The Rifles
Freedom Run


2.5
average

Review

by Centre USER (2 Reviews)
December 1st, 2011 | 5 replies


Release Date: 2011 | Tracklist

Review Summary: The Rifles have changed, and it's not for the best

Okay, I feel the need to throw a disclaimer out here: I like change in music. Change can be good. Who would want to listen to a band put out the same album year after year? We all value creativity and progression in a band’s career, and it’s something we come to expect from our favorite bands. With that being said, it's obviously important that a band makes the right changes. Bloc Party, Kaiser Chiefs, and Arctic Monkeys are a few examples of English bands that have made the wrong changes over the course of their careers, abandoning what gave them character for a generic sound.

Well, you can go ahead and add The Rifles to that list.

I really hate having to say that, too. The Rifles. Standard-bearers for mod-revival. Hell, they can count Paul Weller, the Modfather himself, as a big fan. That's all in the past though. The Rifles, having lost the rhythm section (Rob Pyne and Grant Marsh) from their first two albums, have a much different sound on Freedom Run, and it's just not good.

The thing I loved about No Love Lost and The Great Escape is how punchy The Rifles sounded. Sure, they were playing simple music, but it was simple music done well. Joel Stoker's lyrics were catchy and smart, and the guitar work was always sharp and aggressive. Even when The Rifles tried to get serious, they still excelled. "Out in the Past" off The Great Escape still ranks as one of my favorite songs.

With Freedom Run, The Rifles, like many bands before them, try to add some pop to their sound. Don't get me wrong, I knew this album was going to be different. A band can't lose half of its members and maintain the same vibe. The Rifles were bound to change, but I was hoping they'd do a better job of it.
The beginning of Freedom Run is alright enough. "Long Walk Back" and "Tangled Up in Love" are catchy, but it's just not The Rifles. It sounds more like I'm listening to an orchestra with the occasional input from the band itself. This album is just too sweet. Everything about it is bright and happy, and by the end of the album, I was getting worn out from the pure poppiness.

Stoker's lyricism is still pretty good, but the sappiness just gets to be too much. Stoker always impressed me in the past with his talent for writing lyrics that just felt London. He had a knack for capturing the mundane aspects of every-day life in the big city and making them meaningful. He's written songs about love and happiness before, but his old work had that urban feeling to it that made it easy to relate to. On Freedom Run, Stoker definitely tries to move away from commonality and focuses on the important things in life. It's not bad, it’s just that I’ve heard all of this before. The beginning of the album is pretty strong, and the end is decent, with "Cry Baby" sticking out in particular. They do pop well, and the lyrics are endearing before it gets to be too much.

But my gripe isn't about the lyrics or the general feel of the album, even though it was feeling over-the-top by the end. The Rifles tried to go for the grandiose pop sound that has worked for some, and by all means, they do it pretty well. It's just that this album is simply not The Rifles. The reason they always stuck out to me is that they took what their mod forefathers gave them, put a modern twist on it, and did it well. With Freedom Run, they've moved away from what once made them unique, and to me, this album sounds like something any other band could have put out. I wouldn't say that The Rifles "sold out." Like I said, I expected them to change, and I like change. Problem is, they didn't change well.

Ignore the album cover: this isn't The Rifles anymore. If you want generic Britpop, then you'll be a big fan of this album. If you like witty mod-revival, come join me - I'll be in the back listening to their first two albums.


user ratings (4)
Chart.
3.3
great

Comments:Add a Comment 
AliW1993
Contributing Reviewer
December 1st 2011


7343 Comments


Pretty good review, especially given that it's only your second. My advice would be not to write in first person quite so much; it's fine to talk about yourself like you do in the intro but after that I find that it's better to just speak about the album rather than what YOU hear.

I've not heard this in it's entirity so can't rate it but what I have heard I've enjoyed a lot more than their first two albums. I wouldn't go so far as to say it was great but I'd rather listen to this than them ripping off the Jam, which is all that I can see in the other two.

Centre
December 1st 2011


3 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5 | Sound Off

I appreciate the criticisms. I definitely feel my first review was a lot better, but I'm still trying to get the hang of it. I'll work on it.

I understand where you're coming from with your Jam comment, but I felt like that was what made the Rifles stand out from all the other English indie bands. To each his own, right?

AliW1993
Contributing Reviewer
December 1st 2011


7343 Comments


Of course. It doesn't help that I'm not really the biggest Jam fan in the first place. I think I'll give this a proper listen in a bit.

Teefax
January 12th 2012


2 Comments


I think this review is spot on. The first album was brilliant exactly for the reasons mentioned here. The second album was very good too. "Freedom Run" just doesn't have the same feel to it. I saw them live on stage a few months ago. Setlist was a mix of old and mostly new stuff. You could feel the change in the reactions of the audience whenever they played one of the older titles, the new stuff is fairly boring by comparison. As the reviewer says, change is good, but not always its for the better (and I agree about the Monkeys, too).

Pheromone
May 29th 2014


3543 Comments


I need to check out more of The Rifles

Digging: Idlewild - The Remote Part



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy