Cannibal Corpse
Butchered at Birth


2.5
average

Review

by JohnnyGetYerKnife USER (19 Reviews)
December 13th, 2009 | 15 replies | 5,432 views


Release Date: 1991 | Tracklist

Review Summary: The same generic, boring, mediocre crap all over again...

5 of 7 thought this review was well written

Personally, the gorier subgenre of death metal was always at its best when bands didn't take it too seriously. The genre had always featured bands that excelled at speed and sheer brutality, but there was a time when it was fun too. Taken Cannibal Corpse's debut, Eaten Back To Life. That album was evil, and despite some production issues, pretty brutal in places too. It was proof that Cannibal Corpse showed the much needed potential to write nasty songs about car crashes and maggot-filled body parts whilst still selling albums. But somewhere along the line, someone came under the impression that the viler the subject matter, the better the album. Thus began the perpetual gross-out war that continues to rage to this day: legions of death metallers attempting to outdo one another with tales of grotesque violence and obscene perversion, racing to see who can get banned from which country for what reason. The music is not important now, it's just to see who can write the goriest lyrics. And who's to blame for this trend? It seems that Cannibal Corpse may be one of the prime suspects.

Cannibal Corpse, really, are no more homicidal than Venom were Satanic, no more than Motely Crue were transvestites. Butchered At Birth was so notorious that it was infamously banned in Germany, as well as other countries due to its lyrical content and album artwork. The album even gained a cult following due to the lyrics, and with tracks entitled Meat Hook Sodomy and Butchered At Birth, it's not hard to see why. But I don't orgasm over the lyrics or the musical content, like I usually do. My problem with this album is that the band was so concerned with making it brutal that they forgot to make it listenable, or, as Jack Black said in School Of Rock they forgot about one little thing... It's called the music!

Cannibal Corpse could write nastier songs about raping dead fetuses and slitting the throat of the dead mother whilst masturbating over her corpse and still sell album. But, this time, they took it to a new level by trying to do it without a solid sound to back up their lyrics. Oh, did they fail... They failed miserably. I can count the interesting riffs from this whole album on one hand. Bob and Jack dish out nearly thirty-six minutes of bland, boring riffage, with a few exceptions. It seems that, on this album, neither one can write a decent solo. And, honestly, this would be a half decent album if it weren't for the production. Bands like Destruction and Kreator had the brutal, balls-out-raw albums just a few years before this. Perhaps it was the crap production, not the lyrics nor album art that got this banned in Germany! The two loudest things on the entire album are the near minute and a half of guitar noises that open Meat Hook Sodomy and the terrible snare sound, which is constantly being sounded. Alex Webster, the most talented member of the entire band, cannot be heard without straining a trained ear through the ensuing wall of noise. And that leaves us with only Chris Barnes to comment on. And he sucks, delivering his vocals in a deeper death growl than on the debut, he delivers his lyrics thoughtlessly, making them undecipherable without a lyric sheet. The only time the vocals don't suck is when Glen Benton steps in as a guest on Vomit The Soul. But, aside from that section, Barnes is unbearable, unaggressive, monotonous, like the rest of the album, and boring.

This is boring and generic. Cannibal Corpse try and remake their debut, but end up creating a pitifully mediocre, boring slap of death metal that suffers also from repetition. And with but a handful of unique riffs hardly worth hunting for, it’s pretty much lacking in redeeming value as well. Stick with Eaten Back To Life; at least there they still had a sense of humour and an ear for a memorable riff.



Recent reviews by this author
Suffocation The Close of a ChapterCircle Takes the Square As the Roots Undo
Satanic Destroyer CorruptionDark Funeral Attero Totus Sanctus
Bathory OctagonTiamat A Deeper Kind of Slumber
user ratings (548)
Chart.
3.6
great
other reviews of this album
ScuroFantasma (4)
A choice cutlet....

Aaron Arneson CONTRIBUTOR (4)
Prepare to be butchered....

lospokey (4)
...

Dominic (4)
...


Comments:Add a Comment 
JohnnyGetYerKnife
December 13th 2009



157 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

So, Cannibal Corpse. Feedback please.

PuerkitoBio
December 13th 2009



60 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Wow that's a bad review. I mean you have the right to rate this ridiculously low (and ignore the fact that this is among a handful of old school DM albums that defined the sound of the genre), but to pretend that they did take themselves seriously is not knowing much about the guys (frankly, Meat Hook Sodomy, don't you think there's some humour in there?), and saying "Cannibal Corpse try and remake their debut" proves you don't know much about how this CD came to life. Their debut was thrash with a death growl. Even CC admit this (check their 20-year history DVD). This one is start to finish Death Metal.

XulOnerom
December 13th 2009



1818 Comments


The review was well written. Maybe calling this "generic" was a little farfetched because CC were pioneers of the genre. But this by no means is a bad review. Counter pos'ing. And I agree, Chris Barnes is a shitty vocalist

Anthracks
December 13th 2009



3733 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

ya this was their first (brutal) death metal album. their first was thrashy from what i remember

Digging: Devangelic - Resurrection Denied

PuerkitoBio
December 13th 2009



60 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying this is badly written (english is not my native tongue, I wouldn't dare), I'm saying the reviewer didn't do much research to appreciate the album in its historical context.

Eakflanderyof
December 13th 2009



2143 Comments


Yeah, even if a review is well-written, not having your facts straight makes it bad.

wutangpootang
December 13th 2009



97 Comments


I like this album, good review though

Asiatic667
December 13th 2009



4648 Comments


just too disgusting for me

MetalMassacreAttack
December 13th 2009



424 Comments


Your overall description of the album sounded like a 1.5, yet you rated it 2.5....

Tokyochuchu
December 13th 2009



62 Comments


Meat Hook Sodomy. The song titles of death metal tunes always make me laugh. I peruse them just for fun in HMV sometimes.... Wouldn't be caught dead actually listening to it, though. Just not my cup of tea, I'm afraid.

Nice review, btw.

TheSpirit
December 14th 2009



17695 Comments


Motely Crue were transvestites



Motley.







Digging: Venus Star - Nigredo Expulsion

YUJOS
February 26th 2012



916 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

Vey good review man! Pos'd

Mabbitt
February 14th 2013



1350 Comments


The part I don't understand is how you spend the whole review saying how bad the music is, and then you say that the album wouldn't be that bad if the production was better.

Digging: Rx Bandits - Gemini, Her Majesty

Shuyin
February 14th 2013



11465 Comments


good review, pos

but FUCK YOU cuz CC

Digging: Integral - Sercosa

DreamingWithTheDead
July 30th 2013



207 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

I quite like the 'Lets just be brutal, fuck the music' approach.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy