The Gaslight Anthem
Handwritten


1.5
very poor

Review

by porch USER (21 Reviews)
July 31st, 2012 | 116 replies | 5,767 views


Release Date: 07/24/2012 | Tracklist


25 of 42 thought this review was well written

With Handwritten, The Gaslight Anthem continue to combine completely unremarkable, middle of the road alt rock with a quaint heartland aesthetic that appears increasingly plastic with each record. Newly assisted by Pearl Jam producer Brendan O’Brien, the band again take the most superficial aspects of their influences and marry them to homogenous, unimaginative songwriting that clearly has designs on being perceived as gut wrenchingly sincere and anthemic but instead falls on the wrong side of bombast and cheesiness. While The Gaslight Anthem haven’t always sucked quite as much balls as some other practitioners of this particular strain of huff and puff bluecollar rock (see Titus Andronicus), Handwritten is a pretty poor effort. O’Brien’s presence presumably had its intended effect; the record sounds suitably glossy and radio friendly and will almost certainly help the band appeal to a wider audience, but the songs themselves don’t stack up. Four albums in, frontman Brian Fallon continues to fall back on lyrical crutches recalling the worst elements of Westerberg and Springsteen, now backed by clunky, mid-paced songs that are more Shinedown than Replacements. It should be bland at worst, but The Gaslight Anthem’s rigid adherence to such tired cliches and rote songwriting across entire records has now progressed to the point where their music is downright bad, and best avoided.



Recent reviews by this author
Fugazi In on the Kill TakerMeat Puppets Meat Puppets II
Big Star Radio CityFlipper Gone Fishin'
Black Flag In My HeadThe Clash London Calling
user ratings (463)
Chart.
3.8
excellent
other reviews of this album
1 of

Comments:Add a Comment 
auberginedreams
July 31st 2012



5757 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

"The Gaslight Anthem continue to combine completely unremarkable, middle of the road alt rock with a quaint heartland aesthetic"

oh man i actually agree with porch.

Digging: Deafheaven - Sunbather

WeepingBanana
July 31st 2012



9146 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5 | Sound Off

But Titus aren't really guilty of anything you mentioned in the sentences before

clercqie
July 31st 2012



5082 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

It's well-written and all that, but this piece sounds way too biased, if you ask me...

Digging: Sorrow (UK) - Dreamstone

alachlahol
July 31st 2012



6819 Comments


well i knew this wasnt going to be as good as the latest defeater but damn

Tyrael
July 31st 2012



18660 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

pos

still waiting for you to review Frank Turner man

KILL
July 31st 2012



52102 Comments


awesome

Digging: Buckingham Nicks - Buckingham Nicks

Captain North
July 31st 2012



6417 Comments


Yeah, never understood any of the hype for these guys.

Deviant.
Staff Reviewer
July 31st 2012



28822 Comments


Still love the band, but this is still a great and really kinda truthful review

Digging: Calibre - Spill

MichaelSnoxall
July 31st 2012



12135 Comments


I heard a lot of hype around The '59 Sound, checked it out and thought pretty much aaaaalllllllll this. Though I listened to a few songs from Handwritten, it sounded better than '59.

Digging: Immolation - Kingdom of Conspiracy

DarthMann
July 31st 2012



13123 Comments


take over for adam thomas

auberginedreams
July 31st 2012



5757 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

i've really never understood the hype for this band. i tried when their last album came out, just couldn't get into it. i figured i'd give them another chance so i listened to one song off of this a few days ago and it was so boring i didn't even get through the whole song.

MichaelSnoxall
July 31st 2012



12135 Comments


They're okay. Nothing special.

Blackbelt54
July 31st 2012



3972 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0 | Sound Off

I like this album a whole lot more than you do, but you've made some good points. I agree, they do sound more plastic with each album. I really do love the 59 Sound, partly because of when I first listened to it, it was different than my normal stuff I spun. Sadly, this and American Slang don't even touch the 59 sound with a whatever-foot pole. And I agree with the banana, Titus is not guilty of this stuff.

Digging: Night Birds - Maimed For The Masses

ThroneOfAgony
July 31st 2012



3453 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Pretty good review, but you didn't really explain much to how this is a 1.5

I'm not fond of the band though

omnipanzer
July 31st 2012



20588 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

It's great rock and roll and at this point I would assume anyone picking this up is wanting to hear this bands particular sound. They are typical american blue collar rock done particularly well imho. Any familiarity to any other musician just means they have influences... kind of like 99.9% of every other musician to ever put pencil to pad and I think that can be forgiven.

Nice blurb, well phrased - POS.

Digging: Bonobo - The North Borders

Aids
Contributing Reviewer
July 31st 2012



21894 Comments


good review, pos

i never really understood the love for this band. i wont bother with this album.

omnipanzer
July 31st 2012



20588 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Titus Andronicus DOES blow.

WeepingBanana
July 31st 2012



9146 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5 | Sound Off

lol i'm still failing to see the titus comparison

Aids
Contributing Reviewer
July 31st 2012



21894 Comments


lol suddenly everyones like oh yea agred nevwr really liked this baaand


what? that this band has always seemed to draw polarizing opinions. riff riff riff, you silly motherfucker you.

porch
July 31st 2012



7782 Comments


cheers fellas

this: "clearly has designs on being perceived as gut wrenchingly sincere and anthemic but instead falls on the wrong side of bombast" is the part i was referring to with titus andronicus, and it's all over the monitor. basically some guy spilling his guts on top of over-anthemic, turgid music that doesn't stand up under the weight of its aspirations




You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2013 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy

IndieClick Music Network