Nirvana
Nirvana


3.5
great

Review

by Adam Downer STAFF
October 12th, 2005 | 164 replies


Release Date: 2002 | Tracklist


I'd like to start by telling you all something about Nirvana that you never knew before.... ummm.... hold on..... Well screw it, you guys know everything about Nirvana anyway. 8 years after Kurt Cobain's suicide (eh hem, "murder") Krist and Dave got back together, two fully successful musicians, Dave with the Foo Fighters, Garbage, Queens of the Stone Age and Krist with..... ok so Dave, the fully successful musician, and Krist got back together to put out a Nirvana Greatest Hits album. The end result is a career spanning, though average Greatest Hits cd, from a fantastic band.

1. You Know You're Right

You Know You're Right is the only song on here previously unreleased. And it's worth it. Kurt mumbles the verse, with that northwest drawl that would come to be copied by many bands to come (Like Seether). All is quiet until the tension mounting line "Things have never been so swell/I have never felt or fell", then all hell breaks loose into the chorus with "Pain!" It's a song that, when you consider what happened a few months later, symbolizes Kurt Cobain at the time. The second verse is even better with Kurt screaming the "Things have never been so swell" line. Dave's drumming is great, and Krist's basswork is pretty easy and average. The real credit here goes to Kurt's voice.


****BLEACH****


2. About a Girl

The "First Great song Kurt wrote" is a Beatles inspired tune, found on Bleach, and not much to gawk at. Mumbled verses, as usual, but no fun chorus that has become the best part of Nirvana's work. The solo is the best part, with Dave riding on a tambourine and Kurt putting a Bealtes-esque guitar riff over it. Easy guitar part, but good work done from Dave and Krist in the rhythym section.


****INCESTICIDE****


3. Been A Son

The only song I consistently skip, Been A Son is a boring, song with nothing special at all. Dave pens it, which is an unexpected change, but I've always hated his voice. The solo is good, with distortion and jumpyness, but it's too short. The song sounds like it was recorded in a Tin Can as well. Probably the worst song off Incesticide to put on the Greatest Hits album.

4. Sliver

Kurt's lament about a night at his grandmother's, it starts off with some excellent bass, and then explodes into the chorus. The song slowly builds up with each verse being much better than the last, especially when Kurt sings in the next octive of his voice. It's a short 2 minutes, and not one of the highlights of the album, but the better of the two Incesticide Songs.


****NEVERMIND****


5. Smells Like Teen Spirit

If you've never heard this song, then you need to hear it. Right now. This is the revolutionary song of the Nineties, the reason your listening to Green Day, Sum 41, and other alt-rock bands out there. Everything about this song is classic Nirvana. The mumbled verses, the 4 chord riff, the tom roll that is now copied by every drummer at one point or another. Oh and of course, The Famous Chorus. The scream that came to define a generation. It's impossible to copy Kurt's voice in this (Believe me I tried. I failed miserably). The solo drags, but it's really not noticeable. Perfection in a 4 chord epic.

6. Come As You Are

Chances are you've heard this song. You probably know it by heart. That watery bass intro, the gentle basic beat behind it, and Kurt's voice just being raw emotion as usual. Blink 182 actually nicked a line from this song "Take your time/Hurry Up/ The choice is yours don't be late" can be found with a very small variation in "Adam's Song" Excellent work done all around by everyone. Solo is repetetive, but then again, most Nirvana songs are. Beats the Unplugged Version.

7. Lithium

Starting with a gentle bass Intro, Lithium is the closest thing to a ballad to be found in the Nevermind section of the hits. Oddly, you can understand everything Kurt says, and his drawl found in the last 6 songs is much less noticeable. The lyrics are funny at times (I'm so horny/That's ok my will is good). The Anthematic "Yeah" is the best part of the song. The song dies in the bridge, which is a real downer (haha), but is followed by a bass solo, which is greatly appreciated. It outstays it's welcome though.

8. In Bloom

A booming guitar-drum roll intro starts this song. But then it all drops out with Kurt singing the verse by himself (well, with Krist and Dave). The second verse contains my favorite line of all time "We can add some more/Nature is a whore." Great harmonies by Dave, a rarity in itself. The chorus outlines Kurt's obsession with guns, and it sounds ver hard, almost powerful. The drum work here is to be commended, so nice job Dave. The solo is weird, with the bottom dropping out over the distortion guitar riff. A Nevermind Classic, along with SLTS and Lithium.


****IN UTERO****


9. Heart Shaped Box

Heart Shaped Box is a quieter, far darker song than anything found on Nevermind. Starting with that creepy guitar, and the mumbled pure passion verses, It announced that In Utero was not your Happy Go Boom Nevermind again. The chorus is unlike anything done by Nirvana before with Kurt screaming "Hey! Wait!". The solo is another bottom-drops-out effort and it works with the dark feeling of the song. Lyrics are weird and regard cancer eating, cutting yourself on Angel Hair, and zodiac signs (namely Pisces).

10. Pennroyal Tea

I like the way this song begins. Kurt singing melancholy words over the forlorn guitar. The verses are short, and lead directly into the chorus. The chorus has some great harmony work done by Dave, and the guitar is very clean. I don't know how to explain it, but i just love how it sounds. It's another sad song about nothing in particular, but once again Kurts emotion churns through. Hands down better than the Unplugged Version.

11. Rape Me

I originally thought this song was bland and boring, but i grew to like it. It starts with some 4 chord progressions similar to SLTS, and uses words like "Rape Me/Rape Me My Friend". The "chorus" is something strange and is easily forgettable. The bridge is what makes the song. Kurt's sliding vocals are something great. The song ends with Kurt Screaming RAPE ME at the top of his lungs. It's a sad song, as were most of the songs on In Utero, but it was a gem.

12. Dumb

A slow song, Dumb uses Cello which is an immediate change. This one goes into the too depressing zone, and I'm not really a fan of it. It has some great vocal work done, but it has no catchy melody. Dave's drums are too loud over the gentle words of Kurt. The end drags on for far too long with the repeating line "I think I'm Dumb". Slow and depressing, Dumb fails to do it for me.


****MTV UNPLUGGED IN NEW YORK****


13. All Apologies

While I am more of a fan of the In Utero Version, All Apologies is the only ballad that really made it big during Nirvana's career. The voices are strained, as would be expected during a live performance, but it leaves sort of a passionate edge to them that were not found on the In Utero version. The cello gives the song a subliminally dark attitude, which adds greatly to the song's live aura. The end drags on, and I was never a fan of that. Although it's worth the wait to get to Dave's harmonies at the end when he's alone with Kurt. Fantastic song.

14. The Man Who Sold the World

My favorite song off this cd, The Man Who Sold the World is a David Bowie song, that Nirvana Owns. The sliding guitar at the beginning, compiled with fantastic basswork done by Krist, leads into a great Definining Nirvana song. The way Kurt more or less hums the words leave the audience with an impression that he had not grown cynical or silly with fame, but rather wiser, seeing the world for what it is. Krist's scale done on bass is a melodic mark of excellence, giving the chorus an edge. The end is great, with that sad, hopeful guitar leading the way. This song is genius. Own's David Bowie's version. A perfect ending to a Greatest Hits album.

OVERALL

This is the perfect solution for any person looking to get into Nirvana. It has everything one might want from the band. There are all the classics, along with some hidden surprises. If all these songs were on one studio album, then I'd undoubtedly give this a 5. But it's a greatest hits, and really all the works been done. A buy for any person who's Nirvana collection doesnt include everything Nirvana's done.

Recommended Songs:

You Know You're Right
Smells Like Teen Spirit
The Man Who Sold the World

Pros:

Excellent songs, as would be expected from any Nirvana Album.
Most of the songs are recognizable.
As far as greatest hits cd's go, this one was above average.

Cons

Been A Son
Needed "Where Did You Sleep Last Night" off of the MTV Unplugged album on the US version.

Please Rate and Reply :-)



Recent reviews by this author
Beach Slang Cheap Thrills On A Dead End StreetThe Men Tomorrow's Hits
Macintosh Plus FLORAL SHOPPEThe Dismemberment Plan Uncanney Valley
Justin Timberlake The 20/20 ExperienceThe Men New Moon
user ratings (780)
Chart.
3.8
excellent
other reviews of this album
Spamue1G (4.5)
This album contains some of the most powerful moments in music history, but isn't really worth buyin...

Bron-Yr-Aur (3)
...

CobainsGuitarPlayer (4.5)
...


Comments:Add a Comment 
Thor
October 12th 2005


10202 Comments


Pretty good review, and I agree with your rating.

Digging: Black Crown Initiate - The Wreckage of Stars

kolzig33189
October 12th 2005


335 Comments


good review but i would have given it a 4 or 4.5

Electric City
Staff Reviewer
October 12th 2005


15743 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Like I said, I would have given it a 5 if it was a studio album, but the work was done. There was no real incentive for me to give it a 5, as the only new thing on it was You Know You're Right.

kolzig33189
October 12th 2005


335 Comments


^^^true

CmS
October 12th 2005


19 Comments


I thought "Where Did You Sleep Last Night" did appear on it

Edit: Oh, US version...NevermindThis Message Edited On 10.12.05

pulseczar
October 12th 2005


2385 Comments


the album's name is INCESTICIDE not insecticide.

Electric City
Staff Reviewer
October 12th 2005


15743 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

O my mistake. I'll change it now

Jawaharal
October 12th 2005


1832 Comments


nirvana is poop

Storm In A Teacup
October 12th 2005


13228 Comments


You changed it from Insecticide to Insesticide, but it should be Incesticide.

Just pointing it out, not trying to be mean or anything, good reveiw also.

umbilical_mind
October 12th 2005


1 Comments


nice review. and yeah i think a 4 does it justice.

rustysurf84
October 12th 2005


327 Comments


good review.. but this sorta shows the "pop" side of nirvana
if you like this, listen to the whole bleach album etc.. thats really the sound nirvana was goin for

and nice dis on krist lol


ergodyneuser
October 12th 2005


4 Comments

Album Rating: 1.0

worst best of ever

Electric City
Staff Reviewer
October 12th 2005


15743 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

You changed it from Insecticide to Insesticide, but it should be Incesticide.

Just pointing it out, not trying to be mean or anything, good reveiw also.




^^DAMMIT! lol.

Apathy
October 12th 2005


645 Comments


Good review. All my friends like Nirvana, but I can't seem to get into them.

Chewy12345
October 12th 2005


37 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

my cd doesn't have number 15.

Electric City
Staff Reviewer
October 12th 2005


15743 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

You should try man. This is the album for it definately. Nirvana are rock gods.

Chewy12345
October 12th 2005


37 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

the cd i have only goes to 14.

Electric City
Staff Reviewer
October 12th 2005


15743 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Me as well. We're Americans.... we dont get the bonus kick ass tracks....

bassx901
October 13th 2005


13 Comments

Album Rating: 1.0

dude.............this sux. i hate it when people write reviews. they think that they are f***ing rock history buffs. how can u say that dave ghrol invented the tom roll??? have you ever LISTEDED to any 80s metal?? u are a dumb f***. sure, nirvana did help to revolutionize the music industry in the early 90s but how can u say that they alone did it. there were MANY MANY bands to come out of that genre that were just as successful. for example......Pearl Jam out sold Nirvana with their album ten. think about what u are telling people dumb f***.

Electric City
Staff Reviewer
October 13th 2005


15743 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Ok first off, I don't pretend to be an expert on Nirvana. I'm a fan, but I only have 3 albums. I never said Dave invented the Tom Roll in SLTS. I said it's been copied many times, and this song is what made it more accessible to kids who were fans of real music instead of lets-see-how-fast-you-can-pick 80's hair metal.

To your second point, Smells Like Teen Spirit was the first song of alt rock to make it big. It made alt rock accessible to many other bands out there.

And if you hate when people write reviews, then get the fuck off this site.

Have a nice fuckin day. ;-)



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy