Girls
Father, Son, Holy Ghost


4.5
superb

Review

by Nick Butler EMERITUS
November 29th, 2011 | 32 replies


Release Date: 2011 | Tracklist


The more cynical listeners out there might backhandedly describe Christopher Owens, the creative lynchpin behind Girls, as 'a great student of rock history' - in other words, somebody who knows the canon inside out and lifts from it liberally. And sure, there's no denying that a lot of the ideas here are probably older than Owens himself; that much is clear within the first minute of the album, as "Honey Bunny" bursts out of the traps sounding like a lost early Beach Boys classic with a few Carl Perkins-esque guitar licks thrown in for good measure.

Yet one of the most fascinating things about this album for me is that it very rarely sounds truly retro, or that much like its primarily influences. Instead, it's closer to a raft of other 'great students of rock history' that have appeared in the past two decades - Beulah, Elliott Smith, Oasis, Neutral Milk Hotel, Teenage Fanclub, The Magic Numbers, even Wolfmother on "Die". It's almost as if Girls have made a conscious decision to take those bands on at their own game, to prove that they're better at updating all the ideas from the '60s that indie rock has decided are worth holding onto. It's probably not true, but if it was, they would deserve all the credit in the world, because they've actually succeeded.

The quality of sound and songwriting on Father, Son, Holy Ghost is frequently breathtaking, and the most telling indicator of that is that, on first listen, even though your natural instinct is to play a game of spot the influence, it becomes impossible; you're too busy marvelling at how good it is. Even "Honey Bunny", probably the album's most blatant throwback, gets over the Beach Boys comparison through its breakneck energy, sheer enthusiasm, and pure melodicism, all of which are more in tune with acts like Dinosaur Jr than anything from the rock'n'roll era.

Elsewhere, the album can be described perfectly by two old adages - the first that stealing from one person is plagiarism while stealing from two or more is just good research, the second that a great song is a great song regardless of its origins. The first is a valid defense of the album but the second is the important one - these are seriously fucking great songs. Picking a favourite is nigh-on impossible - the absolutely beautiful "Jamie Marie", the dark and panoramic "Vomit", the wistful "Forgiveness", and the airy "My Ma" are all solid contenders, as is "Honey Bunny". Each song has a tune you can hum, a lyric somebody somewhere will probably get tattooed, and a musical twist to keep repeated listens as enthralling as the first, and what more can you really ask for from a pop or rock album? And that's before we even mention the production, which is little short of perfect - it's spacious, crystal clear, and warm, making this the kind of album that somehow sounds wrong on MP3.

And the music? Brilliant, both instantly familiar and neoteric. The album's sole nuts-out riff fest, "Die", will probably be described as Zeppelinesque by quite a few people, but its riff actually feels more like Wolfmother's "Woman" and Muse's "Knights of Cyndonia" than anything recorded before 2000, and its melody is catchy enough to overshadow the bridge, which hints at Pink Floyd. "My Ma" has a wistfulness that instantly recalls Elliott Smith, but can be traced further back to The Byrds and The Beatles, with a guitar solo that could have been on a Bowie song. "Vomit" takes it listener on an exhausting journey first time out, collapsing out of its atmospheric arpeggios into noisy, scuzzy garage rock, before pulling itself back together for just long enough to escalate into a wave of soulful female vocals and organs that doesn't sound all that much like "The Great Gig in the Sky", but recalls it anyway - oh, and there's room for another guitar solo too, this time with more of a country influence. (And is it just me, or does the melody just carry the tiniest hint of The Cure's "Lovesong" about it?)

And yet for all these half-memories of other songs that Girls conjure, it sounds bang up-to-date. A big part of that is the song structures, which often change up completely half-way through; it's a path that's been well-trodden by the likes of Arcade Fire, Coldplay, and Muse in recent years, but barely anybody has done it as well as Girls do here. Yet a lot of it is a simple matter of energy and, dare I say it, honesty; Owens at his best is a gloriously unrestrained frontman, both in his performance and his writing. There's something really charming about a songwriter that's as happy to include lyrics as silly as 'they don't like my bony body/they don't like my dirty hands' as he is to sing something as sincere as 'maybe I didn't realize the way I loved the way you moved, until you moved so far away I couldn't see you anymore', not to mention a man that's willing to write two openly positive songs about his mother while working in a genre that places more emphasis than most on how cool you act.

