Abandon All Ships
Geeving


1.0
awful

Review

by Andrew Caswell USER (51 Reviews)
October 14th, 2010 | 187 replies | 22,529 views


Release Date: 2010 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Titanic meet iceberg.

11 of 11 thought this review was well written

The idiotic crabcore tale began when some anonymous person made a wikipedia page about how the stage moves portrayed in Attack Attack's now infamous music video were similar to that of a crab. The label from then on was meshed with a strange upheaval of dance meets core and the rest is history. The internet trolls and scene kids of the world equally rejoiced as a new obnoxious trend was born. The overhyped craze soon sprouted instant knock offs for revenue and that's where Toronto, Ontario's europop/trance infused metalcore act Abandon All Ships ties in. I normally am one to preach about not judging a book by its cover before you view its content but for this occasion you can make an exception.

There are basically only two redeeming factors for those who enjoy passable electronics and catchy hooks as the band manages to bring a believable rave like atmosphere in certain sections. Unfortunately that's where the praise ends as the other musicians never seem to venture past what has become expected of Rise Records. I’m perplexed with the singing/screaming duo of bassist Martin Broda and frontman Angelo Aita. It's obvious that the overbearing auto-tune Martin uses is one hundred percent unnecessary and is used as a complete crutch . Angelo, on the other side, is grating because I can't understand how he can settle for such apathetic mid tempo growls with absolutely no stamina.

There's no doubt the lyrical material nearly sends the albums mindless fun factor straight down to sheer comedy laughs. First off, none of lines make a damn bit of sense when mashed together in song form. Martin opts for the sweet lovesick sentiments towards a special someone but then Angelo professes violent disgust in a derogatory fashion. In ‘When Dreams Become Nightmares’ it travels from hoarse threats, "You'll burn in hell, you ***ing whore" straight into gentle reassurance, "Baby, don't cry, don't scream." It comes off like a Dr. Jekyll/Mr. Hyde complex that refuses to mesh and is tremendously insufferable.

I first caught wind of this band through the MuchMusic program "disBAND" and was immediately turned off by seeing a bunch of Canadian guidos with Kanye West sized egos. It's worse enough they were the biggest disrespectful tools to every professional that tried to hand them helpful advice. I knew from that point on Abandon All Ships would never be accepted but it'd be entertaining to watch their piss poor attitudes erupt with an inevitable backlash. I'm confident people will send Geeving sinking down in critical flames because there's nothing more tiring than watching spoiled brats boringly shovel a product they don't even buy.



Recent reviews by this author
The Here and Now Born to Make Believe Part 1Fall Out Boy Save Rock and Roll
The Distillers Coral FangKeyes Therefore/Without
Chris Gaines Greatest HitsChunk! No, Captain Chunk! Something For Nothing
user ratings (355)
Chart.
2
poor
other reviews of this album
Travis McKenzie (3.5)
Abandon All Ships is a decent band and Geeving is a great 1st album to kickstart their career. This ...

thechodewarrior (2)
Attack Attack's younger, less annoying Canadian brother....

DropdeadWHA (1.5)
Abandon All Ships! are back and once again they've sunk the ship, this time only deeper.......

Chris Higgins (3)
A very generic and laughable album, yet so fun....


Comments:Add a Comment 
sspedding
October 14th 2010



4448 Comments

Album Rating: 1.0

isnt a hardcore band - is metalcore. Other than that, very good.

EDIT: The review.

Digging: TesseracT - Altered State

andcas
October 14th 2010



57814 Comments


I rushed this one out so I'm gonna go back and shorten things up.




Digging: Faith No More - The Real Thing

sspedding
October 14th 2010



4448 Comments

Album Rating: 1.0

i tend to view long reviews as a good thing because it allows you to go into lots of detail. Pos'd for you.

andcas
October 14th 2010



57814 Comments


I tend to try to go into enough detail to get the idea of it all.




sspedding
October 14th 2010



4448 Comments

Album Rating: 1.0

Keep to them guidelines and you shouldn't ever receive negative feedback because you obviously write quite well. You also don't see many reviews written in first person, I don't know where I stand with it but it at least adds variation.

andcas
October 14th 2010



57814 Comments


thanks for the feedback. how do you feel about the album?

sspedding
October 14th 2010



4448 Comments

Album Rating: 1.0

Not listened to it in its entirety. Find the autotuned cleans obnoxious. I couldn't say until later, sounds like a 2.

andcas
October 14th 2010



57814 Comments


well if you hate auto-tune then you're gonna rate this low.






PinkBlackberry
October 14th 2010



2346 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

Heyyyy Andcas. Fuckin' monster review, seriously.

Gonna gib joo a pos :3

AbyssalCreation
October 14th 2010



2004 Comments


The title Bro My God makes me groan.Pretty sure this is gonna be the next flavor of the week band
that most my friends and other scene kids will worship.

sspedding
October 14th 2010



4448 Comments

Album Rating: 1.0

i dunno, it probably isnt even good enough for that.

andcas
October 14th 2010



57814 Comments


cool deal PinkBlackberry.

bloc
October 14th 2010



32272 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Pretty fun album

Digging: Queens of the Stone Age - ...Like Clockwork

andcas
October 14th 2010



57814 Comments


I'd say only the choruses.

bloc
October 14th 2010



32272 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

True, but album definitely turned out better than what I was expecting.

andcas
October 14th 2010



57814 Comments


I'm sure you'll soon find yourself in the minority lol.




Apollo
October 14th 2010



9453 Comments


I'm completely convinced that the blatant auto-tune is one-hundred percent unnecessary and unlike most bands who use it as a crutch to mask the singer can't carry a pitch to save his life I do not see that being the case for this guy and think he'd be fine with doing without but a gimmick is a gimmick.

massive run on sentence but great review dude

BRO MY GAWD

Digging: Erlen Meyer - Erlen Meyer

andcas
October 14th 2010



57814 Comments


I'm gonna clean up some things later on apollo.



LG
October 14th 2010



3033 Comments


Ewww, I feel dirty even lookin at this review.

andcas
October 14th 2010



57814 Comments


don't let the crab people get you.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2013 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy

IndieClick Music Network