The Dismemberment Plan Change

  full reviewuser ratings (82) 
Tracklist:
"Sentimental Man"
"The Face of The Earth"
"Superpowers"
"Pay for the Piano"
"Come Home"
"Secret Curse"
"Automatic"
"Following Through"
"Time Bomb"
"The Other Side"
"Ellen And Ben"

Ranking: #36 for 2001

user rating
4.2
excellent
Chart.

related




  On 26 Lists

4.0
excellent
Robin Smith STAFF

April 1st, 2010 | 47 replies | 8,097 views

Summary: Travis Morrison should play the lottery if he's such a know-it-all.

I don’t like for things to be uncanny, but then again there is something uncanny about the way Change walks which both baffles and contents me. It's an album abundantly removed from the isolating, apocalyptic themes of their Indie masterpiece Emergency & I but somehow creeping and crawling with the same paranoid feelings it sends out. Okay, some of the songs have colossal scope – “Pay for the Piano” is typically high-stakes for the band and all the speedy drumming and grungy guitars could easily call for political reforms (“Somebody’s got to pay for the piano/Somebody’s got to make sure we honor everyone” ) – but this isn’t end of the world stuff. So why exactly does every song on Change make me anxious that Travis Morrison is coming to town?

Such a question isn’t really answered in the absolutes its predecessor was because in 2001, The Dismemberment Plan isn’t really driving towards a specific and devastating ending, let alone a revolution. Even if “Pay for the Piano” is eerie and universal, the band lets that very same tone loose for the remainder of ten songs, no matter how diverse they are for subject matter. “Come Home” takes the album’s mood and makes a loner of Morrison, recycling what spoke to our generation just a song ago and instead putting listeners through the frontman’s dearth of personal experience. On the face of it, he’s relatable, but in actual fact the only person that matters in this moment is Morrison and Morrison alone: “Made myself some coffee and listened to the rain rattle the leaves/I told myself nothing is wrong and stared through the paper for a long long time”. And enough cannot be said of how stricken with paranoia he is – the song explodes from its sparse dynamic into something explosive and jittery with much credit to Joe Easley’s drumming prowess – his fragmented smattering of percussion can only say as much as Morrison does himself though, which is quite simply “I don’t know”. Two songs into the future and the Plan have reinvented their own wheel again, but even as the band twist and turn heads with “Automatic” – which is as good as an acoustic lullaby, especially for a band this proud and prone to freak outs – they still can’t calculate anything but the cold and nerve-wracking, and Morrison’s lyrical outlook oozes bleakness; where verses stand in this man’s way, he will simply overflow with words.

Enough can be said of that restraining and dark album mood, though, because this album lives and dies by its absolutely gorgeous instrumentation. And there is definitely no schedule to this aspect of the album – Change defines sporadic, and in the best way possible too. “The Other Side”, for a best example, has no structure to speak of and sounds the sums of its parts in some unexplainable and excellent way – the drums sound sliced out of the song and then in again, the guitars have no place that isn’t for their own sake and Morrison’s vocals sound as if they’re going a’capella when they aren’t – as if that isn’t enough, it actually all fits perfectly. Nearly every song does its best to meander into known and unknown territory in the same stroke, with “Superpowers”, “The Face of The Earth” the most obvious (from their synth foundations to their guitar rock implosions), and “Ellen and Ben” the grooviest, laying down the most monotonous tale possible with glitchy and geeky musical interplay not shy of the experimental storytelling The Velvet Underground would go in for – a modern “The Gift”, minus the majority of its creepy aftertaste.

So basically, Change is a lot of change happening both within the band and out of it - and no, Travis Morrison isn’t best pleased.

Share: Facebook Stumble Digg!Digg Twitter Del.icio.us


Recent reviews by this author
mewithoutYou Ten Stories
Best Coast The Only Place
Moonface With Siinai: Heartbreaking Bravery
Ghost Mice All We Got Is Each Other
Maps & Atlases Beware and Be Grateful
Okkervil River The Stage Names

Comments:Add a Comment 
pianotuna
Staff Reviewer
April 1st 2010



3573 Comments


none of the above makes any sense, i apologise.

Digging: toe - The Book About My Idle Plot on a Vague Anxiety

klap4music
Staff Reviewer
April 1st 2010



6986 Comments


who is robin smith

Digging: Simian Mobile Disco - Unpatterns

Digging: Simian Mobile Disco - Unpatterns

pianotuna
Staff Reviewer
April 1st 2010



3573 Comments


who is ryan loomba?

redskyformiles
Staff Reviewer
April 1st 2010



15714 Comments


who is ryan loomba?
this

Digging: Love American - Disquiet

Digging: Love American - Disquiet

klap4music
Staff Reviewer
April 1st 2010



6986 Comments


wow guys my personal relationship is PERSONAL

SeaAnemone
April 1st 2010



13673 Comments


I need this? I need this. ps this review is fantastic, you knew that already though.

robertsona
Contributing Reviewer
April 1st 2010



12838 Comments


holy fuck yes reading brb

Observer
Emeritus
April 1st 2010



4869 Comments


listening to this today, actually

great review

Digging: Andrew Bird - Break It Yourself

Digging: Andrew Bird - Break It Yourself

pianotuna
Staff Reviewer
April 1st 2010



3573 Comments


klap4tabloids

robertsona
Contributing Reviewer
April 1st 2010



12838 Comments


"An album abundantly removed from the isolating, apocalyptic themes of their Indie masterpiece Emergency & I but somehow creeping and crawling with the same paranoid feelings it sends out."

kind of a sentence frag, i guess? idk

"and Morrison’s lyrical outlook literally oozes bleakness"

sorry but why 'literally' haha i dont think it's -literally- oozing bleakness?

"“The Face of The Earth” the must obvious"

most = must*?


overall fantabulous review and i LOVE this album

Observer
Emeritus
April 1st 2010



4869 Comments


so these guys still together?

pianotuna
Staff Reviewer
April 1st 2010



3573 Comments


lol at those grammatical failures. thankyou for the helpful wurds.

i think morrison retired from music, observer.

Observer
Emeritus
April 1st 2010



4869 Comments


shame, this and emergency are great so far.

review for this was very needed

Minus The Flair
Staff Reviewer
April 1st 2010



843 Comments


i was totally gonna review this you bitch. woah that lie was so transparent it hurt. thank god you're here to actually review the things that i need to review, and review them better.

also, just to check with you, at the end of the latest lost, is that desmond? keepin' on topic guys.

pianotuna
Staff Reviewer
April 1st 2010



3573 Comments


youre lucky i just wrapped up watching it an hour ago you bitch. it was totally des, but i still have a sneaking suspicion they just wont come back to him for another 8 episodes or so. was it just me or was that episode just one big banter session? p.s. < 3

Minus The Flair
Staff Reviewer
April 1st 2010



843 Comments


haha i hope i spoil it for someone who hasn't seen it yet. but yeah, whole episode was a bit of a dissapointment. the ones with the jin and sun usually are, despite how fucking awesome jin is and strangely hot sun is (that scene in the hotel - jackpot). i guess they can't reveal shit every episode though (though they really should cos I'M GETTING ANGRY).

more on topic, has anyone heard travis morrison's solo record, travistan? i actually haven't but pitchfork gave it a 0.0(!) so, through the power of fantastically negative press, i've been curious to check it out.

pianotuna
Staff Reviewer
April 1st 2010



3573 Comments


i actually dug the whole banterous aspect of it, esp the ben illana scene. basically, lockes camp is boring as shit and illana's camp is where the party is at. but yeah, sun is pretty cute. i wish they would make claires character more like she was in season 4 (which was when she was better looking than all those others in that she didn't sweat as much as them), and also that they'd stop INTRODUCING NEW CHARACTERS. ugh. also i miss juliet going back to the claire/sun line of thought

also yeah i saw that and was hmm i guess i should like that album to prove a point.

Minus The Flair
Staff Reviewer
April 1st 2010



843 Comments


claire (pre-sweaty crazy bitch)=hot
sun=cute
juliet=come back ily
that girl with glasses=GET THE FUCK OFF MY LOST

pianotuna
Staff Reviewer
April 1st 2010



3573 Comments


we share the same dream, matt.

robertsona
Contributing Reviewer
April 1st 2010



12838 Comments


drusm for otherside are so sick



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Site Copyright 2005-2012 Sputnikmusic.com
All Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy