Papa Roach
Metamorphosis


3.5
great

Review

by William Forest Collins USER (13 Reviews)
January 20th, 2012 | 15 replies


Release Date: 2009 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Either it was the fact that this was the album that really got me into music to begin with, or I was the most lenient motherfucker on the planet...

Well, after glimpsing over the history of Papa Roach, I have discovered that their music is hit or miss style. You either like it or you don't. There's no acquired taste for the music due to its occasional lack of creativity. Although this lack of astonishment, even for the now critically acclaimed mainstream rock stars was the ultimate downfall of their latter performances, I have to say, they still persist. It's just taking longer for these kinds of things to take off.

Papa Roach have always had a promising future, and whether or not any of their content was acceptable for listening even after harsh critiques, they still remain one of my personal favorites in the mainstream world not hindered by fame. If you absolutely had to consider this album a metamorphosis, I would say the only thing changing is the band's reluctance to get jumping as soon as possible. Other than their ever so slight musical regression after the power ballad "Scars", or the very harmonious "Paramour Sessions", they still show a very reasonable future.

This album contains the average hit or miss theory for the band, but I must say some of the best parts of this album are the areas few people ever get to. When the album starts with the interlude "Days of War", it is vague what exactly the band is trying to do at this point. So many low-end songs that pick up later have released many of the band's albums to either soft harmonious ballads, or supreme heavy songs. In this case, it is harsh guitars with Jacoby screaming with an echo to add a small touch of dominance for the first track "Change or Die". This track is actually one of the best songs to ever set the tone for an album by the band, and really gives you a taste for what this album has to offer. If you don't like this track, there is little left for you to get excited about to be perfectly honest.

Now let’s face it. Every band goes through this at one point or another. Papa Roach have started down the road to hell for all musicians with their lack of creative lyrics. This is the ultimate downfall of this album; otherwise, this album would be far more appreciated for its music, but not so much for what it supposedly promised. If the lacking of cohesive lyrics is the true metamorphosis for the band, this album should not be named after it now should it. Songs like "I Almost Told You That I Love You" or "Carry Me" show the weakest parts of the album in terms of lyrics. But "IATYTILY" is a very catchy hard rock song in terms of music.

Other tracks contain some less mediocre content on both realms of music, lyrics and instrumentation, and compliment this album to give it the best possible sound it could afford. "Lifeline" is undoubtedly one of the best. If you've ever heard of Papa Roach you've probably heard this song at one point or another, if not "Lifeline", certainly "Scars". But this song has some pretty simple but fast paced guitar lines and the vocals in the chorus are some of the best. But honestly, one of the best songs on the album would have to "State Of Emergency". This song has excellent instrumentation, with the slightest touch of applicable distortions in the guitar, the bass stands out, and the mediocrity of this album you saw before (considering this is the last track) just flies out the window. Catchy, meaningful and held high with a bright shining light of potential, this song will easily carry out the album from heavy hardcore rock, to peaceful silence.

As for the band, well, after this album I can’t really say nails are being prepared for their coffin. But I can say that the band is quite noticeably on the verge of accessing a more rough musical style based on what was supposed to be the high point of the bands career. No sir indeed. Infest and Lovehatetragedy is what we need more of. I give my support and dedicate myself to the promising integrity this album is certainly capable of expressing. Due to however the occasional lacking of superior influences, gathered from nothing the band has ever done before, this album fails to do one important thing. Show the audience the promising change for Papa Roach as they once again explore new territory. Overall, a decent listen, but nowhere near as prominent as the band or the fans surely foresaw.



Recent reviews by this author
Skillet AwakeKorn Follow the Leader
Korn Life Is PeachyKorn Korn
System of a Down Steal This Album!The Ergs! Dorkrockcorkrod
user ratings (410)
Chart.
2.4
average
other reviews of this album
DurgTv (2)
Papa Roach’s sound has not changed one bit, if anything they have the exact same sound but the son...

Davey Boy STAFF (2)
Is a regression in quality considered a ‘metamorphosis’?...


Comments:Add a Comment 
Horsehammer
January 20th 2012


550 Comments


ok, here we go...

Xenophanes
Emeritus
January 20th 2012


10666 Comments


First person perspective is generally frowned upon, and in this case is does detract a bit from the review. However, this was very well written nonetheless, and you did describe the album well. Waaaaaay better than my 12th ; )
Good job!


You got balls man.

Digging: Blut Aus Nord - Memoria Vetusta III - Saturnian Poetry

tiesthatbind
January 20th 2012


7380 Comments


Yeah solid review man

I like Lifeline, the rest is mostly meh but this album's not nearly as bad as it's made out to be imo

renegadestrings
January 20th 2012


1469 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

this album isn't bad... but it's just so damn dull. there are exciting parts to it, but when you actually listen, it sounds like the band is just coasting. Live This Down is one of the laziest songs ever written.

i'm not asking for Protest the Hero-style technicality, but a little variation wouldn't hurt especially considering these guys have been making music for more than a decade.

Horsehammer
January 20th 2012


550 Comments


aw snap, Live This Down was one of my first favorites

Metalstyles
Staff Reviewer
January 20th 2012


8393 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

This album's very inconsistent, but it ain't bad. State of Emergency and Into The Light are both really good rock tracks, and there are a few other moments where PR shine on this album, but there's just too much filler here when listened to in full-length.

EDIT: Btw I agree with you, Horsehammer, I like Live This Down too. It's simple, but in a hooky way imo.

Horsehammer
January 20th 2012


550 Comments


the guitar hook for the intro is honestly what grabs me, and the very beginning to the chorus

fish.
Contributing Reviewer
January 20th 2012


22059 Comments


Hollywood Whore rules

Digging: Andy Stott - Faith in Strangers

KjSwantko
January 20th 2012


9448 Comments


album cover rocks so hard

Metamorphosis
January 20th 2012


420 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

This album is not where I got my name from.

Xenophanes
Emeritus
January 20th 2012


10666 Comments


bullshit. I've made up my mind, it is where you got it.

Horsehammer
January 20th 2012


550 Comments


they call me.......Lovehatetragedy

ConsiderPhlebas
January 20th 2012


6157 Comments


You make some strange points. It's a bit of a cliche - and often completely imagined - but there are love-them-or-hate-them kinda bands, but saying you either like them or you don't... how could you like them and not like them at the same time?

blastOFFitsPARTYtime
January 20th 2012


1477 Comments

Album Rating: 1.0

A lenient motherfucker you are.

Good review, though. I liked some of their earlier stuff.

Horsehammer
January 20th 2012


550 Comments


thanks for the feedback



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy