Alcest
Ecailles De Lune


2.5
average

Review

by Steven28 USER (6 Reviews)
April 5th, 2012 | 30 replies | 1,339 views


Release Date: 2010 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Another case of disillusioned hype...

1 of 10 thought this review was well written

I bought this record after seeing it being hyped on various forums and by various reviewers as a 'beautiful black metal shoegazing' album (admittedly i was rather put off by the shoegazing aspect, but nonetheless...). However when i actually listened to it, i found it to be a major disappointment; yes, the harmonies were pleasant, but it's tedious and repetitive compositional ideas made my excitement with the album rather ephemeral.

The two-part title track is really the centre piece of the album, and incorporates much of what is to be expected in the rest of the album. The guitar repeated play fast tremolo strummed chords, and sparse broken chords interchangeably; this proves to be the only variety in the album worth noting, besides maybe the occasional switch to shriek-style vocals. The vocals are pleasant enough, however i wish they were more like his vocals in Lantlos; in this album they simply fit comfortably in the mix, without showing any dynamics or character. The last aspect of the track, and this is true of most of the album too, is the drums; they are simply bland.

The second track was rather forgettable, and is by far the weakest track on the album. The guitars are relentlessly tedious as per usual for this album, but i quite liked the melody line towards the end i must say.
Then after this follows a one and a half minute 'filler' track. Right... Next...

Now we come onto 'Solar Song', the only track i really like on the album. The melody is original, the vocals sound beautiful and the repetitive tremolo strummed guitars actually suit this piece; it builds gradually, and overall has a rather majestic feel. This track may be the only reason i kept this album in my collection.

The not-so-grand finale of the album is yet again a rather dull song. It is possibly the most gentle track on the album; it has a repetitive chord sequence played with quaver notes on the guitar, however the vocals hear do standout somewhat. The track never really goes anywhere and proves to be a sedate and boring conclusion to a sedate and boring album.

Emotion with deliverance; Melody without beauty. This album may be somewhat original within the black metal scene, but that doesn't make it good. However due to this slight difference that makes them stand out somewhat they have rapidly become overrated, and this album follows in the footsteps of that superficial hype.



Recent reviews by this author
Blut Aus Nord 777 - CosmosophyThe Enid Something Wicked This Way Comes
Blut Aus Nord 777 - The DesanctificationCynic Carbon-Based Anatomy
King Crimson The Power to Believe
user ratings (750)
Chart.
4
excellent
other reviews of this album
Apollo (5)
Neige is a creative genius and propels his one man projects latest effort to stunning brilliance....

BathoryHordes (4)
Neige takes the listener on a musical journey of elegance and beauty....

Zettel (4.5)
"Écailles de Lune" est l'album qu’était esquissé dans des ouvrages antérieurs....

Mike Stagno STAFF (4)
Écailles de Lune sees Alcest improve in all the right ways....


Comments:Add a Comment 
kount
April 5th 2012



1225 Comments

Album Rating: 1.0

you bought it

MetallicOpeth
April 5th 2012



14632 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

lol

DarkNoctus
Contributing Reviewer
April 5th 2012



7922 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0 | Sound Off

well that's your fault for buying into hype, isn't it? :]

Digging: Summoning - Old Mornings Dawn

Tyrael
April 5th 2012



18657 Comments


dammit noctus

Wreath
April 5th 2012



85 Comments


Ècailles De Lune according to you: "tedious, repetitive, sedate, boring"

*checks profile*

Sun O))): Monoliths and Dimensions - 4.5/5.

Orly.

Steven28
April 5th 2012



52 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5 | Sound Off

Dunn o))) are atmospheric, varied; monoliths and dimensions also has some jazz influences and experimentations with exotic scales. In no way is it tedious or boring, the final track 'Alice', for example, is a majestically powerful track.

Wreath
April 5th 2012



85 Comments


And I suppose the same thing goes with the oh so diverse Meshuggah?

Even though I like that band.

Tyrannic
April 5th 2012



1952 Comments


reading this review was tedious, boring, and overall against my general well-being.


D:

feanaro
April 5th 2012



715 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Solar Song is the worst song on the album. Review is pretty awkward and incoherent as well.

Ire
April 5th 2012



39275 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

zzzzzZZZZZZZzzzzzzzz...

Digging: Of Montreal - Daughter of Cloud

Steven28
April 5th 2012



52 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5 | Sound Off

I'm sorry the review has gathered so much disdain; would anyone do me the favour of constructively explaining their dislike (it is my first review after all, help is readily welcome).

DarkNoctus
Contributing Reviewer
April 5th 2012



7922 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0 | Sound Off

sure thing, steven! :]

for one it reads very conversation-like. for second, it is essentially a track-by-track review which are widely seen as uninteresting to read. also, there's a lot of first person, you should probably avoid that, it makes it seem too much like a blog post. [:

it also sounds like you're using words like 'tedious' without really knowing what the word entails. what is tedious about the guitarwork on track 2, for example? also, there isn't really a 'chord sequence' in the last track at all. you don't really describe the music either, i don't really know what it sounds like by your descriptions. i don't really understand why you dislike the album, despite having read your whole review. more description next time.

also, capitalize 'I'. also, don't start a review essentially saying you went in with unrealistically high expectations. :]

Tyrael
April 5th 2012



18657 Comments


it sparkles!

Tyrael
April 5th 2012



18657 Comments


agreed

Steven28
April 5th 2012



52 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5 | Sound Off

Thanks DarkNoctus, 'twas very helpful

Steven28
April 5th 2012



52 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5 | Sound Off

It's simply a matter of opinion, I never doubted his intension...

Tyrael
April 5th 2012



18657 Comments


'Neige is a creative genius

Neige takes the listener on a musical journey of elegance and beauty'

you should write a review for this! :]

feanaro
April 5th 2012



715 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

dude neige sounds like an angel as always how could you doubt that

DarkNoctus
Contributing Reviewer
April 5th 2012



7922 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0 | Sound Off

i want to cuddle him until the end of the world :]

i want him to sing softly in my ear telling me everything will be fine

in french [:

Tyrael
April 5th 2012



18657 Comments


Oh hey noctus, Wolf asked a question earlier today and you should be able to answer it I think

it was: Sometimes I'd really wonder what happens if our fanboy "likes sparkly things" Tyr and sparkly rainbow sailor Noctus teamed up for a rainbow ride like in Romantically Apocalyptic.

well it's not really a question but you get the picture



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2013 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy

IndieClick Music Network