One of the best thing about following music is being proven wrong, so I'm happy to say that Father, Son, Holy Ghost makes me look foolish - despite liking Album, I never, ever imagined Girls would be anywhere near this good. I didn't even think they'd make it to a third album, if I'm being honest, yet suddenly they sound like they'll probably end up being one of the most enduring bands of our era. I'm always happy to admit that I'm wrong though, as long as I can have albums as brilliant as this in return.



Recent reviews by this author
Krzysztof Penderecki and Jonny Greenwood Krzysztof Penderecki / Jonny GreenwoodLana Del Rey Paradise
Scott Walker Bish BoschEmilie Autumn Fight Like A Girl
Susanne Sundfor The Silicone VeilPepe Deluxe Queen of the Wave
user ratings (237)
Chart.
3.8
excellent
other reviews of this album
Ali CONTRIBUTOR (4)
A triumphent sophomore which will fuel the fans and quell the critics....


Comments:Add a Comment 
Iai
Emeritus
November 29th 2011


3553 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Hooray for embarrassing nonsensical fanboy ramblings about a band you didn't even like all that much until last week!

killrobotmusic
November 29th 2011


670 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Great review. This is easily one of the top albums of 2011 and this album has seemed to be pretty under the radar on this site up until now.

HBFS
November 29th 2011


1262 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

still has 87 votes which is quite a bit for an album that's gone 'under the radar'

PorkchopExpress
November 29th 2011


387 Comments


Wow, I had no idea the overall site rating for this had dropped to a 3.7

Not that a 3.7 is a low score, but I seriously think this is one of the top five albums of the year. Anyway, great review.

AggravatedYeti
November 29th 2011


7685 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

loved their debut so much more but this record bodes for a more positive future I'd say.

klap
Staff Reviewer
November 29th 2011


10499 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

about time

Digging: Caribou - Our Love

greg84
Staff Reviewer
November 29th 2011


7421 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

I found this album massively overrated and overhyped. This is just dull for the most part.

Digging: Dope Body - Lifer

Enotron
November 29th 2011


7695 Comments


yessssss niiiicck butttleeerrr

robertsona
Staff Reviewer
November 29th 2011


15051 Comments


alex has blue eyes well who cares

psykonaut
November 29th 2011


3913 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

excellent review up in here

Wildcatforever
November 29th 2011


441 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0 | Sound Off

Love the album and love the review. Good work man.

Digging: Foxygen - ...And Star Power

ohfoxxxycole
November 29th 2011


4353 Comments


CD is so boring

jimmykidd
November 30th 2011


532 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

great review. love this album.

Aids
Contributing Reviewer
November 30th 2011


23909 Comments


never really liked this band, but this is apparently way better than their other stuff so maybe I should give it a shot

but yeah probably not. good review though!

Digging: RATKING - So It Goes

iFghtffyrdmns
November 30th 2011


7047 Comments


broken dreams club bored me to death. think i'll avoid this. nice write up and all though, not bad for a blatant fanboy

lancebramsay
November 30th 2011


1585 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

die has such a massive transition at the midway point, love it so much.

PINK FLOYD LIKE CHORDS

Itwasthatwas
November 30th 2011


770 Comments


This is surprisingly good, hated broken dreams club so I didn't expect to like this at all.

Activista anti-MTV
November 30th 2011


3146 Comments


"Each song has a tune you can hum, a lyric somebody somewhere will probably get tattooed, and a musical twist to keep repeated listens as enthralling as the first, and what more can you really ask for from a pop or rock album?"

Why I listen Girls' albums and Nick Butler album review

Blind
December 1st 2011


427 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

the end of vomit is like the best thing ever but the rest of this is just good

EarLobeRobe
December 4th 2011


2 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Surprised that no one has pointed out how much "Die" resembles "Highway Star" by Deep Purple.

Still, great album.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy