rest, resulting in 70 minutes of the same formula in different keys. However, for the few lovebirds on this site that cannot fathom a life without love, this album will leave you like the album title suggests.. Breathless



Recent reviews by this author
Daft Punk Random Access MemoriesOmar S Just Ask the Lonely
Maceo Plex Life IndexPaul Kalkbrenner Icke Wieder
Gold Panda Lucky ShinerFlying Lotus L.A. EP 3 X 3
user ratings (29)
Chart.
1.8
poor
other reviews of this album
DrJohn (1)
Major Affective Disorder: Pleasant Type...


Comments:Add a Comment 
morrissey
Moderator
February 10th 2006


1688 Comments


Very very nice stuff Dan but I'm in the same boat as Sylvia, I certainly haven't heard this album and based on your review I don't intend to. But this review is nicely time for Valentine's Day.

Zebra
Moderator
February 10th 2006


2647 Comments


Excellent review, its up their with your 50 cent review. I can't make a comment on the music considering I have never heard a song from this album.

Liberi Fatali
Emeritus
February 10th 2006


1588 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

I like his Christmas music, but yeah, this album is basically on auto-pilot from start-to-finish. Nice work.

Yeah, it is weird. Unlike most normal artists, his holiday albums are some of his best.

RandyfromPennywise
June 20th 2006


752 Comments


Yeah it's a pretty repetitive album but it certainly has some sensational sax pieces in there, that - as you do say - can inspire and evoke emotion like few vocalists can. He's a very talented bloke, no question. But yeah, this album is repetitive and I'd never listen to it for more than 2 or 3 minutes I'd reckon. Decent review, even if I personally think it's a bit harsh.

(I bought this album 10 years ago when I was learning Sax: I found it a few months ago.)

Liberi Fatali
Emeritus
June 22nd 2006


1588 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

Decent review, even if I personally think it's a bit harsh.

You just said you wouldn't listen to it for more than 2 or 3 minutes, it can't be that great.

I personally love Kenny G's music when I'm in the mood, but from an objective standpoint, the album isn't that great.

RandyfromPennywise
June 23rd 2006


752 Comments


I only say it's a bit harsh because all-in-all I think it's a 2.5 or maybe a 3. That's only my opinion of your opinion on the album. The review (the writing and reasoning), however, is excellent.

jefflebowski
December 16th 2011


8253 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

way to molest an entire genre

Cygnatti
January 11th 2014


21353 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

shit

FiveLeavesLeft
June 5th 2014


9838 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

Shit [2]



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy