Recoil
Selected (Limited Edition)


4.5
superb

Review

by DutchDevotee USER (7 Reviews)
December 22nd, 2011 | 2 replies | 1,568 views


Release Date: 2010 | Tracklist

Review Summary: A compilation of Recoil songs that somehow work together very well. Also included is a disc with new and old remixes that show what intelligent remixing (so no club remixes) can do to songs.

1 of 1 thought this review was well written

When listening too Recoil (a.k.a. Alan Wilder, former musical wizard of Depeche Mode) you need to have some patience. The Recoil songs tend to grow on you as you hear them more often. Alan disguises his soundscapes into songs and uses vocalists and spoken word artists for added lyrics.

This compilation consists of two discs. Disc 1 contains 14 regular tracks, whereas disc 2 contains 12 remixes of Recoil songs. Both collections were picked by Alan himself, so they contain his version of an overview of his solo career.

Somehow the track listing of disc 1 makes you forget that you’re listening to a compilation of older songs. The songs are not represented in chronological order but in a naturally flowing one. Starting off with Strange Hours with the grand voice and lyrical input from Diamanda Galás, this song sets the pace for the album. Next is one of the highlights, when Douglas McCarthy from Nitzer Ebb puts his take on Faith Healer. Although this song is originally released in 1992, it still sounds fantastic. The song builds up and still gives me shivers. The religious content of Faith Healer is somewhat continued in Prey. Prey contains the blues vocals of Joe Richardson. Although I hate blues most of the time, his voice is a great addition to this song. I really like the lyrical use of ‘pray’ and ‘prey’ in the line ‘You’d better pray for prey’.

Some other highlights are Luscious Apparatus, Edge to Life and Shunt. Luscious Apparatus is a spoken word song in which Maggie Estep talks about Carla, who meets a man that feels she was begging to be carved with a knife after having sex. The song is haunting, creepy and beautiful at the same time. In Edge to Life Toni Halliday croons like in her best days with Curve. Once again a song from 1992 that works very well in the order and context that Alan presents here. Shunt does contain lyrics (There’s blood on the line), but is very much an instrumental song. It is the song that comes closest to the first two Recoil EP’s (1+2 and Hydrology, of which there are no songs on this compilation) and shows the craftsmanship of Alan in creating instrumental songs that keep you listening throughout the whole song. Very, very good.

As already said, the order in which the songs are presented makes you think you’re listening to an album with new songs, even though you might already know the songs from earlier albums. This makes it an album worth buying. But the addition of the second disc with 12 remixes makes it even better. Consisting of (edits of) older remixes and new or previously commercially unavailable remixes, this disc shows the power of intelligent remixing. So you won’t find any club remixes on this disc, but instead the songs are recreated or twisted in a way which takes the songs to other areas than they were originally intended. And with great results. That is, if you are into it.



Recent reviews by this author
Sugababes Catfights and spotlightsTrijntje Oosterhuis Wrecks We Adore
Martin Gore Counterfeit (EP)Trijntje Oosterhuis We’ve Only Just Begun
Will Young EchoesDepeche Mode Remixes 2: 81-11
user ratings (2)
Chart.
4.5
superb

Comments:Add a Comment 
Kaleid
December 22nd 2011



709 Comments


Nice, I agree that the songs work very well together, which is unusual for a kind of greatest hits. I think anyone could get by with just Unsound Methods and Liquid, though.

Are the mixes that good? Apart from the Jezebel one, I don't really think I'd be that interested in them unless they were exceptional.

DutchDevotee
December 23rd 2011



37 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5 | Sound Off

@ Kaleid: I really like most of the mixes. I don't know if you own any Recoil mixes already. If so, then perhaps the limited edition is a bit too much for you. Give them a spin and judge for yourself, as I seem to be too much of a remix fan to give solid and (kinda) objective advice.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2013 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy